Table A.1.
Article | Site of Research | Sample |
Academic Discipline |
Methodology |
|||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Student/Staff | UG/PG Student | General Subject Area | STEM (= 1) | Qual/Quant | Data (Size if available) | ||
Al Nashash and Gunn (2013) | UAE | Student | Not specified | Engineering | 1 | Mixed | Survey (38) + FGD (4) + Tracking student data (40) |
Aldamen et al. (2015) | Qatar | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Quant | Survey (254) + Tracking student data (254) |
Baker et al. (2018) | Australia | Student | PG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Survey (88) + Tracking student data (453) |
Bollmeier et al. (2010) | US | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Survey (122) + Tracking student data |
Bos et al. (2016) | Netherlands | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Tracking student data (396) |
Brackenbury (in press) | UK | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Tracking student data (763) |
Brady et al. (2013) | Canada | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Survey (77) + Tracking student data |
Brooks et al. (2014) | Canada3 | Student | UG | Sciences | 1 | Quant | Tracking student data (1,379) |
Caglayan and Ustunluoglu (in press) | Turkey | Student | UG + PG + Associate | Mixed | N/A | Quant | Tracking student data (7,547) |
Chapin (2018) | Australia | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Mixed | Survey (71) |
Chen and Lin (2012) | Taiwan | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Quant | Survey (312) + Tracking student data (312) |
Cooke et al. (2012) | Australia | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Survey (128) |
Danielson et al. (2014) | US | Both | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Mixed | FGD (23) + Survey (257) + Tracking student data (491) |
Davis et al. (2009) | UK | Student | UG | Engineering | 1 | Mixed | Survey (120) + FGD (5) |
Dommett et al. (2019)1 | UK | Both | UG + PG | Mixed | N/A | Mixed | Survey (617) + FGD (25) |
Dommeyer (2017) | US3 | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Quant | Experiment (84) |
Dona et al. (2017) | Australia | Both | UG + PG | Mixed | N/A | Mixed | Survey (119) + Interview (119) |
Draper et al. (2018) | UK | Both | UG | Law | 0 | Mixed | Survey (60) + Tracking student data (60) |
Drouin (2014) | US | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Experiment (141) + Tracking student data (141) |
Ebbert and Dutke (2020) | Germany | Student | Not specified | Mixed | N/A | Quant | Survey (1,079) |
Edwards and Clinton (2019) | UK | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Quant | Experiment (321) |
Elliott and Neal (2016) | UK | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Mixed | Tracking student data (1439)+ Survey (216) |
Euzent et al. (2011) | US | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Quant | Survey + Tracking student data |
Farooq et al. (2017)1 | Malaysia | Student | Executive | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Quant | Survey (481) |
Ford et al. (2012) | US | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Experiment (119) |
Franklin et al. (2011) | US | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Survey (206) + Tracking student data (206) |
Freed et al. (2014) | US | Staff | N/A | Biological Sciences | 1 | Qual | FGD (14) |
Germany (2012) | Australia | Staff | N/A | Mixed | N/A | Mixed | FGD (10) + Survey (96) |
Gorissen et al. (2012)1 | Netherlands | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Mixed | Survey (517) + Interview (14) |
Gorissen et al. (2013)1 | Netherlands | Student | Not specified | Mixed | N/A | Mixed | Survey (120) + Interview (14)+ Tracking student data |
Gorissen et al. (2015) | Netherlands | Student | Not specified | Engineering | 1 | Quant | Experiment (255) + Tracking student data (255) |
Gosper et al. (2010)1 | Australia | Both | UG + PG | Mixed | N/A | Mixed | Survey (970) + Interview (16) |
Groen et al. (2016) | Canada | Both | Not specified | Mixed | N/A | Mixed | Survey (1145) + Interview (6) + FGD (11) + Tracking student data (775) |
Gupta and Saks (2013) | US | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Mixed | Survey (213) |
Guy et al. (2018) | Australia3 | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Survey (137)+ Tracking student data (137) |
Gysbers et al. (2011) | Australia | Both | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Mixed | Survey (593) |
Hadgu et al. (2016) | US | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Tracking student data (63) |
Hall and Ivaldi (2017) | UK | Student | UG | Mixed | N/A | Qual | FGD (42) |
Hussain et al. (2018) | UK | Student | Not specified | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Survey (105) |
Jones and Olczak (2016) | UK | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Quant | Tracking student data (380) |
Joseph-Richard et al. (2018) | UK | Staff | N/A | Mixed | N/A | Mixed | Survey (46) + Interview (12) |
Khan (2016) | Qatar | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Mixed | Survey (97) + Tracking student data (124) |
Krautscheid et al. (in press) | US | Student | UG | Mixed | N/A | Qual | FGD (23) |
Lambert et al. (in press) | UK | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Mixed | Survey (64) + Tracking student data (64) |
Leadbeater et al. (2013) | UK | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Mixed | Survey (140) + Tracking student data + FGD (10) |
Luttenberger et al. (2018) | Austria3 | Student | Not specified | Education | 0 | Quant | Survey (611) |
MacKay (in press) | UK | Both | UG | Mixed | N/A | Qual | Interview (13) + Survey (295) + FGD (2) |
Mallinson and Baumann (2015) | US | Student | UG | Political Science | 0 | Mixed | Survey (320) + Tracking student data (320) |
Marchand et al. (2014) | Canada | Both | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Mixed | Survey (273) + Tracking student data |
McCunn and Newton (2015) | Canada | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Survey (87) + Tracking student data (87) |
McLean and Suchman (2016) | US | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Experiment + Tracking student data (1,014) |
Nair et al. (2015) | Malaysia | Student | UG | Mixed | N/A | Quant | Survey (398) |
Nightingale et al. (2019)1 | UK | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Mixed | Experiment (92) + FGD (92) |
Nordmann et al. (2019) | UK | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Tracking student data (290) |
O’Brien and Verma (2019) | Australia3 | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Quant | Tracking student data (1,169) |
Owston et al. (2011) | Canada | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Survey (439) |
Rahman et al. (2018) | Australia | Both | UG | Engineering | 1 | Mixed | Survey (105) + Tracking student data |
Sarsfield and Conway (2018) | UK | Student | UG | Sciences | 1 | Quant | Tracking student data |
Saunders and Hutt (2015) | UK | Student | PG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Mixed | Survey (84) + FGD (15) |
Shaw and Molnar (2011) | US | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Experiment (113) |
Sloan and Lewis (2014) | US | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Quant | Tracking student data (70) |
Taplin et al. (2011) | Australia | Student | UG + PG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Mixed | Survey (211) |
Terry et al. (2015) | US | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Quant | Tracking student data (890) |
Traphagan et al. (2010) | US | Student | UG | Geology | 1 | Mixed | Experiment (364) + Tracking student data |
Trenholm et al. (2019)1,2 | UK, Australia | Student | UG | Mathematics | 1 | Quant | Experiment (93) |
von Konsky et al. (2009) | Australia | Student | UG | Computer/Information Science | 1 | Quant | Survey (108) + Tracking student data (108) |
Wiese and Newton (2013) | Canada | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Survey (308)+ Tracking student data (597) |
Williams et al. (2012) | Australia | Student | UG | Business/Economics/Management | 0 | Quant | Survey (371) + Tracking student data (371) |
Williams et al. (2016) | US | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Quant | Tracking student data (835) |
Yeung et al. (2016) | Australia | Student | UG | Biological Sciences | 1 | Mixed | Survey (1,022) |
Yu et al. (2015) | Taiwan | Student | UG | Computer/Information Science | 1 | Quant | Experiment (302) |
Notes.
FGD = Focus group discussion.
STEM = Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics Subject.
The last column indicates the number of data points within parentheses for each data source, provided it was clearly indicated.
= More than one institute involved.
= More than one country involved.
= Site not explicitly specified but inferred from the author(s)’ affiliation.