Inactivated whole virus |
Natural virion with genome |
Strong (+++) |
High; Cross-genotype protection |
Low cross-serotypic protection |
Mature technology |
VLP |
Natural virion without genome |
Moderate (++) |
High; Cross-genotype protection |
Low cross-serotypic protection |
Safe; Low cost; Explicit composition; Easy large-scale production and quality control |
Synthetic peptide or recombinant subunit |
Linear epitope or antigen |
Relatively weak (+) |
Low; Cross-genotype protection |
Low cross-serotypic protection; Strong adjuvant requirement |
Safe; Inexpensive; Explicit composition; Easy large-scale production and quality control |
Novel chimeric vaccines |
Natural virion without genome or linear epitopes of antigens |
Relatively high (++/+++) |
High; Cross-genotype protection |
Required to know key neutralization domain and need to design the optimal chimeric strategy |
May induce cross-protection of serotypes |
Recombinant virus-vector vaccines |
Natural virion without genome of target viruses but vectors |
Relatively high (++/+++) |
High; Cross genotype protection |
Risk of vector replication |
May induce cross-protection of serotypes; Comprehensive T-cell immune response |