Table 1.
Study | Participant characteristics | Location | Setting | Methodology | Questionnaire used on help-seeking | Quality assessment score |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Abe-Kim et al. (2007) [10] Supplementary paper: Nguyen and Lee (2010) |
508 Filipino Americans in multi-ethnic study, with 53.74% (n = 273) females and 46.26% (n = 235) males and mean age of 41.904 (SD 16.11) | US | Community-based |
Quantitative Cross-sectional study design (derived from National Latino and Asian American Study, 2002–2003) |
Study-specific questionnaire on help-seeking sources, need for services, treatment satisfaction | Strong* |
Bernardo and Estrellado (2017) [8] | 70 Filipino women, with mean age of 39.13 (SD 9.175) | Philippines | Center-based women shelters |
Quantitative Cross-sectional study design |
Help-seeking intention scale Locus of hope scale |
Moderate* |
Cabbigat and Kangas (2017) | 117 Filipinos with 80.34% (n = 94) females and 19.66% (n = 23) males and mean age of 42.66 (SD 8.268) | Philippines | Local government, social welfare agencies and non-government organizations |
Quantitative Cohort analytic study design |
Study-specific questionnaire on help-seeking behavior Help-seeking preferences Attitudes Towards Services for Children and Adolescents (parent-report section of the child and adolescent services assessment) |
Moderate* |
David (2010) [34] | 118 Filipino Americans with 47.46% (n = 56) females and 52.54% (n = 62) males and mean age of 30.20 (SD = 10.65) | US | Community-based |
Quantitative Cross-sectional study design |
Inventory of attitudes toward seeking mental health services Cultural mistrust inventory Loss of Face Questionnaire Asian value scale |
Moderate* |
Gong et al. (2003) [13] Supplementary papers: |
2285 Filipino Americans, with 50.60% (n = 1156) females and 49.40% (n = 1128) males and mean age of 41.662 (SD 13.398) | US | Community-based |
Quantitative Cross-sectional study design (derived from Filipino American Epidemiological Study, 1995–1999) |
Study-specific questionnaire on help-seeking based on Kleinman (1978) typology of help-seeking sources: lay system, professional care system and folk system Research-designed questionnaire on loss of face |
Moderate* |
Green and Ayalon (2016) [6] | 85 Filipino migrant home care workers with 86% (n = 73) females and 14% (n = 12) males and mean age of 37.04 (SD 6.70) | Israel | Community-based |
Quantitative Cross-sectional study design |
Study-specific questionnaire on social support, formal and informal report of abuse | Strong* |
Hechanova et al. (2013) [31] Supplementary paper: Hechanova et al. (2011) |
365 overseas Filipino workers with 52.88% (n = 193) females and 47.12% (n = 172) males and mean age of 33.14 (SD 7.72) | Philippines with overseas Filipino participants mostly in Middle East | Employment agencies and university-based counseling centers | Mixed methods using surveys, interviews and chat conversations |
Semi-structured open-ended questionnaire Intention to seek counseling inventory (adapted version) |
Weak*/ Fair** |
Hermannsdottir and Aegisdottir (2016) | 209 Filipino immigrants with 67% (n = 140) females and 33% (n = 69) males and mean age of 38.72 (SD 11.33) | Iceland | Community-based |
Quantitative Cross-sectional study design |
Psychological help-seeking attitudes and intentions Beliefs about psychological services scale Study-specific questionnaire on system barriers |
Moderate* |
Ho et al. (2018) [7] | 175 Filipino participants for survey and focus group discussion with 45.71% (n = 80) females and 54.29% (n = 95) males and mean age of 30.49 (SD 9.70) | Multi-country study in Fiji, Cambodia and the Philippines | Community-based | Mixed methods using surveys and focus group discussions |
Attitudes and understanding towards mental disorder Attitudes Toward Seeking Professional Psychological Help—Short Form and semi-structured guide for interview and focus group discussion Semi-structured interview guide for focus group discussion |
Moderate */Good** |
Nguyen (2011) [30] Supplementary paper: Nguyen (2012) |
269 Filipino Americans in multi-ethnic study, with 57.25% (n = 154) females and 42.75% (n = 115) males and mean age of 61.8 (SD 9.9) | US | Community-based |
Quantitative Cross-sectional study design (derived from California Health Interview Survey, 2001) |
Study-specific questionnaire | Strong* |
Shoultz et al. (2010) [32] | 10 Filipino American women with age range from 34 to 52 years old | US | Women’s support agency | Mixed methods using surveys, individual interviews and focus group discussions |
Semi-structured interview guide on help-seeking behavior Perceptions of the Acceptability of violence |
Weak* / Good** |
Straiton et al. (2018) [14] Supplementary paper: Straiton et al. (2017) [67] |
14 Filipino women with mean age of 33.7 | Norway | Community-based | Qualitative using in-depth interviews | Semi-structured interview guide with open-ended questions | Good** |
Thompson et al. (2002a) [33] Supplement papers: Kelaher et al. (2000), Thompson et al. (2002b) [72] |
487 Filipino women participated with mean age of 41.034 (SD 11.19) | Australia | Community-based | Mixed methods using multiple follow-up surveys, in-depth interviews and focus group discussions (derived from Filipina cohort of Australian Longitudinal Study on Women’s Health, 1996) |
Semi-structured interview guide General Health Questionnaire |
Strong*/Good** |
Tuliao et al. (2016) [12] Supplementary paper: Tuliao and Velasquez (2017) |
359 Filipino university students with 52.09% (n = 187) females and 47.91% (n = 172) males and mean age of 17.69 (SD 0.97) | Philippines | University-based |
Quantitative Cross-sectional study design |
Perceived likelihood of seeking help (adapted version) Online counselling attitude scale Self-stigma of seeking help scale Self-concealment scale Interpersonal support evaluation list Inventory of attitudes toward seeking mental health services Loss of face scale Intent to seek counseling inventory General Help Seeking Questionnaire |
Moderate* |
Vahabi and Wong (2017) [16] | 25 Filipino women, age range from 25 to 60 years old | Canada | Community-based |
Qualitative Focus group discussion |
Semi-structured focus group discussion guide | Good** |
*Quality assessment based on the criteria of EPHPP Quality Assessment Tool for quantitative studies
**Quality assessment based on the criteria of CASP Qualitative Checklist for qualitative studies