Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 15;5(1):135–159. doi: 10.1007/s41885-020-00076-x

Table 5.

Post-NPIs changes in daily Google mobility indexes, with country characteristics interactions, FE, all countries, N = 1582

places of shopping & transit parks and
residence restaurants stations beaches workplaces
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
SH {0, 1} 6.5930*** − 21.4214*** − 19.8816*** − 15.5681*** − 15.4178***
(0.5290) (1.4970) (1.3895) (1.8600) (1.4005)
ET {0, 1} 2.2441** − 5.8202* − 4.6262 − 5.3257 − 3.6612
(1.1211) (3.1722) (2.9444) (3.9414) (2.9677)
SWC {0, 1} 8.6343*** − 23.2667*** − 23.4267*** − 12.7039*** − 20.1859***
(0.3171) (0.8954) (0.8311) (1.1126) (0.8377)
ET {0, 1} * ln GDP pc − 1.5158 4.1972 − 0.7336 − 4.6578 2.6772
(1.4852) (4.2025) (3.9007) (5.2215) (3.9315)
SWC {0, 1}* ln GDP pc 0.7065 0.858 − 1.5153 4.7728*** − 1.5192
(0.5142) (1.4550) (1.3505) (1.8078) (1.3612)
ET {0, 1} * Pop density − 4.5089 13.1933 18.1349 − 1.3452 6.5612
(5.2793) (14.9403) (13.8677) (18.5631) (13.9771)
SWC {0, 1} * Pop density 1.133 1.0448 3.6166* − 1.0372 − 2.1305
(0.7348) (2.0769) (1.9278) (2.5806) (1.9430)
ET {0, 1} * ln surface area − 1.4672 0.3524 1.9539 − 1.4346 3.3944
(1.3305) (3.7653) (3.4949) (4.6783) (3.5225)
SWC {0, 1} * ln surface area − 2.3717*** 8.1015*** 7.3160*** 5.0127*** 6.0197***
(0.3706) (1.0430) (0.9681) (1.2959) (0.9757)
ET {0, 1} * PM2.5 − 1.9791* 2.3528 4.772 10.6139*** 4.104
(1.1413) (3.2297) (2.9978) (4.0128) (3.0215)
SWC {0, 1} * PM2.5 − 2.6580*** 4.6792*** 4.5335*** 3.6869*** 6.1490***
(0.3192) (0.9033) (0.8385) (1.1224) (0.8451)
ET {0, 1}* Empl. rate − 0.1424 − 5.193 − 2.9941 0.4974 1.4675
(1.2421) (3.5151) (3.2627) (4.3675) (3.2885)
SWC {0, 1}* Empl. rate − 0.9886*** 3.9615*** 3.2151*** 2.5259** 4.1719***
(0.3638) (1.0282) (0.9544) (1.2776) (0.9619)
ET {0, 1}* Health expend. %GDP − 0.2805 2.6961 4.1755 − 0.1222 0.9763
(1.1750) (3.3253) (3.0865) (4.1316) (3.1109)
SWC {0, 1}* Health expend. %GDP − 0.7943** 2.0899** 0.3806 4.8882*** 1.1686
(0.3567) (1.0095) (0.9370) (1.2542) (0.9444)
ET {0, 1} * Physicians/1000 4.4913** − 8.9163 − 10.0033* − 16.7206** − 10.9613**
(1.9555) (5.5339) (5.1366) (6.8758) (5.1772)
SWC {0, 1}* Physicians/1000 0.8598 − 7.2728*** − 4.2720*** − 8.1505*** − 2.1567
(0.5406) (1.5294) (1.4196) (1.9002) (1.4308)
ET {0, 1} * % 65 yo + − 2.6676 0.9514 6.6116 20.9118*** 4.6088
(2.1159) (5.9879) (5.5580) (7.4399) (5.6019)
SWC {0, 1} * % 65 yo + − 2.6986*** 4.6789*** 4.7986*** 6.5452*** 6.0396***
(0.5132) (1.4518) (1.3476) (1.8039) (1.3582)
R2 adj. 0.671 0.656 0.707 0.539 0.602

Note: The subset of “all countries” includes 88 countries. Google mobility data shows how time spent in different location categories changed compared to the baseline days (a normal value for that day of the week in the 5-week period Jan 3 – Feb 6, 2020). ET denotes extensive testing NPI; SWC denotes schools and/or workplaces closures; SH denotes “stay-at-home” NPI. Coefficients presented, standard errors in parenthesis. Statistical significance is denoted as 10%, ∗∗5%, and ∗∗∗1% levels