Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 17;755:142971. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.142971

Table 2.

Summary across the seven Action Labs of the initial levels of stakeholder awareness, the stakeholders involved and the strategies for engagement.

Action Lab Initial level of awareness Actors involved Strategies for engagement
Bollaertbeek
  • Farmers are little aware of the problem in their area. They know water quality is important, but they think local water quality is sufficient and they do not think that their agricultural activities have a negative influence on water quality.

  • Some contract sprayers do know the situation is bad, others didn't acknowledge the situation at all.

  • The other actors (interviewed at the start of the project) know the quality of the water is bad.

Action lab leader(s) INAGRO (farmer advisory and research)
ILVO (research)
VITO (research)
Informing – newsletter
Informing – presentation
Exchange – bilateral conversation
Exchange – multi-actor conversation
Exchange – questionnaire/survey
Exchange – implementation training
Exchange –field visit
Exchange – interactive workshop
Chemical producers Bayer
Distributers of plant protection products Phytodistributers
Representatives of chemical producers Phytofar
Spraying machine dealers Dauchy
Agri Lemahieu
Farmers Famers of the Bollaertbeek catchment
Contract sprayer Contract sprayers
Farmer advisory and unions Boerenbond
ABS
Boerenbond – Agrobeheercentrum
‘t Boerenlandschap
Water producers and suppliers of drinking water De Watergroep
Regional/national government Province West-Flanders
VMM
VLM
Regionaal landschap De Westhoek
Local government Ieper
Heuvelland
Vester Hjerk
  • No big awareness about the drinking water situation among the public. People are relying on the authorities and waterworks to take action if there is a problem.

Action lab leader(s) UCPH (research)
GEUS (research)
SEGES Research
Informing – newsletter
Exchange – bilateral conversation
Exchange – multi-actor conversation
Exchange – questionnaire/survey
Exchange – interactive workshop
Farmers (consumers) Farmers of the catchment area
Farmer advisory and unions Landbo Limfjord
Water producers and suppliers of drinking water Danish Water Works
Waterworks Vester Hjerk
Regional/national government Stakeholder Advisory Group
Local government Municipality of Skive
Inhabitants – consumers Inhabitants of the action lab area
The Danish Nature Conservation Organisation
Wexford
  • There is a good awareness of PPPs, such as MCPA, potentially causing a problem for Irish drinking water. The number of PPP failures has increased in recent years. Seven suppliers, serving; 60,500 people have been reported to have a problem with MCPA in Ireland.

  • There is a poor knowledge on the underlying processes of MCPA reaching water. It was recognized that we need more knowledge on the transfer pathways and the residence time/breakdown.

  • There was a perception that MCPA is only incidentally lost to water via surface pathways.

  • Due to the heterogeneity of the landscape a targeted approach supported by science is needed to mitigate MCPA loss to water

Action lab leader(s) Teagasc Exchange – bilateral conversation
Exchange – multi-actor conversation
Exchange – questionnaire/survey
Exchange –field visit
Exchange – interactive workshop
Chemical producers Animal and Plant Health Association (APHA)
Hygeia Chemicals Ltd.
NUFARM
Research Ulster University Teagasc Students
Agricultural Catchments Programme
Farmers Famers of the catchments
Farmer unions and advisories Teagasc advisors
Agricultural Sustainability Support Advisors (ASSA)
Water producers and suppliers of drinking water Irish Water
National Federation of Group Water Scheme (NFGWS)
Regional/national government Department of Agriculture Food and the Marine
Local Authority Waters Programme (LAWPRO)
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
Pesticide Control Division of the Department of Agriculture Food and the Marine
Local government Wexford County Council
Food processors and distributers Glanbia
Inhabitants – consumers Citizens – rural dwellers
Val Tidone
  • No data about the impact of viticulture on groundwater quality of Tidone Valley was available at the beginning of the project. Institutional data is poor for this area, but data on groundwater quality of Piacenza province is available in ARPAE's websites.

  • Most of the farmers are not aware of the problem. There is no direct link between the monitoring results and the communication to them.

  • One cooperative and one farm have set-up their organisation and production in compliance with the Italian standard VIVA using indicators for the improvement of their social, environmental and economic performance.

Action lab leader(s) UCSC(University)
ARPAE-ER (Environmental Agency)
APCS (consumer organisation)
Informing – newsletter
Informing – presentation
Informing - leaflet
Exchange – bilateral conversation
Exchange – multi-actor conversation
Exchange – questionnaire/survey
Exchange – implementation
Exchange - field visit
Exchange – interactive workshop
Research Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore
Farmers Farmers of the Val Tidone catchment
Farmer advisory and unions Confagricoltura (farmer representative) Coldiretti (farmer representative)
CIA (farmer representative)
Consorzio Fitosanitario (farmers advisory)
Axe Environment (farmers advisory)
Water producers and suppliers of drinking water IRETI (drinking water production, supply and treatment)
River basin/ environmental protection agency Po River Hydrographic District Basin Authority (river basin agency)
ARPAE (Environmental protection agency)
Regional/national government Piacenza (government provincial level)
Regione Emilia Romagna (government regional level)
Local government Borgonovo (municipality)
Ziano (municipality)
Castel San Giovanni (municipality)
Pianello (municipality)
Alta Val Tidone (municipality)
Local health agency AUSL
Provincial reclamation authority, Consorzio di Bonifica Piacenza
Food trader – Industry winery Vicobarone winery - cellar (Cantina Vicobarone) (food processor and trader)
Val Tidone winery - cellar (Cantina Val Tidone) (food processor and trader)
Consorzio vini DOC Colli Piacentini (local business)
Inhabitants - consumers Consumer associations
Gowienica
  • The Gowienica Miedwaińska River Basin has been operating as a nitrate vulnerable zone for 12 years until now and still some farmers have very little knowledge on this subject.

  • Lack of interest (or little interest) of inhabitants in the water quality state in the catchment.

  • Some farmers did not know that the Gowienica Miedwianska is a river.

  • The problem of water quality is known by farmers and by institutions related to water management and agriculture (NVZ area).

  • Non-agricultural and non-water management companies and inhabitants are not aware of the existing problem.

  • Non-agricultural local companies are not aware of the problem of water quality in the Gowienica river catchment. They assess surface and groundwater as of good quality. The tap water supplied to the recipients mentioned above is also assessed by them as of good quality.

Action lab leader(s) Polish Geological Institute - National Research Institute (PGI-NRI) Institute of Technology and Life Sciences (ITP) West Pomeranian University of Technology (ZUT) Informing – newsletter
Informing - leaflet
Exchange – bilateral conversation
Exchange – multi-actor conversation
Exchange – questionnaire/survey
Exchange – demonstration/field visit
Exchange – interactive workshop
Farmers Farmers of the Gowienica river catchment
Farmer advisory and unions West Pomeranian Farmer's Advisory Centre (ZODR)
Water producers and suppliers of drinking water Szczecin Water Services West Pomeranian Water Services
Regional/national government Department of Environmental Protection, Szczecin City Hall
Regional Water Management Authority, National State Water Farm Polish Waters (RWMA)
Voivodship Inspectorate for Environmental Protection (VIEP)
Regional Directorate for Environmental Protection (RDOŚ)
West Pomeranian Board of Land Reclamation and Water Facilities in Szczecin (operated until 31.12.2017)
Voivodship Fund for Environmental Protection and Water Management Agency for the Restructuring and Modernization of Agriculture (ARMA)
Faculty of Infrastructure, Agriculture and Regional Development
Westpomeranian Voivodeship Office
Local government Warnice Borough Stargard Borough
Food processors and distributers Polish Sugar Inc.
Inhabitants - consumers Inhabitants
Mara
  • Most farmers are not aware that there are some problems related to bad agricultural practices. And if they acknowledge this, they still consider it as a small problem and certainly not their individual problem.

Action lab leader(s) Universitatea Tehnica CLUJ-NAPOCA (UTC)
Ecologic (civil society organisation)
Informing – newsletter
Exchange – bilateral conversation
Exchange – multi-actor conversation
Exchange – questionnaire/survey
Exchange – demonstration/field visit
Exchange – interactive workshop
Research Universities
Experts
Students
Farmers Farmers of the Mara river catchment
Farmer unions Farmer association
Regional/national government EPA Maramures
Directorate of Agriculture Maramures
Water Directorate Maramures
Local government Ocna Sugatag Municipality
County Council Maramures
Budesti Commune
Industry - Tourism Tour operators
Ecotourism destination
Ocna Sugatag Tourism Promotion Center
Inhabitants - consumers Inhabitants of the villages
Children
Priest
Lower Llobregat
  • Basically, all stakeholders, including farmers and citizens, are aware of the general bad quality of the water, but due to the complexity of the area it is difficult to know which activities are the most polluting.

  • Farmers believe that agriculture is not the main source of pollution. On the contrary, agriculture in is perceived as beneficial to protect the area from further urban expansion.

  • Farmers accept the use of treated wastewater for irrigation but demand improvement of its quality and control of specific parameters, as well as additional infrastructures to protect their crops from flooding or water shortages.

Action lab leader(s) IDAEA-CSIC (research organization, action lab leader)
AB (local drinking water company)
CUADLL (local water administration)
CPABLL (local government)
Informing – newsletter
Informing – project presentation and flyers
Informing – press release
Exchange – bilateral conversation
Exchange – multi-actor conversation
Exchange – questionnaire/survey
Exchange – demonstration/field visit
Exchange – interactive workshop
Informing and exchange – conference
Research Agricultural Machinery Unity (UMA) of the Polytechnic University of Catalonia (UMA-UPC)
Higher School of Agriculture of Barcelona attached to Polytechnic University of Catalonia (ESAB-UPC)
University of Barcelona (UB)
IRTA - research institute of the Government of Catalonia adscribed to the Department of Agriculture
Ilersap (analytical company)
Students
Farmers Famers of the Llobregat delta catchment
Farmer advisory and unions Unió de Pagesos (major agriculture trade union)
ADV Horta (farmers advisory)
ADV Fruita (farmers advisory)
Water producers and suppliers of drinking water ATLL
Aigües d'El Prat
FCC Aqualia SA
Regional/national government Catalan Water Agency (ACA, basin water authority)
Public Health Secretary (PHS) (Ministry of Health of Catalonia)
Department of Agriculture, livestock, fisheries and food (Catalan government)
AMB (Metropolitan area of Barcelona)
Local government Consortium of the Delta del Llobregat
Municipalities Parc Agrari del Baix Llobregat: Palleja, Sant Vicenç dels Horts, Santa Coloma de Cervelló, Sant Boi de Llobregat, El Prat de Llobreta, Viladecans, Gavà, Castelldefels, El Papiol, Molins de Rei, Sant Feliu de Llobregat, Sant Joan Despí, Cornellà de Llobregat i l'Hospitalet de Llobregat.
Food processors and distributers Mercabarna (wholesale market for the city of Barcelona)
Inhabitants - consumers Inhabitants of the action lab area