Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 15;124(40):8761–8771. doi: 10.1021/acs.jpcb.0c05761

Table 3. VEEs (in eV) Associated with the x- and y-Polarized Components of the Q and B Bands of Chl a Computed with DLPNO–STEOM-CCSD and TD-DFT, Compared to Quasi-Experimental Valuesa.

method Qy Qx Bx By
DLPNO–STEOM-CCSD 1.75 (0.219) [1] 2.24 (0.040) [2] 3.17 (1.304) [3] 3.40 (1.231) [4]
PBE0 2.19 (0.248) [1] 2.40 (0.020) [2] 3.26 (0.509) [4] 3.45 (0.786) [7]
B3LYP 2.16 (0.237) [1] 2.35 (0.019) [2] 3.17 (0.481) [4] 3.35 (0.731) [7]
BHandHLYP 2.18 (0.269) [1] 2.58 (0.021) [2] 3.50 (0.966) [3] 3.80 (0.899) [5]
CAM-B3LYP 2.14 (0.239) [1] 2.53 (0.029) [2] 3.44 (0.885) [3] 3.71 (0.895) [5]
ωB97X-D3(BJ) 2.09 (0.222) [1] 2.71 (0.047) [2] 3.56 (1.058) [3] 3.93 (0.730) [5]
B2PLYP 2.12 (0.262) [1] 2.23 (0.019) [2] 3.17 (0.905) [3] 3.27 (0.748) [4]
ωB2PLYP 2.04 (0.233) [1] 2.49 (0.048) [2] 3.45 (1.158) [3] 3.78 (0.704) [4]
quasi-exp. VEE 1.99 2.30 3.12 3.38
a

Values in parenthesis indicate oscillator strengths. Numbers in brackets represent the rank of the root based on increasing excitation energies; DFT methods often predict additional spurious low-energy states (see the Supporting Information for complete data).