Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 15;117(39):24144–24153. doi: 10.1073/pnas.2007835117

Table 2.

Governors’ tweets, partisanship, and mobility

Panel A: Full sample
Outcome Median minutes at home Log minutes at home
Post stay-at-home message 10.409*** 15.694*** 0.034*** 0.031**
(3.542) (4.697) (0.009) (0.014)
Post stay-at-home message × Trump vote margin −1.679** 0.001
(0.707) (0.002)
Observations R2 94,690 94,690 94,690 94,690
0.984 0.984 0.997 0.997
County fixed effect (FE) Yes Yes Yes Yes
Day FE Yes Yes Yes Yes
Demographics × Day FE Yes Yes Yes Yes
Trump margin × Day FE Yes Yes Yes Yes
COVID controls Yes Yes Yes Yes
Other tweets Yes Yes Yes Yes
Orders Yes Yes Yes Yes
Panel B: By county party
Outcome Median time at home Log time at home
County party Dem Rep Dem Rep
Post stay-at-home message 21.217*** 9.956*** 0.041* 0.031***
(7.634) (3.243) (0.020) (0.009)
Observations R2 14,708 79,982 14,708 79,982
0.985 0.984 0.997 0.998
County FE Yes Yes Yes Yes
Day FE Yes Yes Yes Yes
Demographics × Day FE Yes Yes Yes Yes
Trump margin × Day FE Yes Yes Yes Yes
COVID controls Yes Yes Yes Yes
Other tweets Yes Yes Yes Yes
Orders Yes Yes Yes Yes
Panel C: Triple interactions
Outcome Median time at home Log time at home
Interaction Continuous vote margin Binary Continuous vote margin Binary
Post stay-at-home message 12.728** 9.978 0.009 −0.011
(6.094) (6.395) (0.013) (0.023)
Post stay-at-home message × Republican governor 6.464 23.380** 0.055** 0.115***
(8.096) (11.329) (0.021) (0.030)
Post stay-at-home message × Trump vote margin 0.964 0.008***
(1.033) (0.003)
Post stay-at-home message × Republican governor
× Trump vote margin −4.460*** −0.014***
(1.271) (0.004)
Post stay-at-home message × Republican county 7.000 0.051**
(4.540) (0.022)
Post stay-at-home message × Republican governor
× Republican county −42.820*** −0.138***
(10.124) (0.031)
Republican county × Day FE No Yes No Yes
Trump margin × Day FE Yes No Yes No
Republican governor × Day FE Yes Yes Yes Yes
Republican county × Republican governor × Day FE No Yes No Yes
Trump margin × Republican governor × Day FE Yes No Yes No
COVID controls Yes Yes Yes Yes
Other tweets Yes Yes Yes Yes
Orders Yes Yes Yes Yes
Observations R2 94,690 94,690 94,690 94,690
0.984 0.984 0.997 0.997

Standard errors in parentheses clustered at the state level. Sample is 96,690 county-days over the period 1 March to 31 March 2020. Treatment indicator equals 1 for all days after the governor of state s issues a tweet encouraging citizens to stay home. “Trump vote margin” is county i’s vote margin for President Trump in the 2016 election. Republican counties are those in which Trump’s vote margin in 2016 was greater than zero. County-level demographic controls are median age, log household income, population density, share of population over 65 y, share Black, share Hispanic, and share male. “COVID controls” include controls for county-level COVID cases and state-level COVID deaths. “Other tweets” includes controls for post-COVID and social distancing related tweets. “Orders” includes controls for whether the state has issued the following types of orders: emergency declarations, banning large gatherings, school closures, restaurant/bar closures, nonessential business closures, and stay-at-home orders. ***P <0.01, **P 003C0.05, *P 003C0.1.