Skip to main content
. 2020 May 20;9(5):425–430. doi: 10.1055/s-0040-1710527

Table 1. Summary of review of the literature on GCTs of the carpal bones.

No. Authors Year Age Sex Bone(s) Duration Treatment Outcome
1 Abdu et al 10 1994 30 M Scaphoid 6 mo Resection and silicone implant Mild reactive silicone synovitis Good wrist function and no evidence of recurrent disease
2 Gupta et al 5 1995 30 M Capitate, hamate, and triquetrum Distal row carpectomy with reconstruction of the left wrist with a bicortical iliac autogenous bone graft and arthrodesis of the distal carpal segment to metacarpals No recurrence with good hand function on 18-mo follow-up
3 Kew et al 11 2000 18 M Scaphoid 2 mo Resection and a pronator quadratus pedicle bone grafting with radioscaphoid fusion No recurrence was found on 7-y follow-up
4 Sakayama et al 12 2008 24 F Hamate 3 mo Curettage with acrylic cementation No recurrence with 100% functional recovery on 3-y follow-up
5 Tarng et al 13 2009 29 F Scaphoid, capitate, trapezium, and trapezoid En bloc resection through a dorsal and volar approach for soft tissue resection, with defect filled autologous with bicortical iliac crest bone graft No evidence of clinical and radiological evidence of recurrence on 1-y follow-up
6 Kotnis et al 14 2009 44 M Triquetrum 8 mo Surgical exploration and local curettage The patient was symptom-free till for 4 m
7 Angelini et al 15 2011 21 F Capitate 7 mo Curettage + phenol ablation + morselized corticocancellous bone allograft Recurrence noticed after 5 mo
8 Oufkir et al 16 2017 48 F Capitate 1 y Staged procedure
 Curettage and bone cement
 Corticocancellous bone graft from the iliac crest, with lunometacarpal arthrodesis
Complex regional pain syndrome in the early postoperative period
2 y after surgery: pain-free with functional range of motion (30 degrees of extension, 25 degrees of flexion), the grip strength was 50% of that of the unaffected side
9 Afsharet al 17 2018 16 F Capitate 6 mo Intralesional curettage + alcohol ablation + allogenic bone graft Satisfactory hand function without any recurrence at 2-y follow-up

Abbreviations: F, female; GCT, giant cell tumor; M, male.