Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 18;11:870. doi: 10.3389/fgene.2020.00870

TABLE 1.

Summary of 19 studies that have evaluated sampling designs using different markers (Microsatellites, AFLPs, SNPs); empirical vs. simulated data; and varying the number of loci, individuals, and populations.

References Dataset Type of sampling No. of populations No. of individuals No. of Loci Principal conclusions
Miyamoto et al. (2008) Microsatellite Empirical 1 480 4 > 30 individuals increases the precision in Hs Between 200 and 300 individuals increase the precision of allelic richness estimates.
Pruett and Winker (2008) Microsatellite Empirical 1 200 8 Precision in summary statistics is increased when > 20 individuals are genotyped.
González-Ramos et al. (2015) Microsatellite Empirical 2 64 15 Above 6 polymorphic markers are enough to adequately define the genetic structure between populations.
Peterman et al. (2016) Microsatellite Empirical 5 80 15 Increasing the number of loci does not change the mean summary statistics, but increases the precision across replicates. IBD patterns are sensitive to fewer loci genotyped.
Sánchez-Montes et al. (2017) Microsatellite Empirical 17–21 (different species) 547, 652, and 516 18, 16, and 15 > 20 individuals and between 50 and 80 individuals per population are needed to estimate HS with precision, and allelic richness, respectively.
Rico (2017) Microsatellite Simulation 17 and 34 (different species) 5,000 and 3,000 20 Spatial sampling design (random, systemic, cluster) affect IBD patterns. Increasing loci, over individuals, increases the accuracy of IBD estimates.
Schwartz and McKelvey (2009) Microsatellite Simulation 1 10,000 15 Different sampling designs generate different FST estimates, and different Structure outputs.
Landguth et al. (2012) Microsatellite Simulation 1 1,000 25 Increasing the number of polymorphic loci increases the precision of patterns of isolation by resistance (IBR).
Oyler-McCance et al. (2013) Microsatellite Simulation 1 1,000 25 Increasing the number of polymorphic loci, individuals, and number of alleles increases the precision and the accurate estimation of patterns of (IBR).
Landguth and Schwartz (2014) Microsatellite Simulation 64 64 20 Increasing the number of populations (even if fewer individuals are sampled) increases the possibility of finding correct patterns of IBD.
Smith and Wang (2014) Microsatellite Simulation 3 100 100 Reducing the number of samples do not affect Hs, FST estimates, but reduces the power to detect accurate allelic richness.
Hale et al. (2012) Microsatellite Mixed (Simulation and empirical) 4 100 9, 5, 7, and 8 For four different species, sampling between 25 and 30 individuals are enough to estimate accurately HS and FST.
Dubois et al. (2017) Microsatellite Mixed (Simulation and empirical) 4 4 different taxa: 726, 408, 372, 384 16 Sex proportions do not affect summary statistics estimates. >20 individuals increase the precision of summary statistics. Empirical and simulated data show different patterns of deviation.
Sinclair and Hobbs (2009) AFLPs Empirical 6 159 59 and 117 >30 individuals per population needed to estimate accurately FST.
Willing et al. (2012) SNPs Simulation 2 1,000 21,000 Fewer individuals are needed to accurately estimate FST for MPS datasets.
Fumagalli (2013) SNPs Simulation 1 1,000 20,000 Low individual sampling, with a high genome coverage underestimates the number of segregating sites, HS estimates and genetic structure.
Nazareno et al. (2017) SNPs Empirical 2 70 3,500 Fewer individuals (8) but with a large number of SNPs (>1,000) increase the precision of HS and FST.
Flesch et al. (2018) SNPs Empirical 4 120 14,000 >25 individuals (with 10,000 SNPs) are needed to estimate accurate kinship indexes (10,000 SNPs), identifying as identical by descent alleles and FST values.
Puckett and Eggert (2016) Mixed (SNPs and Microsatellite) Empirical 34 Microsatellites dataset: 506 SNP dataset: 96 Microsatellite dataset: 15 SNP dataset: 1,000 1,000 SNPs are more precise than microsatellites for assigning birth areas, even if fewer individuals are sampled.