Skip to main content
. 2020 May 21;8(5):e2823. doi: 10.1097/GOX.0000000000002823

Table 3.

Risk of Bias of Each of the Studies

Article Selection Bias Recall Bias Observer Bias Perception Bias
Agu et al20 Low; 2,545 participants selected from the population of Enugu, Nigeria Not applicable High; several residents travelled to different locations to administer questionnaires Low; survey contained multiple choice questions only
Irabor et al21 Low; participants recruited among surgeons from various departments in a hospital Not applicable Unclear Low; survey contained multiple choice questions only
Nnabugwu et al22 Low; 369 patients recruited from various surgical departments in a hospital Low; patients were given questionnaire on day before surgery High; 3 interns administered the questionnaires High; questionnaire contained mostly free-hand answers
Ochieng et al23 Low; participants recruited among surgeons from 3 different hospitals Not applicable Unclear High; semistructured interviews used mainly qualitative approach
Ochieng et al24 Low; participants recruited among patients in various departments of a hospital Low; participants interviewed within 2 weeks of surgery Unclear High; authors reviewed semistructured interviews
Sanwal et al25 Moderate/high; 100 patients selected from the general surgery department Low; questionnaire administered within a week of surgery Unclear Unclear
Sceats et al26 High; participants selected among patients who underwent hernia repair during an STSM Low; interviews conducted in the same session as the informed consent session Moderate; 3 researchers interpreted the data High; authors reviewed video interviews
Sutton et al27 High; participant cohort selected from patients undergoing surgery on a STSM Low; patients were given the survey on the day of surgery Unclear Low; survey contained multiple choice questions only
Teshome et al28 High; participants selected among patients in an Obstetrics and Gynecology department Low; interviews conducted immediately after discharge High; questionnaire administered by several nurses High; questionnaires were interview based
Walker et al29 High; patients were recruited if received hand surgery on STSM Low; 2 surveys given, one preoperative and one immediately postoperative Unclear Moderate; most of the survey was multiple choice; however, free-hand answers were also part of the assessment
White et al30 High; patients were recruited if received plastic/maxfax/ortho interventions on Mercy Ships High; patients were asked to recall experiences from several years before the interviews High; interviews were conducted by several members of staff High; semistructured interviews were conducted