Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 17;7(3):115. doi: 10.3390/bioengineering7030115

Table 2.

Advantages and disadvantages of 3D cell culture protocols.

Methods Advantages Disadvantages References
Synthetic scaffolds Metals Biocompatible
Great mechanical properties
Potential poor biodegradability
Oxidation and aggregation issues
May require to be combined with a polymer
Secondary release of metal ions may cause toxicity
[101]
Ceramics Osteoconductive and osteoinductive properties (bioactive ceramics)
Composition can be similar to the human bone mineral content
Significant brittleness
May display inappropriate degradation/resorption rates
[102]
Polymers Good tunability of physical properties
Low immune response
Low production cost
High reproducibility
Defined purity and composition
Often hydrophobic
Lack of cellular recognition patterns for some of them
Poor biocompatibility
Risk of biodegradation side effects (inflammation, toxicity, etc.)
[101,102]
Natural scaffolds Polysaccharides High biocompatible
Low toxicity
Biodegradable
Often contain biofunctional molecules, cell recognition patterns, and adhesion sites on their surface
Similarity with native ECM
Limited physical properties
Might contain pathological impurities such as endotoxin
Difficult to process
Properties dependent on extraction and processing procedures
[101,102]
Proteins Biocompatible
Biodegradable
Similarity with native ECM
Good interactions with the cells
Limited physical properties
Low stability
Possible transfer of pathogens
Composition varies between batches
Unidentified growth factors and bioactive components
[102,103]
ECM-derived Natural ECM components
Good interactions with the cells
Contain biofunctional molecules
Minimal processing
Uncertain composition
In-between lots variations
Risk of unwanted interactions or interferences in signaling pathways
[104]
Acellular matrix Preservation of the native ECM
High biocompatibility
Incomplete decellularization may generate unwanted immune and inflammatory responses [105]
Hydrogels Natural/
Synthetic
High water content
Can be made from a large variety of natural or synthetic materials
Highly biocompatible
Controlled degradation rate
Highly tunable
Inexpensive
Co-culture possible
High reproducibility
Limited physical properties
Gel-to-gel variations
Structural changes over time
[105,106]
Scaffold-free Spheroids Simple protocols
Highly reproducible
Possibility to use multiple cell types
Size is easily tunable
Inexpensive
Simplified architecture
Limited flexibility
Limited size
Lack of porosity
Lack of matrix interaction
[106,107]
Organoids Cells can be extracted from a patient
Great biomimicking abilities
Has a certain variability
Hard to reach in vivo maturity
Lack vascularization
Can lack key cells types
[107]
Self-assembly Cells produce their own ECM
Cells can be extracted from a patient
Enable the formation of tissue-mimicking organ-specific tissue depending on the cell types used
Requires long culture time
Limited size
Limited mechanical properties
Lack vascularization
Incomplete cell differentiation alters biomimicking properties.
[108]