Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 18;153(11):114116. doi: 10.1063/5.0019560

TABLE II.

Atomic forces (e22) computed via the analytical expression and the finite difference procedure and their differences.

Tested atoms Water-1 O Water-1 H1 Water-1 H2 Water-2 O Water-2 H1 Water-2 H2
Analytical forces (0.096 951 679, (−0.049 846 750, (−0.042 834 464, (0.055 862 413, (−0.248 587 088, (0.188 454 211,
−0.008 409 817, −0.237 351 651, 0.245 826 708, 0.009 291 242, 0.001 371 87, −0.010 728 352,
0.124 608 301) −0.076 271 576) −0.048 683 253) −0.136 952 953) −0.041 030 761) 0.178 330 242)
Finite-difference forces (0.096 951 679, (−0.049 846 749, (−0.042 834 464, (0.055 862 412, (−0.248 587 086, (0.188 454 212,
−0.008 409 817, −0.237 351 652, 0.245 826 707, 0.009 291 241, 0.001 371 87, −0.010 728 352,
0.124 608 301) −0.076 271 576) −0.048 683 253) −0.136 952 954) −0.041 030 761) 0.178 330 242)
Deviations (−0.3 × 10−9, (0.6 × 10−9, (0.02 × 10−9, (−1.4 × 10−9, (2.0 × 10−9, (0.8 × 10−9,
−0.3 × 10−9, −1.1 × 10−9, −1.0 × 10−9, −0.9 × 10−9, 1.1 × 10−9, 0.2 × 10−10,
0.5 × 10−9) 0.2 × 10−9) −0.4 × 10−9) −0.9 × 10−9) −0.1 × 10−10) −0.3 × 10−9)