Table 3.
Reference | Participants (mean age, percentage females) | Stressor | Task | Time between end of stressor and task | Results for HVs For ↑ cortisol - reported as either correlation with cortisol, or as a group difference (stress vs control) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Conditioning tasks | |||||
Merz et al., 2013 | 48 HV stress (Mage=23.22, 50%) 48 HV control (Mage=23.22, 50%) |
TSST outside scanner | Fear conditioning task | 25 min | WB: no significant associations ROI: ↓ L NAcc* no associations with ACC, L amygdala |
Lewis et al., 2014 | 7 HV stress responder (Mage=25.43, 57.1%) 9 HV stress non-responder (Mage=21.56, 55.6%) 13 HV control (Mage=23.41, 50%) |
Cold pressor in scanner | Conditioning task | 0 min | Resp > non-resp: R ventral putamen No significant associations with medial PFC, hippocampus, paracentral lobule |
Emotional tasks | |||||
Weldon et al., 2015 | 24 HV (Mage=37.2, 38%) | fMRI scan itself | Face processing task | 0 min | WB: Fear-neutral: ↑ precuneus, ↑ lingual gyrus Anger-neutral: ↑ inferior temporal gyrus, ↑ superior parietal lobule, ↑ precuneus, ↑ rectal gyrus, ↓ cerebellar tonsil, ↓ inferior semi-lunal lobule Sad-neutral: ↑ bilateral motor cortex, ↑ posterior cingulate, ↑ R precuneus Happy-neutral: ↑ R putamen, ↑ rostral cingulate, ↑ L posterior middle temporal gyrus and precentral gyrus, ↑ bilateral precuneus, ↑ posterior cingulate, ↑ middle cingulate, ↑ cerebellum, ↑ inferior parietal lobule Faces-animals: ↑ L superior frontal gyrus |
Henckens et al., 2015 | 118 HV (0%) | Movie clip in scanner | Face processing task | 0 min | WB: Emotional faces: ↑ bilateral amygdala, ↑ hippocampus, ↑ parahippocampal gyrus, ↑ inferior temporal gyrus, Fearful vs happy: ↓ cluster in midbrain, covering the locus coeruleus, hypothalamus and amygdala↑ ROI: ↑ amygdala |
Shermohammed et al., 2017 | 29 HV stress (Mage=21.13, 51.72%) 25 HV control (Mage=20.89, 48%) |
speech stress induction task (adapted from TSST) outside scanner math stress induction task (adapted from MIST) in scanner |
Cognitive Reapprasal task | Time of going into scanner for speech stressor 0 min for math stressor | WB: no significant associations |
Li et al., 2019 | 27 HV (Mage=24.25, 0%) [25 included in cortisol analysis] | TSST outside scanner | Emotional face recognition | Time of going into scanner | ROI: ↑ L hippocampus in ll 5-HTTLPR carriers but not in ss/sl 5-HTTLPR carriers |
Oei et al., 2012 | 17 HV control (Mage=24, 0%) 17 HV stress (Mage=24.5, 0%) |
TSST outside scanner | Working memory task | Time of going into scanner | ROI: ↓ ventral system, ↓ amygdala, ↓ IFG No significant associations with dorsal system (dlPFC and LPC) |
Oei et al., 2018 | 61 offspring (Mage=66.23, 50.8%) 43 partners (Mage=65.86, 51.2%) |
TSST outside scanner | Emotional Sternberg task | 15 min | ROI: ↑ L amygdala No significant associations with right amygdala, R IFG, cingulate |
Van Leeuwen et al., 2018 | 39 HV (Mage=33.73, 0%) 29 siblings of patients with SZ (Mage=33.17, 0%) |
TSST outside scanner | IAPS pictures | 33 min after start stressor (stressor around 13 min) | ROI: no significant associations in HV with precuneus, mPFC, L precentral gyrus, L STG, L&R vlPFC, superior frontal gyrus, middle cingulate, anterior insula, cerebellum |
Reward tasks | |||||
Porcelli et al., 2012 | 16 HV control (Mage=23.4, 50%) 16 HV stress (Mage=23.4, 50%) |
Cold pressor in scanner | Card guessing task | 0 min | WB: No significant associations |
Oei et al., 2014 | 20 HV control (Mage=21.5, 0%) 17 HV stress (Mage=22.4, 0%) |
TSST outside scanner | Backwards masked task | 10 min | ROI: L&R NAcc |
Maier et al., 2015 | 22 HV control (Mage=21, 0%) 29 HV stress (Mage=21, 0%) |
SPECT outside scanner | Food choice task | 12–17 min | ROI: No significant associations with amygdala, ventral striatum |
Decision-making tasks | |||||
Gathmann et al., 2014 | 16 HV stress (Mage=23.69, 43.75%) 17 HV control (Mage=24.06, 52.9%) |
TSST outside scanner | N back tast, game of dice task | around 30 min | ROI: ↓ L middle frontal gyrus-dorsolateral prefrontal area (BA 9) |
Lighthall et al., 2012 | 23 HV stress (Mage=22.4, 48%) 24 HV control (Mage=22.4, 50%) |
Cold pressor outside scanner | Balloon Analogue Risk Task | 24 min after start stressor (stressor around 3 min) | ROI: ↑ dorsal striatum* No significant associations with insula |
Non-emotional tasks | |||||
Qin et al., 2009 | 13 HV control (Mage=20, 100%) 14 HV stress (Mage =21, 100%) |
Movie clip in scanner | N-back task | 0 min | ROI: ↑ MPFC extending to ACC |
Schwabe & Wolf, 2012 | 29 HV control (Mage=23.8, 50%) 30 HV stress (Mage=23.8, 50%) |
SPECT outside scanner | Probabilistic classification learning task | 25 min | ROI: ↑ caudate (cortisol baseline, not cortisol increase) |
Vogel et al., 2016 | 98 HV (Mage=21.9, 0%)** Stress/placebo Control placebo Stress/MR-blocker Control/MR-blocker |
SPECT outside scanner | Spatial memory task | 17 (+/− 4) min | ROI: ↑ amygdala (in placebo condition) |
Khalili-Mahani et al., 2010 | 9 HV responders (0%) 10 HV non-responders (0%) |
MIST in scanner | Image recognition task | 0 min | Resp > non-resp: hippocampus during encoding; R rostral ACC, L lateral PFC during recognition |
Luettgau et al., 2018 | 29 HV (Mage=23.48, 0%) | TSST outside scanner | n-back task | around 20 min | ROI: No significant associations withdlPFC |
Muehlhan et al., 2011 | 29 HV (Mage=23.8, 12.8%) | fMRI scan itself | Visual detection task | 0 min | ROI: No significant associations with thalamus |
Note: HV = healthy volunteer; TSST = Trier Social Stress Task; SPECT = cold pressor with social element; WB = whole brain; ROI = region of interest; L = left; R = right; NAcc = nucleus accumbens; ACC = anterior cingulate cortex; Resp = responder; non-resp = non-responder; PFC = prefrontal cortex; MIST = Montreal Imaging Stress Task; IFG = inferior frontal gyrus; dlPFC = dorsolateral prefrontal cortex; LPC = lateral parietal cortex; BA = Brodman area; MPFC = medial prefrontal cortex
Only in males
Only total participants was reported, not the numbers per group.