Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 16;15(9):e0238517. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0238517

Table 3. Detailed description of all behavioural variables measured in 11 subtests in MVCCB 2.

Name of subtests Variables coded Type of variable Description Inter-observer reliability (Cronbach’s alpha/ Cohen’s kappa)
Exploration Exploration Percentage time Dog was moving/standing in the room and had its nose on or in close proximity (approx. 5 cm) to the floor/wall/object/s or both front paws placed on an elevated surface (e.g., window sill, table). 0.95
Locomotion Percentage time Dog was moving in the room with or without any directed activity. 0.99
Inactive Percentage time Dog was inactive (sitting/standing/lying). 0.99
Position at O_1m Percentage time Dog was standing/sitting/lying or moving within 1m of O. 0.94
Looking at O Percentage time Dog’s head and eyes were orientated towards O (dog was moving or stationary). 0.97
Picture viewing Follow O Duration Dog was moving in the direction of the moving O or stationary O. 0.95
Move independent Duration Dog moved independently of O. 0.90
Position at O_1m Duration Dog was standing/sitting/lying or moving within 1m of O. 0.96
Looking at O Duration Dog’s head and eyes were orientated towards O (dog was moving or stationary). 0.94
Food choice No. of correct choices Frequency Number of times the dog chose the plate with sausage in both step1 and step2. 100
Separation Position at door Duration Dog was positioned within the semi-circle in front of one of the two doors. 0.96
Look at door Duration Dog was sitting/standing/lying outside the semi-circle but looking at one of the two doors. 0.98
Locomotion Duration Dog was moving in the room with or without any directed activity. 0.98
Exploration Duration Dog was moving/standing in the room and had its nose on or in close proximity (approx. 5 cm) to the floor/wall/object/s or both front paws placed on an elevated surface (e.g., window sill, table). 0.97
Greeting and Playing Latency to approach S/O Latency Measured from the moment the dog approached S/O within 20cm after S/O entered the room and stood by the door. 0.99
This variable was coded separately for S and O.
Greeting (S/O) 4-point scale 0: dog did not approach/approached initially but then avoided (with no interaction with S/O).
1: slowly sniffed or passively stood after approaching S/O with or without tail wagging.
2: friendly greeting, tail wagging, may have cuddled up, jumped or licked.
3: very excited/enthusiastically greeted with intensive searching for contact and tail wagging.
0.98 Cohen’s kappa
This variable was coded separately for S and O.
Playing (S/O) 4-point scale 0: no play.
1: mouthed toy sometimes but did not play/ may have played after a while but needed some encouragement.
2: mouthed toy and sometimes pulled it/brought it back.
3: played more than 90% of time.
0.99 Cohen’s kappa
Memory test with distraction Latency to find food Latency Measured from the first detectable forward movement of the dog (after O removed the lead) until the dog found the food. 0.99
Detour Latency to success Latency Latency to get the reward in trial 1, 3 and 4. This variable was coded separately for each trial. 100
Time close to gate Duration Duration of time dog stayed close to the gate (the head of the dog was within 50 cm of the gate) in trial 1, 3 and 4. This variable was coded separately for each trial. 0.98
Looking at E Duration Duration of time dog looked at E in trial 1, 3 and 4. This variable was coded separately for each trial. 0.98
Looking at O Duration Duration of time dog looked at O in trial 1, 3 and 4. This variable was coded separately for each trial. 0.98
Attention Time looking at toy/human (E) Duration Total duration of time the dog looked at the moving toy/human (E). This variable was coded separately for the toy and human condition. 0.98/0.98
Time looking at O Duration Total duration of time dog looked at O. This variable was coded separately for the toy and human condition. 0.97/0.98
Novel action Latency to pull out board Latency Measured from the point when the yellow board was visible until the dog pulled out the board and ate the sausage in trial 1. 100
Manipulative persistency Manipulate toy Percentage time The toy was pushed or moved with the dogs’ nose or paw (only actual contact with the toy was measured) in step 1 and step 2 separately. 0.95
Clicker training for eye contact Latency to eye contact Latency Measured from the moment the dog had taken the sausage into its mouth until the dog looked up into the face of E. The average of the first 3 trials and average of the last 3 trials were measured as separate variables. 0.96
Latency to find food Latency Measured from the moment the piece of sausage left E’s hand, until the dog found the food, and took it into its mouth. The average of the first 3 trials and the last 3 trials were used as separate variables. 0.72