Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 28;3:535. doi: 10.1038/s42003-020-01262-z

Table 4.

Comparison between the current proposed NMR-based POCT with AI-aided technology and existing state-of-the-art technologies (e.g., high-field NMR52, electrophoresis53, hplc54, and PCR-based assay45) which have been reported for clinical hemoglobinopathies.

NMR-based POCT High-field NMR Electrophoresis HPLC cation exchange PCR-based assay
Information Phenomic Proteomic Proteomic Proteomic Genomic
Mode of action Water-protein interactions (time domain) Chemical shift (frequency domain) Electric field (protein charge) Mass transfer DNA amplification
Multi-dimensional Yes Yes Yes No No
AI-assisted Yes No No No No
Equipment size Bench-top Large Bench-top Large Large
Equipment price Cheap Expensive Cheap Expensive Expensive
Price per assay Ultra cheap Medium Medium Expensive Expensive
Sample processing Easy Easy Difficult Difficult Difficult
Time to results Minute Hours Hours Hours Hours
POCT Yes No Yes No No
Non-destructive Yes Yes No No No
Functional test Yes Yes No No No
References This work Levitt et. al., Kutlar et. al., Kehra et. al., Kutlar et. al.,

The price per assay for NMR-based POCT refers to a single microcapillary tube (<$0.10). In addition, the proposed method is label-free and therefore no chemical treatment is required.

HPLC high-performance liquid chromatography.