Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 25;20:1451. doi: 10.1186/s12889-020-09498-4
SWiM reporting item Item description Page in manuscript
Methods
1 Grouping studies for synthesis 1a) Provide a description of, and rationale for, the groups used in the synthesis (eg, groupings of populations, interventions, outcomes, study design) 7
1b) Detail and provide rationale for any changes made subsequent to the protocol in the groups used in the synthesis N/A
2 Describe the standardised metric and transformation methods used Describe the standardised metric for each outcome. Explain why the metric(s) was chosen and describe any methods used to transform the intervention effects, as reported in the study, to the standardised metric, citing any methodological guidance consulted N/A
3 Describe the synthesis methods Describe and justify the methods used to synthesise the effects for each outcome when it was not possible to undertake a meta-analysis of effect estimates 9 & 10
4 Criteria used to prioritise results for summary and synthesis Where applicable, provide the criteria used, with supporting justification, to select the particular studies, or a particular study, for the main synthesis or to draw conclusions from the synthesis (eg, based on study design, risk of bias assessments, directness in relation to the review question) 10
5 Investigation of heterogeneity in reported effects State the method(s) used to examine heterogeneity in reported effects when it was not possible to undertake a meta-analysis of effect estimates and its extensions to investigate heterogeneity 10
6 Certainty of evidence Describe the methods used to assess the certainty of the synthesis findings 10–12
7 Data presentation methods Describe the graphical and tabular methods used to present the effects (eg, tables, forest plots, harvest plots) 10 & 29–34
Specify key study characteristics (eg, study design, risk of bias) used to order the studies, in the text and any tables or graphs, clearly referencing the studies included
Results
8 Reporting results For each comparison and outcome, provide a description of the synthesised findings and the certainty of the findings. Describe the result in language that is consistent with the question the synthesis addresses, and indicate which studies contribute to the synthesis 17–22
Discussion
9 Limitations of the synthesis Report the limitations of the synthesis methods used and/or the groupings used in the synthesis and how these affect the conclusions that can be drawn in relation to the original review question 23 & 24