TABLES OF BONE AREA AND BONE MINERAL COMPOSITION FOR NAVAJO WOMEN AND MEN AS COMPARED TO NON-HISPANIC WHITE WOMEN FROM NHANES DATA (2005–2008)a
| Bone Mineral Concentration | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||||
| Women | L1–L4 Spine | Femoral Neck | Total Hip | |||||||
|
|
|
|
|
|||||||
| BMI | Age | NHANES | Navajo | p value | NHANES | Navajo | p value | NHANES | Navajo | p value |
| BMI <25 | 20–29 years | 59.4[57.6–61.2] | 41.4[38.5–44.2] | <.001 | 4.1[4–4.2] | 3.6[3.4–3.8] | <.001 | 29.8[28.8–30.7] | 26.8[25.2–28.4] | .002 |
| 30–39 years | 61[58.7–63.3] | 44.6[39.1–50.2] | <.001 | 3.9[3.8–4] | 3.7[3.3–4] | 0.167 | 29.2[28–30.4] | 29.4[25–33.7] | .397 | |
| 40–49 years | 60.8[58.6–63] | 45.5[41.3–49.7] | <.001 | 3.8[3.7–3.8] | 3.4[3.3–3.5] | <.001 | 29.1[28.1–30.1] | 27.2[25.1–29.4] | .093 | |
| 50–59 years | 54.8[53–56.6] | 43.8[39.6–48.1] | <.001 | 3.5[3.3–3.6] | 3.5[3.3–3.7] | 0.384 | 27.5[26.4–28.6] | 28.2[26.2–30.1] | .329 | |
| 60 years and older | 50.9[49.3–52.6] | 33.6[26.8–40.4] | <.001 | 3.2[3.1–3.2] | 2.9[2.7–3.2] | 0.016 | 25.9[25.3–26.5] | 22.9[19.6–26.1] | .037 | |
| 25≤ BMI <30 | 20–29 years | 65.6[63.2–68] | 44.6[41.8–47.4] | <.001 | 4.5[4.3–4.6] | 3.9[3.8–4] | <.001 | 31.9[30.8–32.9] | 28.1[26.9–29.4] | <.001 |
| 30–39 years | 63.2[60.8–65.6] | 49.8[47–52.6] | <.001 | 4.2[4.1–4.4] | 4[3.8–4.2] | 0.035 | 31.4[30–32.9] | 32[30.4–33.6] | .345 | |
| 40–49 years | 59.3[57.2–61.3] | 48.2[45.5–50.9] | <.001 | 3.9[3.8–4] | 3.8[3.7–4] | 0.267 | 29.8[29–30.5] | 30.1[28.8–31.4] | .363 | |
| 50–59 years | 56.5[53.9–59.1] | 41.3[38.9–43.7] | <.001 | 3.8[3.7–3.9] | 3.6[3.4–3.7] | 0.052 | 29.2[28.2–30.2] | 29.6[27.9–31.2] | .365 | |
| 60 years and older | 53.9[52.5–55.2] | 37.1[34.6–39.7] | <.001 | 3.5[3.5–3.6] | 3.2[3–3.4] | <.001 | 28.4[27.8–29.1] | 26.1[24.8–27.5] | .004 | |
| BMI >=30 | 20–29 years | 62.6[60.7–64.5] | 48.9[46.7–51.1] | <.001 | 4.7[4.4–5] | 4.5[4.3–4.6] | 0.158 | 33.9[32.4–35.5] | 33.6[32.3–35] | .381 |
| 30–39 years | 61.3[59.6–63] | 50.9[49.1–52.7] | <.001 | 4.4[4.3–4.5] | 4.3[4.2–4.5] | 0.279 | 32.2[31.1–33.3] | 34.2[33.1–35.3] | .014 | |
| 40–49 years | 64.3[62.3–66.4] | 51.3[49.3–53.2] | <.001 | 4.5[4.3–4.6] | 4.2[4.1–4.3] | 0.003 | 34.5[33.3–35.8] | 34.3[33.4–35.2] | .375 | |
| 50–59 years | 60[57.7–62.3] | 44.9[42.4–47.4] | <.001 | 4.1[3.9–4.3] | 3.8[3.6–3.9] | 0.003 | 32.9[31.5–34.3] | 31.3[30.2–32.4] | .083 | |
| 60 years and older | 55.9[53.9–57.9] | 40.7[38.3–43.2] | <.001 | 3.8[3.7–3.9] | 3.4[3.3–3.6] | <.001 | 30.6[29.9–31.3] | 29.1[27.5–30.7] | .095 | |
| Bone Mineral Concentration | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||||||
| Men | L1–L4 Spine | Femoral Neck | Total Hip | |||||||
|
|
|
|
|
|||||||
| BMI | Age | NHANES | Navajo | p value | NHANES | Navajo | p value | NHANES | Navajo | p value |
| BMI <25 | 20–29 years | 71[69.2–72.8] | 49.6[46.3–52.8] | <.001 | 5.2[5–5.3] | 4.4[4.2–4.6] | <.001 | 42.7[41.9–43.6] | 37.2[35.4–39] | <.001 |
| 30–39 years | 68.3[66.1–70.6] | 48.3[42.4–54.1] | <.001 | 4.6[4.5–4.8] | 4.2[3.7–4.7] | 0.071 | 39.2[37.7–40.7] | 36.5[32–41.1] | .180 | |
| 40–49 years | 68.7[65.8–71.5] | 53.5[47.3–59.8] | <.001 | 4.6[4.4–4.8] | 4[3.8–4.3] | 0.002 | 41.5[39.4–43.6] | 36.9[34.2–39.6] | .007 | |
| 50–59 years | 70.8[67–74.5] | 51.9[39.7–64.2] | <.001 | 4.4[4.2–4.6] | 3.9[3.4–4.5] | 0.033 | 40.8[39–42.6] | 36.1[29.6–42.6] | .069 | |
| 60 years and older | 71.2[68.1–74.4] | 59.9[50.5–69.3] | .007 | 4.1[4–4.2] | 4.1[3.7–4.4] | 0.393 | 39.1[38.1–40] | 40.1[34.5–45.8] | .358 | |
| 25≤ BMI <30 | 20–29 years | 72.2[69.6–74.7] | 54.7[51.5–57.8] | <.001 | 5.3[5.1–5.5] | 5[4.8–5.2] | 0.034 | 44.8[43.3–46.4] | 42.1[40–44.1] | .035 |
| 30–39 years | 74.3[71.7–76.9] | 56.1[51.6–60.5] | <.001 | 5.1[5–5.3] | 4.5[4.3–4.7] | <.001 | 45.3[43.7–47] | 42.1[39.8–44.3] | .021 | |
| 40–49 years | 74.9[72.7–77] | 59.8[56.2–63.4] | <.001 | 5[4.9–5.1] | 4.5[4.3–4.8] | <.001 | 45[43.8–46.2] | 41.7[39.7–43.7] | .007 | |
| 50–59 years | 74.5[72.6–76.5] | 60.6[56–65.1] | <.001 | 4.8[4.6–4.9] | 4.3[4.1–4.5] | <.001 | 44[42.9–45] | 40.3[38–42.7] | .007 | |
| 60 years and older | 75.6[73.3–77.9] | 65.7[59.8–71.6] | .002 | 4.5[4.4–4.6] | 4.3[4–4.5] | 0.060 | 43.1[42.4–43.8] | 42.4[39.5–45.2] | .352 | |
| BMI >=30 | 20–29 years | 72.5[69.6–75.5] | 61.4[58.7–64.2] | <.001 | 5.8[5.6–6] | 5.5[5.3–5.7] | 0.042 | 46.4[44.5–48.2] | 45.4[43.3–47.5] | .309 |
| 30–39 years | 68.9[66.6–71.2] | 62.4[59.1–65.7] | .002 | 5.3[5.1–5.4] | 5.1[4.9–5.3] | 0.192 | 45.8[44.1–47.5] | 46.3[44.4–48.3] | .368 | |
| 40–49 years | 72.8[70.2–75.4] | 61.6[58.4–64.8] | <.001 | 5.2[5–5.3] | 5[4.8–5.2] | 0.132 | 46.5[45.3–47.7] | 45.9[44.1–47.8] | .346 | |
| 50–59 years | 72.4[70–74.9] | 64.9[61.7–68.2] | <.001 | 5[4.9–5.2] | 4.7[4.5–4.9] | 0.004 | 46.5[45.4–47.7] | 46.5[44.7–48.4] | .399 | |
| 60 years and older | 75.5[73–78] | 68[64–72] | .002 | 4.9[4.8–5] | 4.4[4.2–4.7] | 0.002 | 47.1[46–48.1] | 44.2[41.5–46.9] | .047 | |
| Area Women | L1–L4 Spine | Femoral Neck | Total Hip | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||||
| BMI | Age | NHANES | Navajo | p value | NHANES | Navajo | p value | NHANES | Navajo | p value |
| BMI <25 | 20–29 years | 57.5[56.3–58.8] | 46.6[45–48.2] | <.001 | 4.8[4.8–4.9] | 4.6[4.5–4.8] | 0.007 | 31.7[31.1–32.2] | 31[30–32.1] | .238 |
| 30–39 years | 58.3[57.1–59.5] | 47.5[44.1–50.9] | <.001 | 4.8[4.7–4.9] | 4.7[4.4–4.9] | 0.154 | 32[31.4–32.7] | 32.2[30–34.5] | .393 | |
| 40–49 years | 59.2[58–60.4] | 48.8[46.6–51.1] | <.001 | 4.9[4.8–5] | 4.7[4.5–4.9] | 0.012 | 32.9[32.3–33.5] | 32.4[30.6–34.2] | .340 | |
| 50–59 years | 58[57–59.1] | 50.3[47.9–52.7] | <.001 | 4.9[4.8–5] | 5[4.8–5.1] | 0.319 | 33.5[32.7–34.2] | 33.9[32–35.8] | .365 | |
| 60 years and older | 57.5[56.9–58.1] | 48.5[44.4–52.5] | <.001 | 5[5–5.1] | 4.9[4.7–5.1] | 0.250 | 34.3[33.9–34.8] | 33.4[31.8–35.1] | .189 | |
| 25≤ BMI <30 | 20–29 years | 59.4[57.8–60.9] | 46.9[44.9–48.9] | <.001 | 4.9[4.8–5] | 4.7[4.6–4.8] | 0.012 | 31.8[31.2–32.5] | 31[30–31.9] | .118 |
| 30–39 years | 58.6[56.9–60.3] | 49[47.5–50.5] | <.001 | 5[4.9–5.1] | 4.8[4.7–5] | 0.072 | 32.5[31.6–33.5] | 33.4[32.3–34.4] | .204 | |
| 40–49 years | 57.2[56.2–58.2] | 49.3[47.7–50.8] | <.001 | 4.8[4.8–4.9] | 4.7[4.6–4.8] | 0.094 | 31.9[31.4–32.5] | 32.2[31.4–33] | .346 | |
| 50–59 years | 56.7[55.7–57.8] | 47.3[45.9–48.8] | <.001 | 5[4.9–5.1] | 4.7[4.6–4.8] | <.001 | 32.5[31.8–33.3] | 32.8[31.8–33.9] | .360 | |
| 60 years and older | 57[56.2–57.8] | 47.6[45.8–49.4] | <.001 | 5[5–5] | 4.8[4.7–4.9] | 0.004 | 34.3[33.9–34.7] | 33.9[33–34.7] | .254 | |
| BMI >=30 | 20–29 years | 56.1[55.2–57] | 47.7[46.5–48.9] | <.001 | 4.9[4.8–5] | 4.8[4.7–4.8] | 0.111 | 32.3[31.5–33.1] | 32.1[31.3–33] | .387 |
| 30–39 years | 56.3[55–57.5] | 48.7[47.7–49.7] | <.001 | 4.9[4.8–5] | 4.7[4.6–4.8] | <.001 | 31.7[31.1–32.3] | 32.8[32.2–33.3] | .010 | |
| 40–49 years | 57[56–58] | 50.1[49–51.1] | <.001 | 4.9[4.8–4.9] | 4.8[4.7–4.9] | 0.066 | 33.1[32.5–33.6] | 33.2[32.6–33.9] | .367 | |
| 50–59 years | 56.6[55.5–57.7] | 48.9[47.8–50] | <.001 | 5[4.9–5] | 4.8[4.8–4.9] | 0.012 | 33.8[33.2–34.4] | 33.7[33–34.3] | .385 | |
| 60 years and older | 56[55–56.9] | 47.9[46.5–49.2] | <.001 | 5.1[5–5.1] | 4.7[4.6–4.8] | <.001 | 34.3[34–34.7] | 33.7[33–34.5] | .138 | |
| Area Men | L1–L4 Spine | Femoral Neck | Total Hip | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||||
| BMI | Age | NHANES | Navajo | p value | NHANES | Navajo | p value | NHANES | Navajo | p value |
| BMI <25 | 20–29 years | 68[67–68.9] | 53.8[51.9–55.7] | <.001 | 5.6[5.5–5.7] | 5.2[5.1–5.4] | <.001 | 41[40.4–41.7] | 39.6[38.2–40.9] | .043 |
| 30–39 years | 67.7[66.5–69] | 54.5[49.8–59.1] | <.001 | 5.6[5.5–5.7] | 5.2[4.9–5.5] | 0.008 | 41.2[40.2–42.2] | 39.4[36.1–42.8] | .205 | |
| 40–49 years | 68.4[67–69.8] | 56.4[52.7–60] | <.001 | 5.7[5.6–5.8] | 5.4[5.2–5.6] | 0.002 | 43[41.8–44.1] | 41.5[39.2–43.8] | .188 | |
| 50–59 years | 69.6[67.4–71.8] | 57[50–64.1] | <.001 | 5.7[5.6–5.8] | 5.4[5.1–5.7] | 0.008 | 43.1[42.1–44.2] | 43.4[39.4–47.3] | .396 | |
| 60 years and older | 69.7[68.6–70.9] | 62.3[58.5–66.2] | <.001 | 5.7[5.7–5.8] | 5.8[5.5–6.1] | 0.367 | 44.4[43.8–45.1] | 47.9[42.3–53.4] | .115 | |
| 25≤ BMI <30 | 20–29 years | 67.4[66.1–68.8] | 56.4[54.5–58.2] | <.001 | 5.6[5.5–5.7] | 5.3[5.2–5.4] | <.001 | 41.6[40.7–42.4] | 40.5[39.2–41.9] | .182 |
| 30–39 years | 69[67.5–70.4] | 57.4[55.2–59.6] | <.001 | 5.7[5.6–5.8] | 5.3[5.2–5.5] | <.001 | 42.9[42–43.8] | 41.7[39.9–43.5] | .179 | |
| 40–49 years | 70.1[68.9–71.2] | 60.1[58.3–61.8] | <.001 | 5.7[5.6–5.8] | 5.3[5.2–5.5] | <.001 | 42.9[42.1–43.6] | 42[40.8–43.2] | .178 | |
| 50–59 years | 69.9[68.9–70.8] | 59.7[58–61.3] | <.001 | 5.8[5.7–5.9] | 5.3[5.2–5.5] | <.001 | 43.4[42.6–44.2] | 42.1[40.7–43.5] | .097 | |
| 60 years and older | 70.1[69.2–71] | 63.1[60.2–66] | <.001 | 5.8[5.8–5.9] | 5.4[5.3–5.6] | <.001 | 44.6[44.2–45.1] | 44[42.3–45.8] | .312 | |
| BMI >=30 | 20–29 years | 66.6[65.1–68.1] | 58[56.6–59.5] | <.001 | 5.6[5.6–5.7] | 5.4[5.3–5.5] | <.001 | 40.8[39.8–41.8] | 41[39.9–42.2] | 0376 |
| 30–39 years | 66.2[65–67.4] | 57.9[56.1–59.8] | <.001 | 5.7[5.6–5.8] | 5.4[5.3–5.5] | 0.004 | 42.1[40.9–43.2] | 42[40.7–43.3] | .398 | |
| 40–49 years | 68[67–69] | 58.9[57.5–60.4] | <.001 | 5.7[5.7–5.8] | 5.5[5.4–5.6] | 0.002 | 43[42.3–43.6] | 42.6[41.4–43.7] | .332 | |
| 50–59 years | 67.1[66–68.1] | 60.3[58.5–62.1] | <.001 | 5.7[5.7–5.8] | 5.4[5.3–5.5] | <.001 | 43.7[43–44.3] | 43.7[42.7–44.7] | .397 | |
| 60 years and older | 67.9[66.8–69] | 62.2[59.9–64.5] | <.001 | 5.8[5.8–5.9] | 5.4[5.3–5.6] | <.001 | 44.9[44.4–45.4] | 43.9[42.5–45.4] | .164 | |
Note:
The p values are the result of the z test for mean difference.