Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 26;2020:9756518. doi: 10.1155/2020/9756518

Table 3.

COVID-19/non-COVID-19 pneumonia classification results. Class.: classification; bac. pneu.: bacterial pneumonia; Sens.: sensitivity; Spec.: specificity; Prec.: precision; Acc.: accuracy; AUC: area under the curve; Ref.: reference.

Class. Subjects Dataset Method Sens. (%) or recall Spec. (%) Prec. (%) Acc. (%) AUC (%) F1-score Ref.
COVID-19/influ-A/normal 219 COVID-19
224 influ-A
175 normal
Private CNN
ResNet
86.7 N/A 81.3 N/A N/A 83.9 Xu et al. [52]
Peer-reviewed
COVID-19/CT-EGFR 1266 COVID-19
4106 CT-EGFR
Private COVID19Net (DenseNet-like str.) 79.35 71.43 N/A 85.00 86.00 90.11 Wang et al. [53]
Peer-reviewed
COVID-19/other pneu. 521 COVID-19
397 normal
76 bac. pneu.
48 SARS
[26, 47] DL
ShuffleNet V2
85.71 84.88 N/A 85.40 92.22 N/A Hu et al. [10]
Preprint
COVID-19/other pneu. 521 COVID-19
665 non-COVID-19 pneu.
Private DNN
EfficientNet B4
95 96 N/A 96 95 N/A Bai et al. [54]
Peer-reviewed
COVID-19/CAP 1495 COVID-19
1027 CAP
Private Multiview representation learning 96.6 93.2 N/A 95.5 NA N/A Kang et al. [56]
Peer-reviewed
COVID-19/CAP 1658 COVID-19
1027 CAP
Private RF-based ML model 90.7 83.3 N/A 87.9 94.2 N/A Shi et al. [57]
Preprint
COVID-19/bac. pneu./normal 88 COVID-19
101 bac. pneu.
86 normal
Private DRE-Net 96 N/A 79 86 95 87 Ying et al. [58]
Preprint
COVID-19/other pneu./non-pneu. 230 COVID-19
100 normal
Private AD3D-MIL 90.5 NA 95.9 94.3 98.8 92.3 Han et al. [44]
Peer-reviewed
COVID-19/other pneu./non-pneu. 1194 COVID-19
1357 other pneu.
998 normal
444 lung cancer
Private +
[26, 47]
FCONet
ResNet50
99.58 100.0 NA 99.87 100.0 NA Ko et al. [59]
Peer-reviewed
COVID-19/other pneu./non-pneu. 1292 COVID-19
1735 pneumonia
713 non-pneu.
Private COVNet
ResNet50
90 96 NA NA 96.0 NA Li et al. [8]
Peer-reviewed
COVID-19/other pneu./healthy 3854 COVID-19
6871 other pneu.
8566 healthy
Private MVPNet
3D UNet
3D UNet-based network
100 25 NA 94 NA 97.0 Ni et al. [60]
Peer-reviewed