Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 8;2020:3969868. doi: 10.1155/2020/3969868

Table 1.

Characteristics of studies included in the meta-analysis.

Author Year Country Study design Reference standard method Test technology Rapid influenza tests Age stage Sample type Sample source Type of influenza virus The number
of samples
TP FP FN TN
Poehling et al. 2002 The United States Prospective Culture+PCR LFIA QuickVue Children (0 to 19 years old) Nasal swab Hospital Influenza A (H3N2) 233 14 5 5 209
Quach et al. 2002 Canada Prospective Culture LFIA QuickVue Children Nasopharyngeal aspirates Hospital Influenza A and B virus 300 42 43 11 204
Cazacu et al. 2003 The United States Prospective Culture LFIA QuickVue Children (3 months to 28 years) Nasal wash specimens Hospital Influenza A and B virus 356 38 7 16 295
Stripeli et al. 2010 Greece Prospective RT-PCR LFIA QuickVue Children (6 months to 14 years old) Nasal swab Pediatrician Influenza A virus (H3N2) 217 27 7 13 170
Patel et al. 2011 Germany Prospective RT-PCR NALFA The rapidSTRIPE assay Unclear Nasal swab Patient centers Influenza A (H1N1) 174 92 4 13 65
Kim et al. 2012 Korea Prospective RT-PCR LFIA RDT kit Unclear Nasal swab Hospital Influenza A (H1N1) 215 75 4 17 119
Sun et al. 2013 China Retrospective RT-PCR LFIA IC-SED Unclear Nasopharyngeal swab Hospital Influenza A (H1N1) 60 51 0 0 9
Ge et al. 2013 China Prospective Culture+RT-PCR NALFA RT-LAMP-LFD Unclear 65 pharyngeal swabs, 7 sputa, and 8 tracheal aspirates Unclear Influenza A (H7N9) 80 22 0 0 58
Leonardi et al. 2013 The United States Prospective RT-PCR LFIA QuickVue Children 12 and under vs. adults Nasopharyngeal swab Unclear Influenza A virus 141 66 2 24 49
Leonardi et al. 2013 The United States Prospective RT-PCR LFIA QuickVue Children 12 and under vs. adults Nasopharyngeal swab Unclear Influenza B virus 78 16 1 11 50
Leonardi et al. 2013 The United States Prospective RT-PCR LFIA Sofia Children 12 and under vs. adults Nasopharyngeal swab Unclear Influenza A virus 141 72 0 18 51
Leonardi et al. 2013 The United States Prospective RT-PCR LFIA Sofia Children 12 and under vs. adults Nasopharyngeal swab Unclear Influenza B virus 78 22 0 5 51
Zazueta-Garcia et al. 2014 Mexico Retrospective RT-PCR LFIA The Xpect Flu A&B Kit Children Nasopharyngeal washes Hospital Influenza A (H1N1) 113 34 10 24 45
Sakurai et al. 2015 Japan Prospective RT-PCR LFIA LFIC-AB 0 to 77 years old Nasal swab Unclear Influenza A 129 74 1 0 54
Sakurai et al. 2015 Japan Prospective RT-PCR LFIA LFIC-AB 0 to 77 years old Nasal swab Unclear Influenza B 145 90 0 1 54
Sakurai et al. 2015 Japan Prospective RT-PCR LFIA LFIC-AB 2 to 77 years old Self-blow nasal discharge specimens Unclear Influenza A 125 70 4 0 51
Sakurai et al. 2015 Japan Prospective RT-PCR LFIA LFIC-AB 2 to 77 years old Self-blow nasal discharge specimens Unclear Influenza B 121 64 6 0 51
Sakurai et al. 2015 Japan Prospective RT-PCR LFIA LFIC-AB 0 to 45 years old Nasopharyngeal aspirates Unclear Influenza A 142 73 1 2 66
Sakurai et al. 2015 Japan Prospective RT-PCR LFIA LFIC-AB 0 to 45 years old Nasopharyngeal aspirates Unclear Influenza B 124 56 2 0 66
Ma et al. 2018 China Prospective RT-PCR NALFA LFD-RPA Unclear Swabs and serum Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Influenza A (H7N9) 50 21 0 0 29
Zhang et al. 2019 China Prospective RT-PCR LFIA HRP-LFIA Unclear Nasopharyngeal swab Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Influenza A 628 55 2 6 565
Zhang et al. 2019 China Prospective RT-PCR LFIA HRP-LFIA Unclear Nasopharyngeal swab Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Influenza B 390 71 0 15 292
Zhang et al. 2019 China Prospective RT-PCR LFIA HRP-LFIA Unclear Oropharyngeal swab Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Influenza A 647 45 0 23 579
Zhang et al. 2019 China Prospective RT-PCR LFIA HRP-LFIA Unclear Oropharyngeal swab Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Influenza B 705 45 2 32 626