Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 9;20:744. doi: 10.1186/s12879-020-05450-4

Table 1.

Description of studies excluded in review

N Author/Country Population/Study design Reasons for exclusion
1

Shalhoub 2015

Saudi Arabia

A patient with MERS-CoV/HIV co-infection/case study TB status was not reported
2

Bogorodckaya 2020

Russia

three TB patients co-infected with COVID-19/ case study Cases were incompletely reported.
3

Wang 2020

China [26]

A patient with COVID-19/HIV co-infection/case report TB status was not reported
4

Zhu 2020

China

A patient with COVID-19/HIV co-infection/case report TB status was not reported
5

Zhao 2020

China

A patient with COVID-19/HIV/HCV co-infection/ case report TB status was not reported
6

Baluku 2020

Uganda

A patient with COVID-19/HIV co-infection /case report TB status was not reported
7

Blanco 2020

Spain

Five cases of COVID-19/HIV co-infection/ clinical case series None reported TB status
8

Riva 2020

Italy

Three cases with COVID-19/HIV co-infection / case series None reported TB status
9

Aydin 2020

Turkey

Three patients with COVID-19/HIV co-infection /case series Outcomes of interest were not reported
10

Benkovic 2020

USA

Four patients with COVID-19/HIV Co-infection/Case series Outcomes of interest were not reported
11

Haddad 2020

USA

A case with COVID-19/HIV co-infection/Case report TB screening was not reported
12

Gervasoni 2020

Italy

47 COVID-19/HIV co-infected patients Retrospective study Outcomes of interest were not reported
13

Wang 2020

China [26]

A patient with COVID-19/HIV Co-infection/Case report TB status was not reported
14

Härter 2020

Germany

33 COVID-19/HIV co-infected patients Retrospective study Outcomes of interest were not reported
15

Wu 2020

China

Two patients with COVID-19/HIV co-infection/Case series TB screening was not reported
16

Del 2020

Spain [27]

77,590 COVID/HIV co-infected cases Outcomes of interest were not reported
17

Bulled 2020

South Africa

Comment on COVID-19/HIV/TB co-infection This was a commentary
18

Tadolini 2020

Italy

49 patients with COVID-19/TB co-infection Duplicate report from the same cohort
19

Chen 2020

China [28]

COVID-19/TB burden Letter to the editor without case report
20

Drain 2020

USA

Explanatory article on COVID/HIV burden TB screening was not reported
21

Karim 2020

USA

Included percentage of COVID-19/HIV/TB report No primary data reported
22

Pang 2020

China

Included COVID-19/TB cases A correspondence
23

Wang 2020

China [26]

A case of COVID-19/HIV co-infection The outcomes of interest were not reported
24

Kilds 2020

USA

A case of COVID-19/HIV co-infection The outcomes of interest were not reported
25

Ridgway 2020

USA

A case series of five COVID-19/HIV co-infection Had no outcome of interest reported
26

Sigel 2020

USA

Eighty eight COVID-19/HIV co-infection Had no outcome of interest reported
27

Patel 2020

USA

A case study of COVID-19/HIV co-infection The interest outcome was not reported
28

Guo 2020

China

A survey among COVID-19/HIV co-infected cases The interest outcome was not reported
29

Shalev 2020

USA

31 patients with COVID-19/HIV co-infection The outcomes of interest were not reported
30

Karmen-Tuohy 2020

USA

A case control of 21 patients COVID-19/HIV co-infection The outcomes of interest were not reported
31

Toombs 2020

United Kingdom

Three Cases with COVID-19/HIV co-infection Do not contain the outcome of interest
32

Ruan 2020

China

Three cases with COVID-19/HIV co-infection Had no outcome of interest reported
33

Sun 2020

Singapore

A case of SARS-2/HIV co-infection Had no outcome of interest reported
34

Richardson 2020

USA

43 cases of SARS-2/HIV co-infection Do not contain the outcome of interest
35

Ho 2020

USA

93 cases of SARS-s/HIV co-infection The outcomes of interest were not reported
36

Su 2020

China

Two cases with SARS-2/AIDS co-infection The outcomes of interest were not reported
37

Kumar

India

A case of COVID-19/HIV co-infection Had no outcome of interest reported