Table 1:
Risk factor | Screening method and duration | Outcome | Level of evidence^20 |
---|---|---|---|
Head and neck cancer | Endoscopy with Lugol’s or NBI every 6 months to 1 year after completion of therapy for HNSCC, for 10 years | • Detects earlier stage disease • Improved survival • No evidence for cost-effectiveness, |
II-III (moderate) |
Tylosis | 4 quadrant biopsies from proximal, middle, and distal esophagus starting at age 30; repeat every 1–3 years | • Effective for early diagnosis • Only beneficial for Type A (late onset) Tylosis |
III-IV (low) |
Achalasia | Yearly EGD 10–15 years after disease onset +/− Lugol’s solution | • No evidence for cost effectiveness • Need to screen many patients to detect one cancer |
III (low) |
Asian or African high-risk populations | One time Lugol’s chromoendoscopy beginning at the age of 40 | • Screened groups have lower ESCC incidence and mortality rates | II-III (moderate) |
History of caustic esophageal injury | Endoscopy every 2–3 years 10–20 years following the injury | • No evidence for effectiveness | IV (low) |
Levels of evidence: Level I evidence: presence of at least one prospective, randomized, controlled trial, level II evidence: well-designed cohort or case-controlled studies; level III evidence: case series or flawed clinical trials; level IV evidence: opinions of respected authorities or expert committees; level V evidence: insufficient evidence to form any opinions