Table 1.
Series | Study duration | Publication year | Test | Design | Number of patients | Impact of molecular testing |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Aragon Han, P. et al. (43) | 2009–2013 | 2014 | GEC, Mutation Panel | Retrospective | 87 | 78/87 (90%) no change in management 9/87 (10%) surgical plan altered 6/9 (67%) change inappropriate 5/6 (83%) inappropriately overtreated |
Noureldine, S. et al. (44) | 2012–2014 | 2015 | GEC | Retrospective | 273 | 250/273 (92%) no change in management 23/273 (8%) surgical plan altered 16/23 (73%) inappropriately overtreated |
Marti, J. et al. (22) | 2013–2014 | 2015 | GEC | Retrospective | 165 | At cancer center: 42/70 (60%) GEC suspicious lesions resected 18/42 (43%) GEC suspicious resected lesions ultimately benign (inappropriately overtreated) At general hospital: 21/34 (62%) GEC suspicious lesions resected 18/21 (86%) GEC suspicious resected lesions ultimately benign (inappropriately overtreated) |
Noureldine, S. et al. (45) | 2014–2015 | 2016 | GEC, ThyroSeq, Mutation Panel | Prospective | 140 | 129/140 (92%) no change in management 11/140 (8%) surgical plan altered 10/11 (91%) inappropriately overtreated |
Taye, A. et al. (28) | 2014–2016 | 2018 | ThyroSeq | Retrospective | 156 | 37/51 (73%) ThyroSeq suspicious lesions resected 29/37 (78%) ThyroSeq suspicious resected lesions ultimately benign (inappropriately overtreated) |