Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 15;11:5164. doi: 10.1038/s41467-020-18982-9

Table 1.

Characteristics of articles included in the systematic review.

First author/reference No. Article type Country Publication stage Quality score Overall quality No. neonates
Abasse17 Case report Francea PR 6 Good 1
Aghdam18 Case report Iran PR 4 Intermediate 1
Alonso Diaz19 Case report Spain PR 5 Intermediate 1
Alzamora20 Case report Peru PR 3 Intermediate 1
Ayed21 Case series Kuwait Preprint 1 Low 2
Banerjee22 Case series India PR 2 Low 6
Barbero23 Retrospective cohort study Spain PR n.a. Intermediate 1
Buonsenso24 Case series Italy PR 4 Intermediate 1
Carosso25 Case report Italy PR 4 Intermediate 1
Chacon-Aguilar26 Case report Spain PR 5 Intermediate 1
Coronado Munoz27 Case report USA PR 4 Intermediate 1
Demirjian28 Case report UK PR 4 Intermediate 1
Dong29 Case report China PR 6 Good 1
Dumpa30 Case report USA PR 6 Good 1
Eghbalian31 Case report Iran PR 4 Intermediate 2
Feng32 Case series China PR 3 Intermediate 4
Fenizia33 Case series Italy PP 5 Intermediate 2
Ferrazzi34 Case series Italy PR 1 Low 3
Garazzino35 Case series Italy PR 2 Low 15
Gonzales Brabin36 Case report Spain PR 3 Intermediate 1
Gordon37 Case report UK PR 2 Low 1
Gregorio-Hernandez38 Case series Spain PR 5 Intermediate 3
Groß39 Case series Germany PR 5 Intermediate 1
Han40 Case report South Korea PR 6 Good 1
Hantoushzadeh41 Case series Iran PR 6 Good 1
Hasan42 Case series Bangladesh Preprint 6 Good 7
Hu43 Case series China PR 6 Good 1
Ibarra Rios44 Case report Mexico Preprint 5 Intermediate 1
Kanburoglu45 Case report Turkey PR 1 Low 1
Kayem46 Case series France PR 1 Low 1
Kirtsman47 Case report Canada PR 6 Good 1
Knight48 Retrospective cohort study UK PR n.a. n.a. 12
Kulkarni49 Case report India PR 6 Good 1
L’Huillier50 Case series Switzerland PR 1 Low 1
Lorenz51 Case report Germany PR 6 Good 1
Martinez-Peres52 Case series Spain PR 1 Low 4
Marzollo53 Case report Italy PR 6 Good 1
Meredith54 Case series UK PR 1 Low 1
Meslin55 Case series France PR 6 Good 4
Mithal56 Case series USA PR 3 Intermediate 4
Needleman57 Case report USA PR 4 Intermediate 1
Ng58 Case series UK PR 6 Good 1
Oncel59 Case series Turkey PR 6 Good 4
Paret60 Case series USA PR 3 Intermediate 1
Patanè61 Case series Italy PR 6 Good 2
Patil62 Case series USA PR 4 Intermediate 3
Pierce-Williams63 Case series USA PR 5 Intermediate 1
Piersigilli64 Case report Belgium PR 6 Good 1
Precit65 Case report USA PR 5 Intermediate 1
Salik66 Case report USA PR 1 Low 1
Salvatori67 Case series Italy PR 6 Good 2
Savasi68 Case series Italy PR 1 Low 4
Schwartz69 Case series Iran PR 5 Intermediate 19
Siddhi70 Case report UK PR 3 Intermediate 1
Sinelli71 Case report Italy PR 6 Good 1
Sisman72 Case report USA PR 6 Good 1
Sola73 Case series Latin Americab PR 5 Intermediate 6
Sun D74 Case report China PR 6 Good 1
Sun75 Case series China PR 6 Good 1
Verma76 Case series USA PR 2 Low 1
Vivanti77 Case report France PR 6 Good 1
Wang78 Case report China PR 6 Good 1
Wang X79 Case report China PR 6 Good 1
Wardell80 Case series USA PR 6 Good 4
White81 Case series USA PR 6 Good 3
Wu82 Case series China PR 5 Intermediate 3
Xia83 Case series China PR 4 Intermediate 3
Xiao84 Cross-sectional study China PR n.a. Intermediate 2
Yu85 Case report China PR 4 Intermediate 1
Zamaniyan86 Case report Iran PR 6 Good 1
Zeng H87 Case series China PR 2 Low 2
Zeng L88 Case series China PR 6 Good 3
Zeng LK89 Case report China PR 6 Good 1
Zhang90 Case series China PR 5 Intermediate 2
Total 176

For articles reporting both infected and non-infected neonates, only those with proven infection (defined as at least one positive nasopharyngeal swab, and/or the presence of specific IgM) were included in the review. The methodological quality of case reports and case series was evaluated using the Mayo Evidence-Based Practice Center tool103, specifically dedicated to the quality evaluation of this type of articles and summarized both as a 0–8 score and as overall qualitative evaluation. The tool was not applied to the retrospective cohort or cross-sectional studies included in the review.

n.a. not applicable, PR peer-reviewed.

aThis case was observed in Mayotte Island, an overseas French department in in the Indian Ocean.

bThis study was conducted in seven neonatal units affiliated to the network of the Latin American Neonatal Society (Sociedad Iberoamericana de Neonatologia (SIBENA); in detail, positive SARS-CoV-2 neonates included in this review were from Peru (n = 3), Dominican Republic (n = 2) and Honduras (n = 1).