Table 1. LLIN durability components.
Component | Definition | Test conducted | Outcome indicators | WHO criteria or industry standard |
---|---|---|---|---|
Attrition | Net loss from household through discarding or alternative use | Household survey | Net presence | |
Physical integrity | Physical state of the net to estimate bite protection | Count number, location, and size of hole(s) of a maximum 3 nets per household | Holed surface area measured by pHI [6] or MHSA (cm2) | pHI 0–64, MHSA ≤ 79 cm2: good |
pHI 65–642, MHSA 80–789 cm2: damaged | ||||
pHI ≤ 642, MHSA ≤ 789 cm2: serviceable | ||||
pHI ≥ 643, MHSA ≥ 790 cm2: too torn/unserviceable | ||||
Functional survival [6] | Estimation of nets still in households in serviceable condition | Median survival analysis | (Number of nets present and serviceable)/(number of nets originally received and not given away or lost to follow-up) | Median net survival in years = time point at which the estimate of functional survival crosses 50% |
Biological efficacy | Ability of net to incapacitate or kill susceptible anopheline mosquitoes after contact with insecticide | IACT: whole nets [24] | Proportion of mosquitoes dead at 24 hours | |
Proportion of mosquitoes not blood fed | ||||
WHO cone/tunnel test: 25 × 25 cm pieces [13] | Net samples meeting optimal bioefficacy criteria | 1-hour knock-down ≥ 95% or 24-hour mortality ≥ 80% or blood feeding inhibition ≥ 90% |
||
Insecticide content | Amount of active ingredient in the net | Permethrin: GC-FID Deltamethrin: HPLC-DAD |
Compliance of nets with WHO specifications at baseline; loss of active ingredient over time | Olyset: 20 g/kg ± 25% [15–25 g/kg] PermaNet: 1.4 g/kg ± 25% [1.05–1.75 g/kg] NetProtect: 1.8 g/kg ± 25% [1.35–2.25 g/kg] |
GC-FID, gas chromatography with flame ionisation detection; HPLC-DAD, high-performance liquid chromatography with diode array detection; IACT, Ifakara Ambient Chamber Test; LLIN, long-lasting insecticidal net; MHSA, median hole surface area; pHI, proportionate hole index; WHO, World Health Organization.