Table 3.
Effects of year, cultivar, and levels of NPK on nitrogen accumulation (kg ha–1) in different plant organs at different growth stages and on nitrogen harvest index of maize.
Treatments | At silking | At physiological maturity | Post-silking N accumulation | HI(N)† | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Leaf | Stalk | Total | Leaf | Stalk | Grain | Total | |||||
Stem | Tassel | Stem | Other | ||||||||
Year | |||||||||||
Year 1 | 51.5a | 55.6a | 7.66a | 114.8a | 44.2b | 15.6b | 9.21a | 114.8a | 183.8b | 69.0b | 0.64a |
Year 2 | 51.6a | 54.8b | 7.68a | 114.1a | 52.4a | 22.0a | 9.20a | 118.2a | 201.8a | 87.7a | 0.58b |
Cultivar | |||||||||||
P3522 | 63.3a | 59.4a | 3.9c | 126.7a | 49.6a | 14.7c | 7.2b | 122.2a | 193.7a | 67.0b | 0.63a |
P3396 | 42.9c | 54.6b | 7.4b | 105.0c | 47.7a | 18.7b | 10.3a | 118.6a | 195.4a | 90.4a | 0.61a |
Rajkumar | 48.3b | 51.7b | 11.7a | 111.7b | 47.6a | 23.0a | 10.1a | 108.7b | 189.4a | 77.8ab | 0.58a |
Levels of NPK | |||||||||||
N100P30K30 (50% RDF) | 49.6e | 42.2e | 6.8ef | 98.5d | 50.0cd | 15.8de | 8.0d | 118.1cd | 191.8e | 93.3bc | 0.61ab |
N150P45K45 (75% RDF) | 58.1cd | 55.7d | 8.0cd | 121.9c | 53.7bc | 18.7d | 10.1c | 129.3bc | 211.9d | 90.0bc | 0.61ab |
N200P60K60 (100% RDF) | 64.8ab | 71.6c | 8.9bc | 145.2b | 60.0b | 23.2c | 11.6b | 144.3ab | 239.1c | 93.9bc | 0.60ab |
N250P75K75 (125% RDF) | 68.8a | 80.1b | 9.3a | 158.2a | 67.9a | 29.8b | 12.0b | 149.6a | 259.2b | 101.0ab | 0.58ab |
N300P90K90 (150% RDF) | 60.7bc | 90.3a | 9.6a | 160.6a | 70.3a | 41.7a | 14.0a | 153.3a | 279.2a | 118.6a | 0.55b |
P60K60 (100% RDF–N) | 28.2f | 25.0f | 5.9fg | 59.1e | 29.5e | 8.7gh | 6.3e | 62.7e | 107.2g | 48.2d | 0.59ab |
N200K60 (100% RDF–P) | 57.7cd | 56.0d | 8.3bc | 122.1c | 45.7d | 13.7ef | 8.3d | 129.8bc | 197.4de | 75.4c | 0.66a |
N200P60 (100% RDF–K) | 54.1de | 57.6d | 7.1de | 118.7c | 36.4e | 10.7fg | 7.5d | 107.4d | 161.9f | 43.2d | 0.66a |
Control (–NPK) | 21.7g | 18.8g | 5.2g | 45.7f | 21.2f | 7.0h | 5.1f | 54.1e | 87.5h | 41.8d | 0.62ab |
Source of variation | |||||||||||
Year | ns | * | ns | ns | * | ** | ns | ns | * | ** | ** |
Cultivar | ** | * | ** | ** | ns | ** | ** | * | ns | * | ns |
Levels of NPK | ** | ** | ** | ** | ** | ** | ** | ** | ** | ** | ** |
Year × cultivar | ns | * | ns | ns | * | * | ns | ns | ns | ns | * |
Year × levels of NPK | ns | * | ns | ns | ns | * | ns | ns | ns | ns | ns |
Cultivar × levels of NPK | ** | ** | ns | ** | ns | ** | ** | ns | ns | ns | ns |
Year × cultivar × levels of NPK | ns | * | ns | ns | ns | ns | ns | ns | ns | ns | ns |
Year 1 and year 2 represent winter 2012–13 and 2013–14, respectively. Within year, cultivar, and levels of NPK, numbers followed by different letters indicate significant differences at p ≤ 0.05 (otherwise statistically at par). ns, non-significant (p > 0.05). *Significant at p ≤ 0.05. **Significant at p ≤ 0.01; Other = Tassel + cob + shank + husk; †HI (N), Harvest Index (Nitrogen)