Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 28;9(9):882–889. doi: 10.1530/EC-20-0296

Table 1.

The characteristics of included studies in current meta-analysis.

First author, year
Country
Ethnicity
Sample size
Genotypes (wtwt/wtmt/mtmt)
P-value for HWE
NOS score
Cases
Controls
ApaI rs7975232
 Ahmad 2018 India Mixed 254/254 62/140/52 75/134/45 0.264 7
 Castelán-Martínez 2015 Mexico Mixed 387/147 141/160/86 46/75/26 0.631 7
 Chen 2007 China Asian 155/113 108/40/7 60/41/12 0.223 7
 Dabirnia 2016 Iran Mixed 50/50 24/25/1 30/18/2 0.729 7
 Douroudis 2003 Hellenic Republic Caucasian 35/44 11/14/10 17/26/1 0.016 7
 Duman 2004 Turkey Caucasian 75/66 13/56/6 15/45/6 0.002 7
 Dundar 2009 Turkey Caucasian 112/24 26/61/25 8/14/2 0.231 7
 Ge 2009 China Asian 353/208 160/157/36 102/84/22 0.453 8
 González-Mercado 2013 Mexico Mixed 232/87 79/118/35 29/41/17 0.715 7
 Gu 2010 China Asian 186/148 79/86/21 74/61/13 0.932 7
 Iván 2008 Chile Caucasian 67/59 25/31/11 18/27/14 0.536 7
 Kim 2015 Korea Asian 153/47 97/53/3 24/19/4 0.931 7
 Langdahl 2000 Denmark Caucasian 78/74 22/44/12 25/32/17 0.283 7
 Liang 2002 China Asian 30/30 20/6/4 27/2/1 0.011 7
 Luan 2011 China Asian 140/88 71/56/13 44/34/10 0.390 7
 Marozik 2013 Belarus Caucasian 54/77 7/24/23 29/34/14 0.472 7
 Marozik 2018 Lithuania Caucasian 149/172 27/67/55 60/74/38 0.105 7
 Meng 2018 China Asian 90/246 60/25/5 161/69/16 0.028 8
 Mitra 2006 India Mixed 119/97 50/44/25 34/33/30 0.002 7
 Mosaad 2014 Egypt Mixed 30/150 13/15/2 69/71/10 0.142 7
 Riggs 1995 USA Mixed 30/128 12/19/9 38/59/31 0.394 7
 Sassi 2015 Tunisia Mixed 335/231 130/143/62 90/115/26 0.233 7
 Seremak-Mrozikiewicz 2009 Poland Caucasian 163/63 35/82/46 12/32/19 0.821 7
 Tanriover 2010 Turkey Caucasian 50/50 15/23/12 22/15/13 0.007 8
 Uysal 2008 Turkey Caucasian 100/146 35/50/15 46/79/21 0.165 7
 Vandevyver 1997 Belgium Caucasian 87/699 20/45/22 197/375/127 0.027 8
 Wu 2016 China Asian 79/234 43/27/9 105/111/18 0.123 7
 Wu 2019 China Asian 610/616 331/218/61 366/207/43 0.070 8
 Xie 2005 China Asian 295/56 240/43/12 34/16/6 0.075 7
 Yoldemir 2011 Turkey Caucasian 130/130 34/60/36 31/73/26 0.155 7
 Zajickova 2002 Czech Republic Caucasian 65/33 23/33/9 10/17/6 0.793 7
BsmI rs1544410
 Ahmad 2018 India Mixed 254/254 54/137/63 54/152/48 0.002 7
 Berg 1996 Norway Caucasian 19/30 4/8/7 8/11/11 0.156 7
 Boroń 2015 Poland Caucasian 278/292 101/121/56 128/113/51 0.004 7
 Cheishvili 2017 Israel Mixed 37/37 13/11/13 15/12/10 0.039 7
 Chen 2003 China Asian 78/81 65/13/0 69/12/0 0.472 7
 Douroudis 2003 Hellenic Republic Caucasian 35/44 20/12/3 29/10/5 0.019 7
 Duman 2004 Kuwait Mixed 75/66 54/18/3 42/17/7 0.021 7
 Efesoy 2011 Turkey Caucasian 40/30 12/23/5 10/15/5 0.876 7
 Ge 2009 China Asian 353/208 314/33/6 192/12/4 <0.001 8
 Gennari 1998 Italy Caucasian 155/136 23/92/40 49/76/11 0.013 7
 González-Mercado 2013 Mexico Mixed 232/88 143/76/13 46/38/4 0.267 7
 Houston 1996 UK Caucasian 44/44 17/19/8 16/19/9 0.450 7
 Huang 2000 China Asian 14/27 13/1/0 26/1/0 0.922 7
 Hussien 2013 Egypt Mixed 150/50 50/57/43 19/21/10 0.351 7
 Iván 2008 Chile Caucasian 67/59 10/46/11 13/37/9 0.046 7
 Kim 2015 Korea Asian 153/47 142/11/0 42/5/0 0.700 7
 Langdahl 2000 Denmark Caucasian 80/80 23/38/19 25/34/21 0.186 7
 Li 2000 China Asian 96/42 54/36/6 20/21/1 0.095 7
 Liang 2002 China Asian 30/30 28/1/1 30/0/0 NA 7
 Lim 1995 Korea Asian 72/70 61/9/2 60/9/1 0.349 7
 Liu 2005 China Asian 56/89 50/6/0 76/11/2 0.060 7
 Marozik 2013 Belarus Caucasian 54/77 11/31/12 40/26/11 0.062 7
 Marozik 2018 Lithuania Caucasian 149/172 32/64/53 64/73/35 0.098 7
 Melhus 1994 Sweden Caucasian 70/76 14/29/27 34/35/7 0.637 8
 Mencej-Bedrac 2009 Slovenia Caucasian 240/228 103/110/27 88/100/40 0.215 8
 Meng 2017 China Asian 90/246 74/12/4 216/24/6 <0.001 7
 Mitra 2006 India Mixed 119/97 51/46/22 40/38/19 0.080 7
 Mosaad 2014 Egypt Mixed 30/150 2/19/9 36/74/40 0.877 7
 Musumeci 2009 Iran Mixed 50/20 27/15/8 17/2/1 0.047 7
 Perez 2008 Argentina Mixed 64/68 17/35/12 20/32/16 0.649 7
 Pollak 2001 Israel Mixed 75/143 24/38/13 60/67/16 0.675 7
 Pouresmaeili 2013 Iran Mixed 64/82 17/33/14 36/33/13 0.252 7
 Riggs 1995 USA Mixed 40/129 9/20/11 20/61/48 0.932 7
 Seremak-Mrozikiewicz 2009 Poland Caucasian 163/63 70/66/27 26/27/10 0.506 7
 Tanriover 2010 Turkey Caucasian 50/50 16/19/15 24/19/7 0.320 8
 Techapatiphandee 2018 Thailand Asian 105/132 85/19/1 103/25/4 0.123 7
 Uysal 2008 Turkey Caucasian 100/146 18/48/34 24/78/44 0.283 7
 Vandevyver 1997 Belgium Caucasian 86/698 24/50/12 203/368/127 0.076 8
 Wang 2007 China Asian 50/48 43/7/0 39/9/0 0.474 7
 Yanagi 1996 Japan Asian 66/66 22/12/12 57/7/2 0.013 7
 Yoldemir 2011 Turkey Caucasian 130/130 35/73/22 43/65/22 0.760 7
 Zajickova 2002 Czech Republic Caucasian 65/33 20/24/21 10/13/10 0.223 7
 Zhang 1998 China Asian 17/164 14/3/0 148/16/0 0.511 8
 Zhang 2000 China Asian 77/35 38/33/6 14/18/3 0.403 7
 Zhu 2004 China Asian 40/158 26/8/6 105/46/7 0.500 7
FokI rs10735810
 Ahmad 2018 India Mixed 254/254 148/92/14 169/80/5 0.20 7
 Castelán-Martínez 2015 Mexico Mixed 232/88 61/118/53 24/45/19 0.807 7
 Choi 2000 Korea Asian 48/65 12/23/13 26/33/6 0.327 7
 González-Mercado 2013 Mexico Mixed 88/88 25/48/15 24/45/19 0.807 7
 Gu 2010 China Asian 186/148 46/100/40 40/84/24 0.071 7
 Iván 2008 Chile Caucasian 67/59 29/27/11 27/25/7 0.744 7
 Kanan 2013 Jordan Mixed 120/90 40/62/18 29/48/13 0.336 7
 Kim 2015 Korea Asian 153/47 50/83/20 14/25/8 0.577 7
 Langdahl 2000 Denmark Caucasian 30/128 12/19/9 38/59/31 0.394 7
 Li 2019 China Asian 224/155 66/103/55 58/68/29 0.259 7
 Lisker 2003 Mexico Mixed 65/57 27/29/9 20/29/8 0.625 7
 Lucotte 1999 France Caucasian 124/105 45/69/10 40/52/13 0.535 7
 Mamolini 2017 Italy Caucasian 170/73 97/60/13 40/25/8 0.194 7
 Mansour 2010 Iran Mixed 50/20 34/9/7 20/0/0 NA 7
 Mencej-Bedrac 2009 Slovenia Caucasian 240/228 88/108/44 105/97/26 0.618 8
 Mitra 2006 India Mixed 119/97 38/42/39 46/33/18 0.011 7
 Mohammadi 2015 Iran Mixed 96/356 52/36/8 198/128/30 0.158 7
 Mosaad 2014 Egypt Mixed 30/150 23/6/1 93/55/2 0.049 7
 Pérez 2008 Argentina Mixed 64/68 22/32/10 22/36/10 0.444 7
 Tanriover 2010 Turkey Caucasian 50/50 27/22/1 29/18/3 0.926 8
 Techapatiphandee 2018 Thailand Asian 105/132 31/46/28 41/73/18 0.106 7
 Wu 2019 China Asian 610/616 296/235/79 404/186/26 0.436 8
 Xing 2011 China Asian 32/70 7/14/11 27/35/8 0.506 7
 Yasovanthi 2011 India Mixed 247/254 104/119/24 122/124/8 <0.001 8
 Yoldemir 2011 Turkey Caucasian 130/130 66/55/9 62/55/13 0.876 7
 Zajickova 2002 Czech Republic Caucasian 78/74 22/44/12 25/32/17 0.283 7
TaqI rs731236
 Ahmad 2018 India Mixed 254/254 124/96/34 89/123/42 0.964 7
 Dabirnia 2016 Iran Mixed 50/50 20/24/6 16/29/5 0.121 7
 Duman 2004 Kuwait Mixed 75/66 10/42/23 15/28/23 0.259 7
 Gennari 1998 Italy Caucasian 160/144 33/87/40 62/71/11 0.126 7
 González-Mercado 2013 Mexico Mixed 232/88 142/77/13 46/36/6 0.769 7
 Iván 2008 Chile Caucasian 67/59 26/31/10 17/34/8 0.167 7
 Kim 2015 Korea Asian 153/47 140/12/1 42/5/0 0.700 7
 Langdahl 2000 Denmark Caucasian 46/284 11/30/5 91/159/34 0.005 7
 Larin 2015 Ukraine Caucasian 44/30 20/18/6 14/12/4 0.584 7
 Marozik 2013 Belarus Caucasian 54/77 17/26/11 39/24/14 0.008 7
 Marozik 2018 Lithuania Caucasian 149/172 38/62/49 58/74/40 0.088 7
 Masi 1998 Italy Caucasian 90/111 41/36/13 38/64/9 0.013 7
 Mitra 2006 India Mixed 119/97 34/42/43 44/31/22 0.001 7
 Mosaad 2014 Egypt Mixed 30/150 9/19/2 39/74/37 0.872 7
 Riggs 1995 USA Mixed 31/130 11/23/7 53/57/20 0.475 7
 Sassi 2015 Tunisia Mixed 335/231 165/128/42 103/95/33 0.152 7
 Seremak-Mrozikiewicz 2009 Poland Caucasian 163/63 78/59/26 22/29/12 0.659 7
 Tanriover 2010 Turkey Caucasian 50/50 15/29/6 25/17/8 0.102 8
 Techapatiphandee 2018 Thailand Asian 105/132 97/6/2 116/15/1 0.513 7
 Uysal 2008 Turkey Caucasian 100/146 40/46/14 54/75/17 0.237 7
 Vandevyver 1997 Belgium Caucasian 46/284 11/30/5 91/159/34 0.005 8
 Wang 2013 China Asian 92/98 47/48/7 48/40/10 0.698 7
 Yoldemir 2011 Turkey Caucasian 130/130 51/59/20 49/59/22 0.558 7
 Zajickova 2002 Czech Republic Caucasian 65/33 11/31/23 8/14/11 0.407 7
 Ziablitsev 1994 Ukraine Caucasian 44/30 20/18/6 14/12/4 0.584 7

HWE, Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium; mt, Mutant type; NA, not available; NOS, Newcastle-Ottawa scale; wt, Wild type;.