Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 10;6(4):998–1011. doi: 10.1016/j.bioactmat.2020.09.030

Table 1.

Overview of hydrogels with different polymer types for cartilage tissue engineering: chemical structure and features for cartilage engineering.

Name (Abbreviation) Chemical structure Features for cartilage engineering Limitations Refs
Synthetic polymers Polyethylene glycol (PEG) Image 2
  • 1.

    Biocompatible

Biologically inert [[47], [48], [49], [50], [51]]
  • 2.

    Easy to be functionalized

Poly (N-vinylcaprolactam) (PVCL) Image 3
  • 1.

    Thermosensitive

Moderate wettability, weak mechanical properties, low anti-biofouling [42,157]
  • 2.

    Cytocompatible to chondrocytes and MSCs

Polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) Image 4
  • 1.

    Mechanical strong

Biologically inert [19,37,38,158]
  • 2.

    MSCs chondrogenic differentiation

Poly (2-methacryloyloxyethyl phosphorylcholine) (PMPC) Image 5
  • 1.

    Monomer and polymer biocompatible

Do not support cell attachment [[39], [40], [41],159]
  • 2.

    Lubricant

  • 3.

    Mechanical strong

Polysaccharides Chondroitin sulfate (CS) Image 6
  • 1.

    Component of natural cartilage

Rapid degradation [11,34,[54], [55], [56]]
  • 2.

    Regulate hypertrophy during MSC chondrogenesis

  • 3.

    Promote cartilage ECM production

Hyaluronic Acid (HA) Image 7
  • 1.

    Component of natural cartilage and tissue

Do not support cell attachment [62,64,68,160,161]
  • 2.

    Promote cartilage marker gene expression of chondrocytes

  • 3.

    Easy to be functionalized

Chitosan Image 8
  • 1.

    Drug delivery capacity

Low solubility and high viscosity [[81], [82], [83],162]
Alginate Image 9
  • 1.

    Fast cross-linking and mechanical strong

Non-biodegradable and elicit immunological responses [[86], [87], [88], [89],91]
  • 2.

    Able to 3D printing/bioprinting

  • 3.

    Can be used as gene carriers

Cellulose Image 10
  • 1.

    Can be sulfated

Lack of mechanical properties [92,93,95]
  • 2.

    Nanofibrils similar to collagen fibrils found in tissue ECM

Proteins Collagen Image 11
  • 1.

    Natural extracellular matrix (ECM) protein

Limited number of functional groups for crosslinking [30,99,100,103,163]
  • 2.

    Immunomodulation

Gelatin Image 12
  • 1.

    Promote cell adhesion

Poor mechanical properties and low thermal stability [35,104,107,130]
  • 2.

    Easy to be modified for UV crosslinking

  • 3.

    Able to 3D printing/bioprinting

Silk Fibroin (SF) Image 13
  • 1.

    Mimicking the collagen structure of native cartilage

Limited options for anchoring growth factor [111,113,114,164]
  • 2.

    Immunocompatible

  • 3.

    Multiple methods for crosslinking

  • 4.

    High mechanical strength

Sericin Image 14
  • 1.

    Low cost

Low stability in aqueous solution [117,165]
  • 2.

    Nutrition-supplying

Fibrin
  • 1.

    Easy to be functionalized

Not chondro-permissive [118,119]
Peptides
  • 1.

    Promote MSC chondrogenesis

Need proper peptide design, synthesis, and purification [125,128]