TABLE 2.
Quality assessment using the “Quality in Prognosis Studies” tool
Author (year) | Study participation | Study attrition | Prognostic factor measurement | Outcome measurement | Study confouding | Statistical analysis and reporting | Overall risk of bias |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Objective measurements | |||||||
Yan et al (2003) 13 | N/A | N/A | L | L | H | H | H |
Scott et al (2011) 14 | H | H | L | N/A a | L | H | H |
Lee et al (2012) 47 | N/A | H | L | L | M | H | H |
Pauli et al (2013) 48 | M | L | L | L | L | M | H |
Pauli et al (2016) 49 | L | M | M | L | M | M | H |
van der Geer et al (2016) 50 | M | H | L | L | M | L | H |
Objective measurements | |||||||
Goldstein et al (1999) 51 | N/A | N/A | L | L | M | H | H |
Wang et al (2005) 52 | N/A | M | L | L | H | H | H |
Bragante et al (2012) 54 | N/A | M | L | L | M | H | H |
Mucke et al (2012) 55 | N/A | N/A | L | N/A | H | H | H |
Lyons et al (2013) 56 | N/A | M | L | M | L | H | H |
Lazarus et al (2014) 57 | N/A | M | L | L | H | H | H |
Safdar et al (2014) 58 | N/A | L | L | L | H | H | H |
Wetzels et al (2014) 16 | N/A | M | L | N/A a | L | L | H |
Bragante et al (2015) 53 | N/A | L | L | L | L | L | L |
Fong et al (2015) 59 | H | M | L | L | H | M | H |
Kamstra et al (2015) 15 | L | H | L | M | M | L | H |
Manaktala et al (2015) 60 | N/A | L | L | N/A | H | H | H |
Nayar et al (2016) 61 | N/A | N/A | L | L | H | H | H |
Al‐Saleh et al (2017) 43 | N/A | H | L | M | H | H | H |
Lalla et al (2017) 62 | H | H | L | M | H | H | H |
Thor et al (2017) 63 | M | H | L | L | H | H | H |
Subjective measurements | |||||||
De Graeff et al (1999) 17 | L | M | L | L | H | H | H |
De Graeff et al (2000) 29 | L | M | L | L | M | H | H |
Epstein et al (2000) 5 | N/A | H | L | L | M | H | H |
Bjordal et al (2001) 28 | N/A | L | L | L | H | H | H |
Hammerlid et al 2001) 18 | N/A | L | L | M | L | H | H |
Ohrn et al (2001) 33 | M | N/A | L | L | H | H | H |
Wiltfang et al (2003) 34 | L | M | L | L | H | H | H |
Fang et al (2004) 30 | N/A | M | L | L | H | H | H |
Abendstein et al (2005) 64 | N/A | L | L | L | M | H | H |
Fang et al (2005) 31 | L | L | L | L | H | H | H |
Nordgren et al (2005) 32 | N/A | M | L | L | M | H | H |
Urdaniz et al (2005) 37 | N/A | L | L | L | M | H | H |
Borggreven et al (2007) 65 | N/A | L | L | L | M | H | H |
Oates et al (2007) 20 | N/A | L | L | L | H | H | H |
Bozec et al (2008) 66 | L | H | L | L | L | H | H |
Bozec et al (2009) 67 | L | M | L | L | L | H | H |
Rizvi et al (2009) 68 | N/A | L | L | M | H | H | H |
Vergeer et al (2009) 35 | M | N/A | L | L | H | H | H |
Yoshimura et al (2009) 69 | N/A | M | M | L | L | M | H |
Chan et al (2012) 36 | N/A | L | L | L | H | H | H |
Al‐Mamgani et al (2013) 70 | L | N/A | L | L | M | H | H |
Rathod et al (2013) 71 | L | H | L | L | L | L | L |
Zhao et al (2014) 72 | N/A | N/A | L | L | H | H | H |
Arslan et al (2015) 73 | N/A | N/A | L | L | H | H | H |
Kumar et al (2013) 74 | L | L | L | L | H | H | H |
Landstrom et al (2015) 75 | N/A | L | L | L | H | H | H |
Rao et al (2016) 19 | H | N/A | L | M | L | L | H |
Dzioba et al (2017) 76 | L | H | L | L | M | M | H |
Gao et al (2018) 77 | N/A | N/A | L | L | H | H | H |
Tribius et al (2018) 46 | N/A | L | N/A | L | H | H | H |
Veluthattil et al (2019) 45 | N/A | M | L | L | H | H | H |
Abbreviations: H, high risk of bias; L, low risk of bias; M, moderate risk of bias; N/A, not applicable.
Extra‐oral measurement.