Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 18;17(9):e1003248. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1003248

Table 1. LLIN durability components.

Component Definition Test conducted Outcome indicators WHO criteria or industry standard
Attrition Net loss from household through discarding or alternative use Household survey Net presence
Physical integrity Physical state of the net to estimate bite protection Count number, location, and size of hole(s) of a maximum 3 nets per household Holed surface area measured by pHI [6] or MHSA (cm2) pHI 0–64, MHSA ≤ 79 cm2: good
pHI 65–642, MHSA 80–789 cm2: damaged
pHI ≤ 642, MHSA ≤ 789 cm2: serviceable
pHI ≥ 643, MHSA ≥ 790 cm2: too torn/unserviceable
Functional survival [6] Estimation of nets still in households in serviceable condition Median survival analysis (Number of nets present and serviceable)/(number of nets originally received and not given away or lost to follow-up) Median net survival in years = time point at which the estimate of functional survival crosses 50%
Biological efficacy Ability of net to incapacitate or kill susceptible anopheline mosquitoes after contact with insecticide IACT: whole nets [24] Proportion of mosquitoes dead at 24 hours
Proportion of mosquitoes not blood fed
WHO cone/tunnel test: 25 × 25 cm pieces [13] Net samples meeting optimal bioefficacy criteria 1-hour knock-down ≥ 95%
or
24-hour mortality ≥ 80%
or
blood feeding inhibition ≥ 90%
Insecticide content Amount of active ingredient in the net Permethrin: GC-FID
Deltamethrin: HPLC-DAD
Compliance of nets with WHO specifications at baseline; loss of active ingredient over time Olyset: 20 g/kg ± 25% [15–25 g/kg]
PermaNet: 1.4 g/kg ± 25% [1.05–1.75 g/kg]
NetProtect: 1.8 g/kg ± 25% [1.35–2.25 g/kg]

GC-FID, gas chromatography with flame ionisation detection; HPLC-DAD, high-performance liquid chromatography with diode array detection; IACT, Ifakara Ambient Chamber Test; LLIN, long-lasting insecticidal net; MHSA, median hole surface area; pHI, proportionate hole index; WHO, World Health Organization.