Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 14;15:286. doi: 10.1186/s13023-020-01573-8

Table 1.

Main characteristics and outcomes of included studies

First author/year [Ref.] Study design No. (M:F) Presentation Mean age at mol. Diag (Y) Country/ethnicity SS (< 3%) Parent marriage Enzyme activity Liver biopsy MPS type/panel Suspected disease Result of molecular test Read length Mean depth of coverage Type of sequencer Trio-based test (parents)
Tong et al. [17] Coh 2 (1:1) Developmental delay, Hepatosplenomegaly, Dystrophia, Neutropenia, 2.5 China 2 patients Non-consanguineous NR NR ES/ Exome Sequencing TruSight One Gene Panel Neurodevelopmental Disease 1 GSD Ia, 1 GSD Ib 2 × 100–150 bp 142× HiSeq2500 (Illumina)

YES

Both parent

Roscher et al. [20] Coh 21 (17:4) Hepatomegaly, liver fibrosis and adenoma, mild cardiomyopathy 11.7 Canada 2 patients Non-consanguineous YES: 14 patients YES: 10 patients TGS/NA GSD III or GSD VI 11 patients GSD IXa; 3 patients GSD IXb; 3 patients GSD IXc; 4 patients GSD VI 2 × 100 bp 100× HiSeq2000 (Illumina) YES both parents
Skakik et al. [23] Coh 5 M Hepatomegaly and hypoglycemia 1.3 Serbia YES Non-consanguineous YES YES ES/ Exome Sequencing TruSight One Gene Panel Hepatic GSD GSD III, VI, IXa as well as in non-GSD associated genes, LIPA and SBDS, responsible for cholesteryl-ester storage disease and Schwachman-Diamond syndrome respectively 2 × 100 bp 100 ×  MiSeq (Illumina) NO
Vega et al. [7] Coh 22(13:9) Hepatomegaly, dysmorphic facies, hypoglycemia, hyperuricemia, hyperlipidemia and kidney failure, hypertransaminasemia, 13.5 Spain YES NR NR NR

TGS/Metabolic disorders panel (Agilent)

ES/ Exome Sequencing TruSight One Gene Panel

GSDs

11 NOT detected by TGS:4 Detected (GSD III, VI, IXb, ALDOB)

18 repeated and detected by ES (1 GSD Ib, 6 GSD III, 7 GSD IXa) as well as in not GSD associated genes, LIPA, CPT2, ANO5, NKX2-5

2 × 250 bp

2 × 250 bp

400×

83.6×

MiSeq (Illumina) YES parents
Zhang et al. [24] Coh 17 M hepatomegaly, growth retardation, and liver dysfunction 9.9 China 7 YES, 10 NO Non-consanguineous NO 8 YES, 9 NO TGS/ GSD panel (Agilent) GSD IX 17 GSD IXa 2 × 100 bp 100× HiSeq2000 (Illumina) NO
Wang et al. [2] CS 16(9:7) Hypoglycemia and mild hepatosplenomegaly, lactic acidosis, neutropenia 6.5 USA YES 15 Non-consanguineous:1 Consanguineous YES YES TGS/ GSD panel (Agilent) GSDs 8 detected and matched with signs (1 GSD Ia, 2 GSD Ib, 3 GSD III, 2 GSD IXa), 4 detected truly with TES but direct seq. not found mut (1 suspected as GSD Ia, recognized as GSD Ib; 1 suspected as GSD 0 recognized as GSD IXc.; 1 suspected as GSD III recognized as GSD VI; 1 suspected as GSD VI or IX recognized as GSD IXa, 5 suspected as hepatic GSD but NOT detected by TGS 1 × 100 bp 758× HiSeq2000 (Illumina) 5 YES Both parents, 11 NO
Wang et al. [21] CS 3 M Hepatomegaly and hypertriglyceridemia 7.3 USA NO Non-consanguineous NR NR ES/NA Hepatic GSD 3 GSD III 1 × 100 bp  ~ 1000× HiSeq2000 (Illumina) NO
Choi et al. [19] CS 2 M Hepatomegaly, elevated AST and ALT levels, neutropenia 0.83 Korean YES Non-consanguineous YES YES ES/NA GSD I 2 GSD Ib 2 × 150–200 bp NR HiSeq2000 (Illumina) NO
Fahiminiya et al. [18] CS 1 M Hepatomegaly, and recurrent hypoglycemia 6 Qatar YES Consanguineous YES YES ES/NA GSD I or III 1 GSD IXc 2 × 100 bp 100× HiSeq2000 (Illumina) NO
Rousseau-Nepton et al. [22] C- series 2 (1:1) Abdominal distension with hepatomegaly, difficulty walking 1.4 Canada YES Non-consanguineous YES NO ES/NA GSD I or III 2 GSD III NR 100x HiSeq2000 (Illumina) YES Parents and siblings
Yang et al. [25] C-series 3 M Increased transaminase, Hepatomegaly, Hypoglycemic 2.8 China 1YES, 2 NO 1Consanguineous, 2 Non-consanguineous YES 1 YES TGS/ 300 genes associated with hepatopathy panel Metabolic liver disorders 3 GSD IXa NR 100× HiSeq2500 (Illumina) YES Parents and siblings

Coh cohort, CS cross-sectional, C-Series case-series, NR not reported, SS short stature, MUT mutation, ES exome sequencing, TGS targeted gene sequencing, NA not associated