Table 1.
Interventions used to improve attraction, recruitment, and retention of health workers in rural and remote areas in select low‐ and middle‐income countries in the EMR (based on WHO recommendation) 11
Countries/Categories | Education | Regulatory | Financial | Personal |
---|---|---|---|---|
Examples from the global recommendations 11 |
Students from rural background Health professional schools outside of major cities Clinical rotations in rural areas Curricula that reflects rural health issues Continuous professional development for rural health workers |
Enhanced scope of practice Different types of health workers Compulsory service Subsidized education for return of service |
Appropriate financial incentives |
Better living conditions Safe and supporting working environment Outreach support Career development programs Professional networks Public recognition |
Afghanistan 14 |
Recruiting students from rural backgrounds (through community nursing [CHN] and midwifery education [CM]) Increasing more training institutes in remote provinces (through IHS/CME) National midwifery accreditation program (tailored to rural deployment) CHW/CHN/CM curricula are based on rural health issues Continuous professional development (refresher courses for CHW) Consideration of preferential admission to meet quotas and rural rotations |
Introducing new cadres Enhancing scope of practice, especially for CHN, CM |
Hardship allowances (double for women in rural care) |
Providing opportunities to male family members Public recognition measures, especially for community health workers, nurses and midwives Afghan midwifery Association (CPD, network) |
Egypt 24 , 25 , 26 | Opening medical colleges and health institutes in rural areas | Raedat refiyat (RR): Female community health workers recruited and deployed in rural areas | Rural hardship allowances | MOH provides housing, attached to PHCs |
Iraq 15 , 27 |
Bridge programs/certificates/diplomas in family medicine and nursing Establishing fellowships for CPD Online courses for in‐service training |
Mandatory 1 year service in rural PHC | Incentive bundles |
Improving living standards Creating compounds for health workers next to medical facilities |
Islamic Republic of Iran 2 , 12 , 22 , 28 |
Opening medical colleges in rural areas Recruiting health workers from rural areas |
Compulsory service special underserved areas (usually in rural areas) Introducing behvarz (community health workers) |
Financial incentives | |
Jordan 17 , 18 , 29 |
Continuous education (specialization in Family Medicine) Providing some internships in (rural) PHCs MOH initiative for rural medical schools rotations to enhance rural exposure |
Female community health workers recruited and deployed in rural areas (only in the South) | Rural hardship allowances | |
Lebanon 2 , 16 , 17 , 30 | Targeted scholarships for rural background students, bonding return of service agreements |
Introducing a rural nurse cadre Improved supervisor support through preceptors |
Financial incentives (eg, bonuses, raises, tuition reimbursements) Rural reimbursement policies exist (but not effective or strong enough) |
Professional development through seminars, courses, and access to conferences, professional development Order of nurses (for those working in rural PHCs) Improving work environments and boosting infrastructure (through contracting out PHCs) |
Pakistan 21 , 28 , 31 |
Changes in curricula Increasing number of training institutions in rural areas |
Introducing new cadres, such as lady health workers and lady health visitors, community midwives recruited from, trained and deployed to all districts Training male CHW |
Fringe benefits, housing facilities and career development opportunities (specifically for doctors) | |
Somalia 20 , 28 |
Public‐private partnerships in training institutions to increase quality and access Course standardization and changes in curricula Expanding health training institutes in remote areas |
Introducing and training midlevel professionals such as midwives, nurses, sanitarians, allied health workers, lab techs Introducing CHWs, especially female health workers and community midwives 1 year mandatory national service post‐graduation (but poor implementation) |
Creating a multisource fund from UN donors to support CHWs Harmonizing salary remunerations for public health workers, Introducing standardized regular living salaries and special hardship allowances for rural, remote and insecure areas |
Introducing better gender‐policies Improving career development policies Introducing workplace safety and security measures Increasing available technologies and equipment Providing recognition and awards Establishing regulatory health professional councils and associations for licensing, networking, credentialing of new cadres |
Sudan 13 , 32 , 33 | Increasing number of training institutions in rural areas |
Establishing law enforcement units in health facilities to ensure policy compliance Compulsory year in PHC (but poor enforcement) Introducing new cadres, recruiting and deploying lower cadres (nurses, med assistant and midwives) in rural areas |
Financial incentives Scholarships |
Upgrading PHC infrastructure and facilities Fringes, rural allowances, (such as health insurance, car ownership), housing subsidies Better gender‐policies to ensure female retention in rural areas |
Abbreviations: EMR, Eastern Mediterranean Region; PHCs, primary healthcare centers.