Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov;144:105998. doi: 10.1016/j.envint.2020.105998

Table 4.

RoB assessment for studies included in meta-analysis – NO2. RoB Domains: CO – confounding; SB – selection bias; EA – exposure assessment; OM = outcome measurement; MD – missing data; SR – selective reporting.

a) All-cause
Author Year Cohort CO SB EA OM MD SR
Fischer 2015 DUELS mod low low low low low
Chen 2016 Four northern Chinese cities mod low low low low low
Bentayeb 2015 Gazel cohort mod mod low low low low
Desikan 2016 South London Stroke Register high high low low low low
Beelen 2014 ESCAPE mod low low low low low
Tonne 2013 MINAP (ACS survivors) mod low low low low low
Cesaroni 2013 Rome longitudinal study high low low low low low
Carey 2013 CPRD mod low low low low low
Hart 2013 Nurses Health Study low low low low low low
Lipsett 2011 CTS low low low low low low
Hart 2011 US trucking industry cohort mod low low low low low
Brunekreef 2009 NLCS-AIR high low low low low low
Jerrett 2009 Toronto respiratory cohort mod low low low low low
Rosenlund 2008 CHD survivors cohort high low low low low low
Lipfert 2006 Washington University-EPRI Veterans mod low low low low low
Abbey 1999 AHSMOG mod low low low low low
Weichenthal 2017 CanCHEC high low low low low low
Hartiala 2016 The Cleveland Clinic GeneBank study mod low low low low low
Turner 2016 ACS CPS-II mod low low low low low
Yorifuji 2013 Shizuoka elderly cohort mod mod low low low low
Filleul 2005 PAARC mod low low low low low
HEI 2000 Six Cities mod low low low low low
Yang 2018 Hong Kong elderly mod low low low low low
Crouse 2015 CanCHEC mod low low low low low
b) Respiratory
Author Year Cohort CO SB EA OM MD SR
Fischer 2015 DUELS mod low low low low low
Dimakopoulou 2014 ESCAPE mod low low low low low
Cesaroni 2013 Rome longitudinal study mod low low low low low
Carey 2013 CPRD mod low low low low low
Katanoda 2011 3 Japanease Prefectures mod low low low low low
Lipsett 2011 CTS low low low low low low
Hart 2011 US trucking industry cohort high low low low low low
Brunekreef 2009 NLCS-AIR mod low low low low low
Jerrett 2009 Toronto respiratory cohort mod low low low low low
Abbey 1999 AHSMOG mod low low low low low
Weichenthal 2017 CanCHEC high low low low low low
Turner 2016 ACS CPS-II mod low low low low low
Yorifuji 2013 Shizuoka elderly cohort mod mod low low low low
Yang 2018 Hong Kong elderly mod low low low low low
Crouse 2015 CanCHEC mod low low low low low
c) COPD
Author Year Cohort CO SB EA OM MD SR
Carey 2013 CPRD mod low low low low low
Katanoda 2011 3 Japanese Prefectures mod low low low low low
Hart 2011 US trucking industry cohort high low low low low low
Naess 2007 Oslo Cohort mod low low low low low
Turner 2016 ACS CPS-II mod low low low low low
Crouse 2015 CanCHEC mod low low low low low
Gan 2013 Vancover high low low low low low
Yorifuji 2013 Shizuoka elderly cohort mod mod low low low low
Yang 2018 Hong Kong elderly mod low low low low low
d) ALRI
Author Year Cohort CO SB EA OM MD SR
Carey 2013 CPRD mod low low low low low
Katanoda 2011 3 Japanese Prefectures mod low low low low low
Turner 2016 ACS CPS-II mod low low low low low
Yorifuji 2013 Shizuoka elderly cohort mod mod low low low low
Yang 2018 Hong Kong elderly mod low low low low low