Table 2.
Author and Year | Study Type | Patient Population | Sample Size | FMT Treatment | Route | Dosage | Clinical Response (Reduction in PDAI ≥3) | Clinical Remission (Reduction in PDAI ≥3 and Total of <7) |
Endoscopic Outcomes | Histologic Outcomes | Adverse Events | Follow-Up |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fang et al., 2016 | Case report | Chronic antibiotic resistant pouchitis | 1 | Single FMT | Sigmoidoscopy (delivered 40 cm into the afferent limb and pouch body) | Stool mixed with saline and diluted to 250 mL | 1/1 after 3 months (cPDAI decreased from 6 at baseline to 0) | 1/1 after 3 months (cPDAI decreased from 6 at baseline to 0) | NA | NA | No reported adverse events. | 3 months |
Herfarth et al., 2019 | RCT with open-label follow-up | Chronic antibiotic dependent pouchitis >4 weeks. mPDAI ≥5 | 6 (FMT (4) Placebo (2)). 5 received open-label FMT afterwards |
Single endoscopic FMT followed by daily oral encapsulated FMT for 2 weeks | Sigmoidoscopy and oral capsules | eFMT (2 × 30 mL, total of 24 g donor stool) and 6 capsules daily consisting of 4.2 g donor stool | 1/6 (Four patients receiving primary FMT and two patients receiving open-label FMT included) | 1/6 (clinical PDAI 1 and no need for antibiotics) | NA | NA | No FMT related safety events were observed. | 16 weeks |
Kousgaard et al., 2020 | Cohort (open-label pilot study) | Chronic pouchitis (≥3 episodes of pouchitis within the last year) | 9 | 14 days of daily self-administered FMT | Enema | 20 g fecal material diluted in 100 mL saline | 3/9 after four weeks | 3/9 after four weeks | Mean ePDAI of 3.2 at baseline decreased to 2.2 after four weeks | Mean hPDAI of 1.7 decreased to 1.0 after four weeks | 7/9 patients reported adverse events while treated. Abdominal pain (5), uncomfortable (2), nausea (2), fever (2), bloating (1), dizziness (1), and fatigue (1). | 6 months |
Landy et al., 2015 | Cohort (pilot study) | Chronic pouchitis with current PDAI ≥ 7 | 8 | Single FMT | Nasogastric | 30 mL of fecal-saline solution followed by 50 mL saline | 2/8 after 4 weeks | 0/8 after 4 weeks | Mean ePDAI of 5 at both baseline and after 4 weeks | Mean hPDAI of 3 at baseline decreased to 2 after four weeks | Nausea (3), bloating (2), vomiting (1), fever (1). All transient (<24 h). | 4 weeks |
Nishida et al., 2019 | Case series | Chronic pouchitis with current PDAI ≥7 | 3 | Single FMT | Colonoscopy | 150–200 g donor stool mixed with 350–500 mL sterile saline | 1/3 after 8 weeks | 0/3 after 8 weeks | NA | NA | No reported adverse events. | 8 weeks |
Schmid et al., 2017 | Case report | A severe flare of pouchitis in a patient diagnosed with pouchitis one year earlier | 1 | A total of three FMTs at baseline, after 5 and 9 weeks | Pouchoscopy | 250 mL fecal-saline suspension | 0/1 after 9 weeks | 0/1 after 9 weeks | NA | NA | No reported adverse events. | 9 weeks |
Selvig et al., 2020 | Cohort (prospective open-label pilot study) | Chronic pouchitis. Prior endoscopic evaluation confirming inflammation and over 4 weeks of symptoms | 18 (7 of the 18 patients pre-treated with Rifaximin) | 1 or 2 FMTs. Single or optional re-treatment | Pouchoscopy. Delivered to the most proximal point of insertion (proximal pouch or neo-terminal ileum) | 250/500 mL in total derived from 25/50 g stool | 1/11 after 4 weeks. Only 11 underwent pouchoscopy at 4 weeks | 1/11 after 4 weeks | Mean ePDAI of 3.38 at baseline decreased to 3.36 after four weeks | Mean hPDAI of 1.05 at baseline increased to 1.36 after four weeks | One patient admitted to hospital 8 days after FMT because of abdominal pain considered not related to FMT. One patient diagnosed with Crohn’s disease at pouchoscopy after four weeks, which was suspected in advance. Minor self-limiting adverse events. Discomfort (4), flatulence (4), bloating or cramping (3), fatigue (3), and nausea (2). | 12 months |
Stallmach et al., 2016 | Prospective open-label pilot study | Chronic antibiotics resistant pouchitis (three or more cycles of antibiotics) | 5 | 1–7 FMTs | FMT to the jejunum with intervals of 3–4 weeks | 275 mL fecal saline suspension derived from 75 g stool | 5/5 after last FMT. | 4/5 after last FMT | Mean ePDAI of 3.8 at baseline decreased to 1.2 after last FMT | Mean hPDAI of 3 at baseline decreased to 1.2 after last FMT | Mild transient fever and CRP increase in one patient. | 3 months. One patient followed for 12 months |
Steube et al., 2017 | Prospective open-label pilot study | Chronic antibiotics resistant pouchitis | 14 | 2–4 FMTs | Nasojejunal or capsule application delivered every 4 weeks according to treatment outcome | NA | 7/14. PDAI scores however not described. Assessed through F-Calprotectin. | NA | NA | NA | No reported adverse events. | 8 weeks |
NA, not available; cPDAI, clinical Pouchitis Disease Activity Index; ePDAI, endoscopic Pouchitis Disease Activity Index; hPDAI, histologic Pouchitis Disease Activity Index; FMT, Fecal Microbiota Transplantation; RCT, Randomized Controlled Trial; mPDAI, modified Pouchitis Disease Activity Index; F-Calprotectin, Fecal Calprotectin.