Table 4.
Estimated mean* |
Cohen's d effect size from assessment |
Percentage change in estimated mean*from assessment |
Reliable treatment outcome† |
|||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Assessment | Post-treatment | 3 month follow-up | To post-treatment | To 3 month follow-up | To post-treatment | To 3 month follow-up | Deterioration | Recovery | ||
Depression (Patient Health Questionnaire-9; n=21 745) | 13·6 (5·9) | 6·5 (4·2) | 6·5 (4·4) | 1·40 (1·37–1·43) | 1·36 (1·34–1·38) | 52·2% (51·6–52·8) | 52·2% (51·5–52·9) | 184/13 058 (1·4%) | 5419/9105 (59·5%) | |
Anxiety (Generalized Anxiety Disorder 7-Item Scale; n=21 745) | 12·0 (5·0) | 5·7 (3·6) | 5·7 (3·8) | 1·45 (1·42–1·47) | 1·42 (1·40–1·44) | 52·5% (52·1–52·9) | 52·5% (52·1–52·9) | 282/13 058 (2·2%) | 5862/9810 (59·8%) | |
Distress (Kessler Psychological Distress 10-Item Scale; n=21 745) | 30·1 (6·9) | 20·8 (6·2) | 20·5 (6·4) | 1·42 (1·40–1·44) | 1·44 (1·42–1·46) | 46·3% (45·9–46·7)‡ | 47·8% (47·3–48·2)‡ | .. | .. | |
Functional effect (Kessler Psychological Distress 10-Item Plus Scale; n=5120) | ||||||||||
Whole days out of role | 5·4 (7·5) | 3·5 (6·2) | 3·3 (6·4) | 0·28 (0·25–0·31) | 0·30 (0·28–0·32) | 35·2% (33·7–36·7) | 38·9% (37·2–40·6) | .. | .. | |
Part days out of role | 9·3 (8·4) | 6·0 (7·2) | 5·8 (7·4) | 0·42 (0·39–0·45) | 0·44 (0·42–0·46) | 35·5% (34·4–36·6) | 37·6% (36·6–38·7) | .. | .. |
Data are mean (SD), % change (95% CI), effect size (95% CI), or n/N (%); for reliable recovery, numerators are number of patients meeting thresholds for reliable recovery and denominators are number of patients with clinically significant symptoms at assessment and complete post-treatment questionnaires, and for reliable deterioration, numerators are number of patients meeting threshold for reliable deterioration and denominators are number of patients who completed the post-treatment questionnaires.
Estimated marginal means derived from generalised estimating equation modelling.
Reliable deterioration and reliable recovery calculated from actual scores post-treatment.
After transformation to 0–40 scale for calculation of percentage change from scores of 10–50.