Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 9;11:590128. doi: 10.3389/fendo.2020.590128

Table 1.

Summary of investigations evaluating impact of molecular testing on surgical management and outcomes.

Series Study duration Publication year Test Design Number of patients Impact of molecular testing
Aragon Han, P. et al. (43) 2009–2013 2014 GEC, Mutation Panel Retrospective 87 78/87 (90%) no change in management
9/87 (10%) surgical plan altered
6/9 (67%) change inappropriate
5/6 (83%) inappropriately overtreated
Noureldine, S. et al. (44) 2012–2014 2015 GEC Retrospective 273 250/273 (92%) no change in management
23/273 (8%) surgical plan altered
16/23 (73%) inappropriately overtreated
Marti, J. et al. (22) 2013–2014 2015 GEC Retrospective 165 At cancer center:
42/70 (60%) GEC suspicious lesions resected
18/42 (43%) GEC suspicious resected lesions ultimately benign (inappropriately overtreated)
At general hospital:
21/34 (62%) GEC suspicious lesions resected
18/21 (86%) GEC suspicious resected lesions ultimately benign (inappropriately overtreated)
Noureldine, S. et al. (45) 2014–2015 2016 GEC, ThyroSeq, Mutation Panel Prospective 140 129/140 (92%) no change in management
11/140 (8%) surgical plan altered
10/11 (91%) inappropriately overtreated
Taye, A. et al. (28) 2014–2016 2018 ThyroSeq Retrospective 156 37/51 (73%) ThyroSeq suspicious lesions resected
29/37 (78%) ThyroSeq suspicious resected lesions ultimately benign (inappropriately overtreated)