Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 23;26(1):213–234. doi: 10.1007/s11366-020-09702-7

Table 4.

Robustness Checks

Variables Model Model 4 Model 5 Model 6
Alternative Nationalism Measure. Individual Model.

Alternative Nationalism Measure

(Full Model.

Alternative Dependent Variable. Social Distancing Index. Alternative Dependent Variable & Nationalism Measure
R-squared 0.200 0.846 0.715 0.822
Countries 89 58 118 77
Observations 12,777 8460 16,707 11,078
Policy Stringency or Social Distancing Index
COVID-19 Cases 29,178 2087 5797*** 3792
(23,781) (30,194) (1624) (3502)
V-Dem 7820*** 1488 536.5** 232.9
(2650) (2113) (244.9) (241.5)
Nationalism 4803*** −740.6 125.1 −111.9
(1300) (1049) (115.1) (114.7)
Govt Effectiveness −18,537* 1519 −53.94 −636.8
(9813) (5312) (546.0) (629.3)
IGO 2165 1719 429.5** 424.8**
(2364) (1299) (211.2) (172.8)
% Over 65 251.9** 84.42 7.106 12.84
(123.3) (91.96) (8.647) (9.548)
Hospital Beds 649.1** −518.0* −64.13 −70.54**
(312.6) (274.5) (41.11) (34.36)
Arrivals −857.4 669.5 −47.47 9.745
(577.7) (560.9) (67.75) (61.59)
GDP −6.10e-05** −6.54e-06 3.95e-06 2.97e-06
(2.45e-05) (2.68e-05) (3.97e-06) (2.36e-06)
Neighboring Cases −4140* −695.8 −573.2*** −377.3
(2406) (2877) (159.1) (341.6)
Nationalist Peer Stringency 8.72e-07*** −4.06e-07 0.190*** 0.0796***
(2.18e-07) (3.12e-07) (0.00848) (0.0147)
Geographic Peer Stringency 0.720*** 0.517***
(0.0721) (0.0734)
Economic Peer Stringency −6.01e-08 −3.03e-07**
(1.33e-07) (1.19e-07)
Political Peer Stringency 0.00819** 0.00434
(0.00345) (0.00368)
Lingual Peer Stringency 0.105** 0.0168
(0.0524) (0.0253)
Constant 48.62*** 5.183*** 1.116*** 0.478***
(0.654) (1.779) (0.239) (0.170)

*** p < 0.01, ** p < 0.05, *p < 0.1