Table 2.
Results |
||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Author, Year | Purpose# | Setting & Sample | Methods | Endogenous Oxytocin Measurement | Mood Measurement | synOT Measurement | Early Postpartum (≤ 6 weeks) | Late Postpartum (> 6 weeks) | Other | Newcastle-Ottawa quality score* |
Gu et al. 2016 | To examine the long-term effects of synOT administration on the endogenous oxytocin system and concomitant indices of functional status, specifically breastfeeding and emotional well being | n= 386 primarily community with some clinical in Quebec subsample of two larger studies (Zelkowitz et al. 2014 above) | Data collected at recruitment and in home at 2 months postpartum including demographics and breastfeeding status | ELISA (Enzo) Unextracted plasma diluted 1:2 or 1:4 | EPDS GAD-8 Perinatal Posttraumatic Stress Questionnaire | Total intra and postpartum intravenous and intramuscular dose calculated from hospital records | 29 women without any OT exposure (7.5% of sample) | At 2 months synOT was positively correlated with endogenous OT levels (p<.001). SynOT was significant predictor of EPDS score. Higher synOT was associated with greater PPD symptoms | 7 | |
Hinshaw et al., 2008 | To test the hypothesis that early use of oxytocin reduces the need for caesarean delivery | n= 412 low risk nulliparous women with spontaneous term labor, diagnosis of primary dysfunctional labor | Randomized control trial. Active managementstarted synOT immediately after primary labor diagnosed, conservative management synOT withheld for 8 hours psychological assessment within 48 hours of delivery | None | EPDS | 100% exposure to synOT. Dose and time of exposure differ on each arm | No significant difference in median EPDS scores or women scoring > 12 (depression cutoff in this study) between arms within 48 hours postpartum | n/a | ||
Kroll-Desrosiers et al. 2017 | To examine the relationship between peripartum synOT administration and the development of depressive and anxiety disorders within the first year PP | n= 46732 from Massachusetts Integrated Clinical Academic Research Database | Retrospective analysis from clinical data repository over nine years. Collected from birth to 1 year postpartum | None | Psychiatric diagnosis ICD-9 codes Psychotropic medications | Yes/no synOT exposure from hospital record | 20% of deliveries with synOT exposure | Within women without any history of anxiety or depression, exposure increased risk by 32%; increased by 36% in women with a history of depression | 50% of patients received PPD diagnosis within just over 2 months postpartum | 7 |
Takacs et al., 2018 | To explore both short- and long-term effects of intrapartum synOT on maternal mood | n= 260 community sample in Czech Republic | prospective longitudinal design data collection at the third trimester of pregnancy, 1-7 days, 6 weeks, and 9 months postpartum | None | EPDS Maternity Blues Questionnaire | Yes/no synOT exposure from hospital record | No effect of synOT on postpartum blues. Receiving synOT predicted a lower risk of positive PPD screen at 6 weeks PP (p=.014) | Receiving synOT significantly predicted a lower risk of positive PPD screen (EPDS > 12) at 9 months PP | 8 |
0-2: low quality, 3-5: moderate quality, 6-8: high quality
purpose as defined in primary study
synOT= synthetic oxytocin (Pitocin); PPD= postpartum depression; EPDS= Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale; ELISA= enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay; ICD-9= International Classification of Diseases, 9th revision