Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 11;6(2):e20027. doi: 10.2196/20027

Table 2.

Summary of all interventions from the included articles and related findings.

No. Aspect of eHealth: aim of the study Intervention and related findings
1 mHealtha: to determine whether providing students with preloaded iPad Minis would enhance their experience and increase awareness of and access to mHealth information resources for clinical care in a rural environment
  • Tablets preloaded with health apps were given to third-year students, who were also asked to complete surveys and a journal

  • An overall positive value for participants who “accessed essential clinical information, experienced improved patient education interactions, and accessed tools and resources to assist them in their experiences”

  • Lessons were learned regarding the project

  • A clerkship director’s request has been made to integrate the project beyond the original pilot

2 Web-based medical resources: to describe the effect of the integration of the OMIMb database during the first year of medical school
  • The OMIM database was taught to students who later performed self-assessments of short-term and long-term learning

  • Students’ confidence in clinical genetics skills increased after the OMIM education session

  • Acknowledging and incorporating students’ search preferences can engage them in the importance of identifying appropriate resources

3 Programming: to determine whether it is possible to teach medical students the basics of programming in 2 days and whether students value programming and its teaching in medical school
  • The Coding for Medics course was developed. After 2 days of intensive teaching, participants were given a few weeks to submit a project

  • Basics of programming successfully taught in 2 days

  • Programming teaching should be offered but optional, “practical” and “relevant to clinical problems”

  • Computational thinking learned and considered “transferable”

  • Programming valued as an important skill for the future and oversubscribed because of enthusiasm

  • Programming deemed necessary for the development of eHealth technologies

4 Programming: to describe a new elective computing course and discuss how it prepares medical students to use computer science and technology
  • A 14-month Computing for Medicine certificate course (C4M) was developed in collaboration with the Department of Computer Science, University of Toronto. The C4M included workshops, seminars, and a project

  • Reinforced valuing and understanding of technology

  • Programming and algorithmic and logical thinking skills were taught

  • Medical schools should consider computer literacy as an essential skill to enhance engagement with technology, collaboration with developers, and patient care quality

  • Questions raised about broader adoption of learn-to-code programs, whether elective or mandatory

5 EHRsc: to develop a course module and evaluate it to identify and share best practices and strategies
  • Mandatory participation in EHR full-day intensive training over 2 days for fifth-year students within their seminar in internal medicine

  • Positive attitude toward EHR usage and software

  • Higher perceived benefits of EHR for doctors and nurses than for other professionals or patients

  • Low perceived benefits of EHR for coworking in multiprofessional team

  • Documentation is a core competency

  • More training, standardized examination, and awareness regarding EHR are needed

6 Online medical resources: to verify the hypothesis that removing the subscription cost barrier to accessing EBCRsd will lead to high student uptake and to an improvement in educational outcomes
  • Agreement with Wolters Kluwer to facilitate the donations of UpToDate subscriptions to students

  • Access to devices and the internet is not a barrier

  • The focus should be on web-based tools and evidence

  • Higher use of EBCRs when cost barrier removed

  • Lower UpToDate uptake by preclinical students

  • The introduction of EBCRs during the last year of medical school may lead to habit formation

  • Improvement in examination performance of this graduating class

  • Equitable access to information is required

7 mHealth: to allow students to acquire and develop skills using devices and health apps in a clinical context
  • A single-semester elective option, “Computer Games and Applications for Health and Well-being,” was introduced for first-year students

  • Students not as adept at using mHealth devices as the literature had predicted

  • Ownership of a suitable mobile device was lacking

  • Availability of useful, free apps was limited

  • Key lessons were learned, which we wish will help prepare the medical curriculum

8 Telehealth and mHealth: to deliver orthopedics education through a mobile app, MyDoc, although teaching medical students about secure communication and the Personal Data Protection Act of Singapore
  • Third-year students were asked to use the MyDoc mobile app that allowed communication in the form of personal messages, case discussions, and sharing of patient details with peers

  • Excellent acceptance and satisfaction

  • Technical issues needed to be addressed

  • There was a need for compliance with privacy laws in the context of the growth of telehealth, so medical schools should consider integrating this secure communication tool to their training

9 Online medical resources: to analyze the effectiveness of a new EBM OSCEe for the end of third-year students
  • In this OSCE, students were provided with computer stations and performed online searches to answer a standardized patient’s questions

  • An average of 4 search tools were used

  • Most commonly used websites were UpToDate and Google

  • Most students successfully provided the patient with relevant evidence

  • This new OSCE allowed proper assessment of student EBM skill

10 EHRs: to verify the hypothesis that an educational intervention for second-year students improves their ability to use the EHR in a way that enhances patient-provider interaction (EHR ergonomics) during a SPf encounter
  • EHR ergonomic training’s impact on patient-provider interaction during SP encounters was compared with the impact of basic EHR training with no additional EHR ergonomic training

  • EHR use improved with EHR ergonomic training

  • Students felt improvement in engaging the patients, articulating EHR use benefits, addressing patient concerns, positioning EHR device, and integrating EHR in patient encounter

  • A minimum of 3 ergonomic training sessions were necessary to see overall improvement

  • Self-perceptions were consistent with performance as observed by SPs and faculty members

11 mHealth: to determine whether medical students, with little or no prior knowledge or training in app development, can use development tools to develop useful health apps
  • Medical students were taught the fundamentals of health app design and development and asked to use the iBuildApp environment to develop an app

  • Perceived need for such training increased

  • Previous programming experience was the strongest influencer of a positive experience

  • It is possible to teach medical students the fundamentals of app design so that they may contribute to health app development

12 mHealth: to determine the ways by which third-year students used mobile technology for learning and clinical decision support
  • Students were provided an iPad and information was collected with beginning and end-of-year questionnaires, iPad usage logs, weekly rounding observations, and weekly semistructured student interviews over a 12-month period

  • Tablet computers used to enhance patient care and learning in clinical contexts

  • Data service capability and midlevel storage capacity should be provided on each device

  • Quarterly app training should be integrated to increase effectiveness in clinical decision support

13 EHRs: to address a training gap by describing the Simg-EHR curriculum and sharing participant feedback and lessons learned
  • The Sim-EHR curriculum, consisting of simulated charts for virtual patients, was implanted as part of the third-year family medicine clerkship

  • Increased comfort with finding information, inputting orders, and updating a health maintenance tool

  • Recognition of the value of the activity

  • Expressed frustrations with timing and opportunity costs

  • Improved ability to place orders and update chart

  • No difference in ability to use a health maintenance tool to create routine disease screening, prevention, and management alerts

amHealth: mobile health.

bOMIM: Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man.

cEHR: electronic health record.

dEBCR: evidence-based clinical resources.

eEBM OSCE: Evidence-Based Medicine Objective Structured Clinical Examination.

fSP: standardized patient.

gSim: simulated.