Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 31;11(9):835. doi: 10.3390/mi11090835

Table 3.

Artificial biomimetic surface.

Substratum Material Natural Templates Fabrication Method Geometrical Features Wettability Bactericidal Efficacy Lethality Reference
Silicon Dragonfly Reactive-ion beam etching Height 500 nm Hydrophilic
Contact angle 80°
Killing rate
P. aeruginosa: 4.3 × 105 per cm−2min−1
S. aureus: 4.5 × 105 per cm−2min−1
B. subtilis: 1.4 × 105 per cm−2min−1
Gram-negative bacteria
Gram-positive bacteria
Spores
[62]
Silicon Dragonfly Deep reactive ion etching Height 4 μm
Diameter 220 nm
Hydrophobic
Contact angle 154°
86% of S. aureus and 83% of E. coli were non-viable after 3 h incubation Gram-positive bacteria
Gram-negative bacteria
Mammalian cell
[66]
PMMA Cicada Soft lithography Height 210–300 nm
Spacing 100–380 nm
Width 70–215 nm
N/A E. coli: 16–141% higher dead fraction than a flat film Gram-negative bacteria [67]
Silicon Cicada Metal assisted etching Height 200 nm
Pitch 200 nm
Width 150 nm
E. coli: 24 h from 3.9 × 106 CFU/mL to 1 CFU/mL Gram-negative bacteria [68]
Quartz N/A Nanosphere lithography Height 300 nm
Apex diameter 10 nm
Hydrophilic
Contact angle ~ 0°
Kill ~38,000 P. aeruginosa and ~27,000 E. coli cm−2min−1 Gram-negative bacteria [69]
PMMA Moth-eye Thermal polymer nanoimprint Height 350 nm
Width 80 nm
Pitch 250 nm
Aspect ratio 4.3
Hydrophobic
135 ± 4°
Percentage of non-viable bacteria are 55%, 45%, 30% for S. aureus, E. coli, and P. aeruginosa respectively Gram-positive bacteria
Gram-negative bacteria
[70]
Silicon Cicada Deep ultraviolet immersion lithography
Plasma etching
Diameter 35 nm
Periodicity 90 nm
Increasing height 220, 360, 420 nm
N/A 360 nm-height 95 ± 5% P. aeruginosa and 83 ± 12% S. aureus cell death Gram-negative bacteria
Gram-positive bacteria
[59]