Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 20;6(10):e05302. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2020.e05302

Table 7.

Compositions and OAV of odorous compounds in three different attractants.

Compounds RI1 KI2 Content (mg/kg)
Threshold3 (mg/kg) OAV
Chicken liver
L. edodes
T. molitor
Chicken liver
L. edodes
T. molitor
SPME SDE SPME SDE SPME SDE SPME SDE SPME SDE SPME SDE
Alcohols
methyl mercaptan 680 675 0.036 -4 0.040 - - - 0.00024 151.42 - 165.72 - - -
amyl alcohol 1253 1255 - - Tr5 2.710 Tr 1.656 0.14 - - - 19.26 - 11.82
3-octanol 1388 1394 0.034 - 0.037 - Tr - 0.02 1.69 - 1.85 - - -
furfuryl mercaptan 1419 1430 - 16.985 - - Tr 18.898 0.00002 - 8.49×105 - - - 9.45×105
1-octen-3-ol 1457 1456 0.156 - 0.355 20.948 0.016 - 0.026 6.02 - 13.66 805.71 0.63 -
2-ethyl-1-hexanol 1473 1484 0.023 - Tr - Tr - 0.26 0.09 - - - - -
Octanol 1532 1564 0.024 - 0.013 - Tr - 0.037 0.65 - 0.36 - - -
Furfuryl alcohol 1625 1660 0.144 71.027 - - Tr 7.993 2 0.07 35.51 - - - 3.99
phenethyl alcohol 1918 1921 - - 0.022 5.671 - - 0.07 - - 0.32 81.01 - -
Esters
dextro-bornyl acetate 1576 1582 - - Tr 4.877 - - 0.44 - - - 11.08 - -
gamma-butyrolactone 1640 1643 0.029 6.095 Tr - Tr - 0.0008 36.63 7618.69 - - - -
ethyl myristate 2089 2070 Tr 4.243 Tr - Tr - 0.18 - 23.57 - - - -
ethyl palmitate 2221 2250 - 4.665 - 10.402 - - 2 - 2.33 - 5.20 - -
Acids
acetic acid 1455 1460 0.1528 44.671 0.031 16.348 0.047 18.898 0.025 6.11 1786.83 1.24 653.93 1.89 755.93
Formic acid 1461 1470 Tr - Tr - Tr - 14.5 - - - - - -
Valeric acid 1721 1734 0.014 - - - - 0.864 0.001 13.85 - - - - 864.41
hexanoic acid 1853 1831 0.031 3.460 0.052 8.948 0.101 36.051 0.012 2.53 288.33 4.34 745.70 8.43 3004.24
octanoic acid 2020 2039 0.039 - 0.044 - 0.067 2.695 0.037 1.06 - 1.2 - 1.82 72.84
lauric acid 2458 2493 - - - 43.555 - - 0.1 - - 0.04 435.55 0.02 -
myristic acid 2715 2716 0.011 79.365 Tr - - - 10 0.001 7.94 - - - -
palmitic acid 2901 2890 - 107.851 - - - 147.947 10 - 10.78 - - - 14.79
Aldehydes
isovaleraldehyde 918 924 0.082 - 0.040 - - - 0.003 27.31 - 13.26 - - -
hexanal 1077 1083 Tr 14.243 Tr 19.226 Tr 13.429 0.03 - 474.77 - 640.86 - 447.65
(E)-2-pentenal 1149 1134 - 0.914 0.012 18.213 - 1.893 1.4 - 0.65 0.01 13.01 - 1.35
heptanal 1187 1186 - - - 1.013 - 0.819 0.14 - - - 7.24 - 5.85
3-methyl-2-butenal 1191 1206 - 14.601 - 14.393 - 14.402 0.5 - 29.2 - 28.77 - 28.8
Octanal 1295 1290 - - Tr 2.722 Tr 2.384 0.021 - - - 129.58 - 113.53
nonanal 1393 1396 0.072 2.291 0.019 2.226 0.020 1.875 0.02 3.58 114.54 0.96 111.29 0.98 93.73
furfural 1468 1476 0.253 1714.472 0.114 524.964 0.181 1337.541 0.25 1.01 6857.87 0.46 2099.87 0.72 5350.17
methional 1480 1480 Tr 31.691 - 10.639 - 2.311 0.06 0.12 528.19 - 177.31 - 38.51
benzaldehyde 1519 1530 0.295 4.801 0.395 5.897 0.611 11.667 0.61 0.48 7.87 0.65 9.67 1.01 19.13
5-methyl furfural 1549 1558 - 1.045 - - - 1.559 1 - 1.04 - - - 1.56
para-tolualdehyde 1622 1638 0.020 - Tr - Tr - 0.0012 16.57 - - - - -
phenyl acetaldehyde 1660 1650 0.053 65.81 - - 0.015 4.864 0.007 7.60 9401.44 - - 2.12 694.92
bread thiophene 1745 1755 0.150 14.362 Tr 3.155 0.013 7.226 0.0045 33.32 3191.56 0.79 701.07 2.87 1605.78
2-undecenal 1761 1759 - - - 19.516 - - 0.1 - - - 195.16 - -
2,4-decadienal 1785 1797 - - - 9.129 - - 0.0001 - - - 9.13×104 - -
2-dodecenal 1850 1842 - - - 20.019 - - 0.0014 - - - 1.43×104 - -
cinnamaldehyde 2058 2043 0.032 - Tr - Tr - 0.14 0.23 - - - - -
Ketones
3-hexanone 1040 1050 - 7.395 - - - 6.056 0.06 - 123.24 - - - 100.94
3-penten-2-one 1119 1126 - - - 4.916 Tr 3.463 0.07 - - - 70.23 - 49.47
2-heptanone 1190 1189 - - - - Tr - 0.045 - - - - - -
coffee furanone 1240 1242 - 3.317 - 3.052 Tr 3.271 0.25 - 13.27 - 12.21 - 13.08
1-octen-3-one 1314 1305 0.098 - 0.043 - - - 0.004 24.39 - 10.66 - - -
3-octen-2-one 1425 1408 - - - - Tr - 0.02 - - - - - -
3-mercapto-2-pentanone 1350 1343 0.010 - - - 0.010 1.689 0.0007 8.86 - - - 10.11 2413.24
acetophenone 1634 1645 0.054 - 0.010 - 0.014 - 0.065 0.84 - 0.16 - 0.21 -
para-methylacetophenone 1800 1797 0.012 - Tr - Tr - 0.01 1.25 - - - - -
(E)-geranyl acetone 1846 1858 0.023 - Tr - - - 0.186 0.13 - - - - -
alpha-ionone 1861 1860 - - 0.028 - 0.010 - 0.0016 - - 17.61 - 4.43 -
beta-ionone 1931 1947 0.024 - 0.019 - - - 0.0012 19.81 - 16.26 - - -
Heterocyclics
thiophene 1015 1021 - - - 14.864 - - 0.006 - - - 2477.42 - -
2-methyl thiophene 1121 1100 0.044 5.780 0.017 8.961 Tr 4.278 0.08 0.55 72.25 0.21 112.02 - 53.46
2-pentyl furan 1241 1231 0.010 0.392 Tr - 0.018 3.017 0.27 0.04 1.45 - - 0.07 11.17
3,4-dimethyl thiophene 1255 1250 - - Tr 5.903 - - 0.008 - - - 737.90 - -
fish thiol 1306 1305 - - - - 0.065 - 0.00007 - - - - 927.97 -
2,5-dimethyl pyrazine 1357 1348 - - - - Tr - 0.87 - - - - - -
2,3,5-trimethyl pyrazine 1426 1422 - - - - Tr - 0.05 - - - - - -
2-acetyl furan 1495 1488 - 3.472 - - - 2.842 10 - 0.35 - - - 0.28
1-furfuryl pyrrole 1829 1820 Tr - - - - - 0.1 - - - - - -
2-acetyl pyrrole 1989 1974 Tr 1.733 - - Tr 2.848 2 - 0.87 - - - 1.42
methyl 2-methyl-3-furyl disulfide 2105 2110 0.855 - 0.012 - 0.063 - 0.00001 8.55×104 - 1188.58 - 6319.92 -
sulfurol 2305 2302 0.474 15.157 0.094 - 0.120 37.575 0.03 15.80 505.24 3.13 - 4 1252.17
indole 2469 2453 0.017 - - - - - 0.0004 43.25 - - - - -
Phenols
2-(methyl thio) phenol 1870 1873 - 3.911 - - - - 0.8 - 4.90 - - - -
phenol 1994 1989 0.037 - Tr - 0.013 - 0.046 0.80 - - - 0.29 -
1

Retention index was calculated in agreement with literature value.

2

Kováts indices for a HP-INNOWAX column [22].

3

Odor thresholds were taken from Van Gemert [23].

4

Not detected.

5

Compositional values less than 0.01 % are noted as traces (Tr).