Table 2.
Methods | Advantages | Disadvantages | References | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Synthetic scaffolds | Metals | Biocompatible Great mechanical properties |
Potential poor biodegradability Oxidation and aggregation issues May require to be combined with a polymer Secondary release of metal ions may cause toxicity |
[101] |
Ceramics | Osteoconductive and osteoinductive properties (bioactive ceramics) Composition can be similar to the human bone mineral content |
Significant brittleness May display inappropriate degradation/resorption rates |
[102] | |
Polymers | Good tunability of physical properties Low immune response Low production cost High reproducibility Defined purity and composition |
Often hydrophobic Lack of cellular recognition patterns for some of them Poor biocompatibility Risk of biodegradation side effects (inflammation, toxicity, etc.) |
[101,102] | |
Natural scaffolds | Polysaccharides | High biocompatible Low toxicity Biodegradable Often contain biofunctional molecules, cell recognition patterns, and adhesion sites on their surface Similarity with native ECM |
Limited physical properties Might contain pathological impurities such as endotoxin Difficult to process Properties dependent on extraction and processing procedures |
[101,102] |
Proteins | Biocompatible Biodegradable Similarity with native ECM Good interactions with the cells |
Limited physical properties Low stability Possible transfer of pathogens Composition varies between batches Unidentified growth factors and bioactive components |
[102,103] | |
ECM-derived | Natural ECM components Good interactions with the cells Contain biofunctional molecules Minimal processing |
Uncertain composition In-between lots variations Risk of unwanted interactions or interferences in signaling pathways |
[104] | |
Acellular matrix | Preservation of the native ECM High biocompatibility |
Incomplete decellularization may generate unwanted immune and inflammatory responses | [105] | |
Hydrogels | Natural/ Synthetic |
High water content Can be made from a large variety of natural or synthetic materials Highly biocompatible Controlled degradation rate Highly tunable Inexpensive Co-culture possible High reproducibility |
Limited physical properties Gel-to-gel variations Structural changes over time |
[105,106] |
Scaffold-free | Spheroids | Simple protocols Highly reproducible Possibility to use multiple cell types Size is easily tunable Inexpensive |
Simplified architecture Limited flexibility Limited size Lack of porosity Lack of matrix interaction |
[106,107] |
Organoids | Cells can be extracted from a patient Great biomimicking abilities |
Has a certain variability Hard to reach in vivo maturity Lack vascularization Can lack key cells types |
[107] | |
Self-assembly | Cells produce their own ECM Cells can be extracted from a patient Enable the formation of tissue-mimicking organ-specific tissue depending on the cell types used |
Requires long culture time Limited size Limited mechanical properties Lack vascularization Incomplete cell differentiation alters biomimicking properties. |
[108] |