Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 6;61(3):E340–E373. doi: 10.15167/2421-4248/jpmh2020.61.3.1448

Tab. I.

Main characteristics of the included studies.

Author, year Study period Country Study design Administration channel Sample size Type of vaccine Type of questions Validation Immunization behaviour
Adler A, 2007 2007 Israel Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,474 Varicella Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Adorador A, 2011 2011 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 108 Dtp Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Aharony N, 2017 2017 Israel Cross-sectional On-line 200 Child vaccines Likert scale With statistical methods Refusal
Akis S, 2011 2011 Turkey Cross-sectional Paper-based 611 Flu Closed Not Acceptance
Akmatov MK, 2009 2009 Kyrgyzstan Cross-sectional Paper-based 934 Child vaccines Closed Not Acceptance
Alberts CJ, 2017 2017 Netherlands Cross-sectional Mail 1,309 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Alfredsson R, 2004 2004 Sweden Cross-sectional Paper-based 300 Mmr Closed With statistical methods Acceptance
Allen JD, 2010 2010 USA Cross-sectional On-line 476 Hpv Closed Not Acceptance
Allison MA, 2010 2010 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 259 Flu Likert scale With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Allred NJ, 2005 2005 USA Cross-sectional Mail 7,810 Dt Closed With statistical methods Acceptance
Alshammari TM, 2018 2018 Saudi Arabia Cross-sectional Paper-based 467 Child vaccines Closed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Ambe JP, 2001 2001 Nigeria Cross-sectional Paper-based 500 Measles Closed Statistical methods not reported Refusal
Aharon AA, 2017 2017 Israel Cross-sectional Paper-based 731 Hbv/dtp/mmr Likert scale Not Refusal
Arrossi S, 2012 2012 Argentina Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,200 Hpv Closed With statistical methods Acceptance
Azizi FSM, 2017 2017 Malesya Cross-sectional Paper-based 545 Child vaccines Closed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Baglioni A, 2014 2014 Italy Cross-sectional Paper-based 648 Hpv Closed With statistical methods Acceptance
Bakhache P, 2013 2013 Multinational Cross-sectional On-line 2,460 Menb Closed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Baldwin AS, 2013 2008-2010 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 256 Hpv Likert scale With statistical methods Acceptance
Bardenheier B, 2003 2000 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 648 Hav Closed Not Acceptance
Bardenheier B, 2004 2001 USA Case-control Paper-based 3,586 Mmr/dtp/hbv Likert scale Not Acceptance
Bardenheier BH, 2004 1997-1998 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 3,552 Dtp/hib/hbv/polio Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Barnack JL, 2010 2006 USA Cross-sectional Mail 200 Hpv Likert scale Not Acceptance
Barnack-Tavlaris JL, 2016 2009 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 4,666 Hpv Closed Not Acceptance
Bazzano A, 2012 2007 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 197 Child vaccines Closed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Bedford H, 2007 2004 UK Cross-sectional Paper-based 859 New vaccines Likert scale Not Acceptance
Beel ER, 2013 2010-2012 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 511 Child vaccines Closed With statistical methods Acceptance
Ben Natan M, 2011 2008 Israel Cross-sectional Paper-based 103 Hpv Likert scale With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Ben Natan M, 2016 2015 Israel Cross-sectional Paper-based 200 Flu Likert scale With statistical methods Acceptance
Ben Natan M, 2017 2016 Israel Cross-sectional Paper-based 200 Hpv Likert scale With statistical methods Acceptance
Berenson AB, 2014 2011-2013 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,256 Hpv Closed With statistical methods Acceptance
Bettinger JA, 2016 2011 Canada Cross-sectional Mail 34 Flu Closed Not Acceptance
Bham SQ, 2016 2015 Pakistan Cross-sectional Paper-based 210 Polio Closed Not Acceptance
Bianco A, 2014 2014 Italy Cross-sectional Paper-based 566 Hpv Likert scale Not Acceptance
Bigham M, 2006 2002-2003 Canada Cross-sectional Telephone 487 Hbv Likert scale With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Alder S, 2015 2012 Argentina Cross-sectional Paper-based 180 Hpv Closed With statistical methods Acceptance
Basu P, 2011 2008 India Cross-sectional Paper-based 522 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Blair A, 1997 1997 Australia Cross-sectional Paper-based 245 Child vaccines Open field Not Acceptance
Blyth CC, 2014 2008–2012 Australia Cross-sectional Paper-based 2,576 Dtp/hib/hbv Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Bodson J, 2016 2013 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 119 Hpv Closed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Bonanni P, 2001 2001 Italy Cross-sectional Paper-based 300 Child vaccines Closed Not Acceptance
Borena W, 2016 2015 Austria Cross-sectional Mail 439 Hpv Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Borras E, 2009 2003-2004 Spain Cross-sectional Telephone 630 Child vaccines Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Brabin L, 2006 2005 UK Cross-sectional Mail 317 Hpv Mixed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Brambleby P, 1989 1988 UK Cross-sectional Mail 977 Mmr Mixed Statistical methods not reported Refusal
Breitkopf CR, 2009 2007 Vietnam Cross-sectional Paper-based 139 Hpv Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Brieger D, 2017 N.A. Australia Cross-sectional Paper-based 201 Mmr Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Brown B, 2017 2015-2016 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 200 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Brown KF, 2011 2009 UK Cross-sectional Mail 535 Mmr Mixed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Brunson EK, 2013 2010 USA Cross-sectional On-line 196 Child vaccines Mixed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Bults M, 2011 2009-2010 Netherlands Cross-sectional Face to face/mail 1900 Flu Open field With statistical methods Refusal
Burdette AM, 2014 2014 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 20,000 Hpv Closed With statistical methods Refusal
Busse JW, 2011 2010 Canada Cross-sectional Paper-based 95 Child vaccines Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Buyuktiryaki B, 2014 2010 Turkey Cross-sectional Paper-based 625 Flu Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Cacciatore MA, 2016 2014-2015 USA Cross-sectional On-line 2,000 Measles Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Campbell H, 2017 2015 UK Cross-sectional Face to face 1,792 Child vaccines Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Carlos RC, 2011 N.A. USA Cross-sectional Mail 937 Hpv Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Casiday R, 2006 2004 UK Cross-sectional Mail 996 Mmr Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Cassell JA, 2006 2004 Uk Cross-sectional Mail 452 Mmr Mixed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Cataldi JR, 2016 2015 USA Cross-sectional On-line 343 Mmr Mixed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Chan JY, 2014 2012 Hong Kong Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,285 Varicella Mixed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Chaparro RM, 2016 2012 Argentina Cross-sectional Paper-based 77 Hpv Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Chau JPC, 2017 2013 Hong Kong Cross-sectional Paper-based 623 Flu Likert scale With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Chen CH, 2015 2011 Taiwan Cross-sectional Mail 1,300 Flu Likert scale With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Chen MF, 2011 2009 Taiwan Cross-sectional Paper-based 2,778 Flu Mixed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Cheruvu VK, 2017 2017 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 21,467 Hpv Closed Not Refusal
Chung YM, 2017 2012-2014 USA Cross-sectional On-line 5,121 Child vaccines Mixed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Cipriano JJ, 2018 2016 USA Cross-sectional On-line 75 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Clark SJ, 2016 2012 USA Cross-sectional On-line 1,799 Hpv Mixed With statistical methods Acceptance
Clark SJ, 2016 2012 USA Cross-sectional On-line 1,799 Hpv Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Clark SJ, 2016 2013 USA Cross-sectional On-line 1,799 Hpv Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Cockcroft A, 2014 2011 Nigeria Cross-sectional Paper-based 5,257 Measles Closed Not Acceptance
Colon-Lopez V, 2016 2013 Puerto Rico Cross-sectional Paper-based 200 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Colon-Lopez V, 2015 2013 Puerto Rico Cross-sectional Paper-based 200 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Coniglio MA,2011 2008 Italy Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,500 Child vaccines Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Constantine NA, 2007 2006 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 802 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Cooper Robbins SC, 2011 2007 Australia Cross-sectional Paper-based 169 Flu Mixed Not Acceptance
Costa-Pinto JC, 2017 2014-2015 Australia Cross-sectional On-line 612 Child vaccines Mixed Not Acceptance
Coyne-Beasley T, 2013 2008 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 1281 Mcv Mixed Not Acceptance
Cuninghame CJ, 1994 1991-1992 UK Cross-sectional Face to face/telephone/mail 93 Child vaccines Mixed Not Acceptance
Cunningham-Erves J, 2016 2012-2013 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 242 Hpv Likert scale Not Acceptance
Dahlstrom LA, 2010 2007 Sweden Cross-sectional Web /paper based 13,946 Hpv N.A. With statistical methods Acceptance
Daley MF, 2007 2003 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 472 Flu Mixed Not Acceptance
Danchin MH, 2017 2015-2016 Australia Cross-sectional Questionnaire (ipad), follow-up phone surveys 975 Child vaccines Mixed Not Acceptance
Danis K, 2010 2004–2005 Greece Cross-sectional Paper-based 3,434 Child vaccines Mixed Not Acceptance
Dannetun E, 2007 2005 Sweden Cross-sectional Paper-based and online 1,229 Hbv Mixed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Dannetun E, 2005 2003 Sweden Cross-sectional Paper-based 173 Mmr Mixed Not Refusal
Danova J, 2015 2013-2014 Repubblica Ceca Cross-sectional Paper-based 480 Child vaccines Closed Not Refusal
Darden PM, 2013 2008–2010 USA Cross-sectional Telephone Dtp/mcv/hpv N.A. Not Refusal
Davis K, 2004 2003 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 575 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Dawar M, 2002 1999 Canada Cross-sectional Telephone 191 Hbv/dtp/hib Mixed Not Acceptance
de Courval FP, 2003 2000 Canada Cross-sectional Telephone 663 Varicella Mixed Not Refusal
de Visser R, 2008 2008 UK Cross-sectional Paper-based 353 Hpv Likert scale Not Acceptance
Dempsey AF, 2011 N.A. USA Cross-sectional Mail 830 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Dempsey AF, 2015 2012-2013 USA Cross-sectional On-line 54 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Dempsey AF, 2006 2009 USA Cross-sectional On-line 1,178 Hpv Likert scale Not Acceptance
DiAnna Kinder F, 2017 N.A. USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 72 Hpv Mixed Not Refusal
Dinh TA, 2007 2005 Vietnam Cross-sectional Paper-based 181 Hpv Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Dorell C, 2014 2010 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 4103 Hpv Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Dorell C, 2013 2010-2011 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 8,652 Hpv/dtp/mcv Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Dorell C, 2011 2009-2010 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 20,066 Hpv/mcv/dtp Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Dube E, 2012 2008-2009 Canada Cohort Paper-based 413 Rotavirus Mixed Not Acceptance
Dube E, 2015 2014 Canada Cross-sectional Telephone 703 Menb Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Dube E, 2017 2015 Canada Cross-sectional On-line 20,13 Child vaccines Mixed Not Acceptance
Dube E, 2016 2014 Canada Cross-sectional Telephone 589 Child vaccines Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Ezat SW, 2013 2012 Malesya Cross-sectional Not reported 155 Hpv N.A. Not Acceptance
Ezeanochie MC, 2014 2009 Nigeria Cross-sectional Paper-based 201 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Ezenwa BN, 2013 2012 Nigeria Cross-sectional Paper-based 290 Hpv N.A. Not Acceptance
Farias CC, 2016 2015 Brazil Cross-sectional Paper-based 797 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Flood EM, 2010 2009 USA Cross-sectional On-line 500 Flu Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Flynn M, 2004 1999-2000 UK Cohort Paper-based 511 Mmr Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Freed GL, 2010 2009 USA Cross-sectional On-line 1,552 Mmr/varicella/mcv/hpv N.A. Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Freeman VA, 1999 1995 USA Cross-sectional Mail 247 Varicella Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Frew PM, 2016 2012-2014 USA Cross-sectional On-line 5,121 Child vaccines Closed Not Acceptance
Frew PM, 2011 2009 USA Cross-sectional Not reported 223 Flu Likert scale Not Refusal
Fry AM, 2001 1999-2000 USA Case-control Paper-based 66 Hib Open field Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Fuchs EL, 2016 2011-2013 USA Cross-sectional Not reported 350 Hpv Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Garcia DA, 2014 2000 Colombia Cross-sectional Paper-based 4,802 Child vaccines Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gargano LM, 2013 2011 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 114 Flu/dtp/mcv/hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gaudino JA, 2012 2004-2005 USA Cross-sectional On-line 1,588 Child vaccines Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gefenaite G, 2012 2009 Netherlands Case-control Mail 469 Hpv Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gellatly J, 2005 2003-2004 UK Cross-sectional Paper-based 110 Mmr Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gellin BG, 2000 1999 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 1,600 Child vaccines Likert scale Not Acceptance
Gentile A, 2015 2013 Argentina Cross-sectional Not reported 1,350 Flu Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gerend MA, 2009 2008 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 82 Hpv Closed Not Acceptance
Gesser-Edelsburg A, 2016 2013 Israel Cross-sectional On-line 197 Polio Open field Not Refusal
Giambi C, 2014 2012 Italy Cross-sectional Mail 1,738 Hpv Mixed Not Refusal
Gilbert NL, 2016 2013 Canada Cross-sectional Telephone 5,720 Hpv Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gilkey MB, 2017 2014-2015 USA Cross-sectional On-line 1,484 Hpv Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Glanz JM, 2013 2009-2011 USA Cross-sectional Mail 854 Child vaccines Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Glenn BA, 2015 2009 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 444 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gomez Y, 2012 2010 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 773 Flu N.A. Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gottlieb SL, 2009 2007 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 889 Hpv Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gowda C, 2013 2011 USA Cross-sectional On-line 79 Mmr Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Grabiel M, 2013 2012 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 129 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Grandahl M, 2014 2012 Sweden Cross-sectional Face to face 25 Hpv Open field Statistical methods not reported Refusal
Grandahl M, 2017 2012 Sweden Cross-sectional Paper-based 200 Hpv Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Greenberg J, 2017 2015 Canada Cross-sectional On-line 1,121 Mmr Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Greenfield LS, 2015 2012 USA Cross-sectional Face to face 157 Dtp/mcv/hpv Mixed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Griebeler M, 2012 2010 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 102 Hpv Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Guerry SL, 2011 2007-2008 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 509 Hpv Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gundogdu Z, 2011 2009-2010 Turkey Cross-sectional Paper-based 300 Varicella Likert scale With statistical methods Acceptance
Gunduz S, 2014 2011-2012 Turkey Cross-sectional Paper-based 285 Flu Mixed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gupta R, 2013 2009-2010 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based and online 381 Flu Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gust D, 2005 2002 USA Cross-sectional Mail 697 Child vaccines Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gust DA, 2006 2004-2005 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 2,286 Mmr/dtp/hbv Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gust DA, 2008 2003-2004 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 3,924 Child vaccines Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gust DA, 2005 2003 USA Cross-sectional Mail 642 Child vaccines Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gust DA, 2004 2001 USA Case-control Mail 1,477 Mmr/dtp/hbv Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Gust DA, 2003 2002 USA Cross-sectional Mail 1,768 Child vaccines Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Gustafson R, 2005 2003 Canada Cross-sectional Telephone 1,246 Varicella Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Haesebaert J, 2012 2008 France Cross-sectional Face to face 32 Hpv Open field Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Hagan D, 2016 2013 Ghana Cross-sectional Paper-based 303 Child vaccines Closed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Hagemann C, 2017 2009-2011 Germany Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,998 Varicella/measles N.A. With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Hak E, 2005 N.A. Netherland Cross-sectional Not reported 283 Influenza/hbv/bcg Likert scale Not Refusal
Hamama-Raz Y, 2016 2014 Israel Cross-sectional On-line 314 Child vaccines Likert scale Not Acceptance
Han K, Zheng H, 2014 2010 China Cross-sectional Face to face 1,530 Bcg/dtp/polio/mcv/hbv Closed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Hanley SJ, 2012 2010 Japan Cross-sectional Paper-based 862 Hpv Likert scale Not Acceptance
Hanley SJ, 2014 2010 Japan Cross-sectional Paper-based 54 Hpv Likert scale Not Acceptance
Harmsen IA, 2012 2011 Netherlands Cross-sectional Paper-based 906 Hbv Likert scale Not Acceptance
He L, 2015 2013 China Cross-sectional Face to face 298 Flu Open field Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Healy CM, 2014 N.A. USA Cross-sectional Not reported 401 Hib/pcv/mcv/flu/hbv/hav/hpv/rotavirus Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Henrikson NB, 2017 2013-2015 USA Cohort Telephone 237 Child vaccines Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Hertweck SP, 2013 N.A. USA Cross-sectional On-line 68 Hpv Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Hilyard KM, 2014 2010 USA Cross-sectional Not reported 684 Flu Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Hofman R, 2014 2009-2011 Netherlands Cohort Mail 793 Hpv Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Hofstetter AM, 2015 2011 USA Cross-sectional Face to face 128 Flu Closed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Hon KL, 2016 N.A. Hong Kong Cross-sectional Paper-based 3,479 Flu N.A. Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Hontelez JA, 2010 N.A. Netherland Cross-sectional Paper-based 198 Hbv Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Horn L, 2010 2008 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 325 Hpv Likert scale With statistical methods Acceptance
How CH, 2016 2014 Singapore Cross-sectional Face to face 200 Pcv Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Hu Y, 2017 2014 China Cross-sectional Face to face 2,772 Child vaccines N.A. Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Hwang JH, 2017 2014 South Korea Cross-sectional Face to face 638 Flu Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Ilter E, 2010 2009 Turkey Cross-sectional Face to face 525 Hpv Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Imburgia TM, 2017 2014 USA Cross-sectional On-line 2,363 Flu Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Impicciatore P, 2000 1997 Italy Cross-sectional Face to face 1,035 Mmr Closed With statistical methods Acceptance
Jani JV, 2008 2001 Mozambique Cross-sectional Face to face 668 Child vaccines N.A. Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Jaspers L, 2011 2009 Indonesia Cross-sectional Face to face 746 Hpv Closed Not Acceptance
Jessop LJ, 2010 2001-2004 UK Cohort Paper-based 749 Mmr Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Jolley D, 2014 2012 UK Cross-sectional On-line 89 Child vaccines Likert scale Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Joseph NP, 2012 2008-2009 USA Cross-sectional Face to face 70 Hpv Open field With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Joseph NP, 2015 N.A. Cross-sectional Paper-based 55 Hpv Closed With statistical methods N.A.
Jung M, 2013 N.A. Cross-sectional On-line 639 Flu N.A. Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Kadis JA, 2011 2009 USA Cross-sectional On-line 496 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Kahn JA, 2009 2006-2007 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 7,207 Hpv Likert scale With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Kalucka SK, 2016 N.A. Poland Cross-sectional Paper-based 140 Child vaccines Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Katz ML, 2012 2009 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 111 Hpv Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Haesebaert J, 2014 2008 France Cross-sectional Paper-based 99 Hpv Open field With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Kaya A, 2017 2016 Turkey Cross-sectional Paper-based 102 Flu Mixed Not Acceptance
Kelley CA, 2015 N.A. Case-control Paper-based 229 Child vaccines Mixed Statistical methods not reported Refusal
Kempe A, 2007 2003 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 472 Flu Mixed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Kennedy A, 2011 2009 USA Cross-sectional Mail 475 Child vaccines Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Kennedy A, 2011 2010 USA Cross-sectional Mail 376 Child vaccines Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Kennedy AM, 2005 2002 USA Cross-sectional Mail 1527 Child vaccines Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Kepka D, 2015 2013 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 118 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Kepka D, 2015 2013 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 67 Hpv Mixed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Kepka DL, 2012 2009 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 578 Hpv Closed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Kester LM, 2013 2010 USA Cross-sectional On-line 501 Hpv Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Kettunen C, 2017 N.A. USA Cross-sectional Mail 84 Child vaccines Mixed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Kim KM, 2017 2014-2015 South Korea Cross-sectional Paper-based 200 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Kinder FD. 2016 N.A. USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 72 Hpv Mixed Not Refusal
Ko HS, 2015 N.A. South Korea Cross-sectional Paper-based 308 Dtp Closed Not Acceptance
Kong KA, 2014 2013 South Korea Cross-sectional Telephone 800 Hav Mixed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Krawczyk A, 2015 2010 Canada Cross-sectional Mail 774 Hpv Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Krawczyk A, 2015 2010 Canada Cross-sectional Mail 708 Hpv Open field Not Refusal
Krieger JL, 2011 N.A. USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 182 Hpv Closed Not Acceptance
Lavail KH, 2013 2010 USA Case-control Mail 376 Child vaccines Likert scale Not Acceptance
Le Ngoc Tho S, 2015 2013 France Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,270 Menb Mixed With statistical methods Acceptance
Lechuga J, 2012 N.A. USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 150 Hpv Open field Not Acceptance
Lee KN, 2017 2015-2016 South Korea Cross-sectional Paper-based 140 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Lee Mortensen G, 2015 2013 Multinational Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,837 Hpv Closed Not Acceptance
Lehmann BA, 2017 2015 Netherlands Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,615 Child vaccines Mixed Not Acceptance
Lewis T, 1988 1988 USA Cohort Mail 2,029 Dtp N.A. Not N.A.
Liao Q, 2016 2012-2013 Hong Kong Cross-sectional Telephone 1,226 Flu Mixed Not Acceptance
Lin CJ, 2006 2003-2004 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 951 Flu Mixed Not Acceptance
Linam WM, 2014 2010-2011 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 372 Flu Mixed Not Acceptance
Lindley MC, 2016 2013 USA Cross-sectional Mail 6,676 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Livni G, 2017 2012 Israel Cross-sectional Paper-based 186 Flu Mixed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Loke AY, 2017 2010 Hong Kong Cross-sectional Paper-based 170 Hpv Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Low MSF, 2017 2015-2016 Singapore Cross-sectional On-line 332 Flu Mixed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Luthy KE, 2010 N.A. USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 86 Child vaccines Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Luthy KE, 2013 N.A. USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 801 Child vaccines Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Luthy KE, 2009 N.A. USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 86 Child vaccines Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Maayan-Metzger A, 2005 2003 Israel Case-control Paper-based 204 Hbv Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
MacDonald SE, 2014 N.A. Canada Case-control Mail 444 Child vaccines Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
MacDougall DM, 2016 2010-2012 Canada Case-control Paper-based 722 Rotavirus Mixed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Madhivanan P, 2014 2010 India Cross-sectional Mail 797 Hpv Likert scale Not Acceptance
Mameli C, 2014 2013 Italy Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,842 Menb Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Marlow LA, 2007 2006 UK Cross-sectional Paper-based 684 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Marlow LA, 2007 2006 UK Cross-sectional Paper-based 684 Hpv Likert scale With statistical methods Acceptance
Marshall H, 2014 2012 Australia Cross-sectional Paper-based 966 Menb N.A. With statistical methods Acceptance
Marshall H, 2007 2006 Australia Cross-sectional Telephone 2,002 Hpv Closed With statistical methods Acceptance
Mayet AY, 2017 2013 Saudi Arabia Cross-sectional Paper-based 998 Flu Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
McCauley MM, 2012 2010 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 690 Child vaccines Likert scale Statistical methods not reported N.A.
McHale P, 2016 2012-2013 UK Cross-sectional Telephone 47 Mmr Open field Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Melman ST, 1999 1995-1997 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,059 Child vaccines Open field Not N.A.
Meszaros JR, 1996 N.A. USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 294 Pertussis Mixed Not N.A.
Michael CA, 2014 2012 Nigeria Cross-sectional Paper-based 48 Polio Open field Not N.A.
Michael CE, 2014 2009 Nigeria Cross-sectional Paper-based 201 Hpv Closed Not Acceptance
Middleman AB, 2002 2000 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 563 Hbv Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Milteer RM, 1996 1991-1994 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 175 Child vaccines Open field Not N.A.
Morales-Campos DY, 2017 2011-2013 Cameron Cross-sectional Paper-based 317 Hpv Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Morhason-Bello IO, 2015 2012 Nigeria Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,002 Hpv Likert scale With statistical methods Acceptance
Morrone T, 2017 2015 Italy Cross-sectional Paper-based 543 Menb N.A. With statistical methods N.A.
Moulsdale P, 2017 2014 UK Cross-sectional Paper-based 86 Flu Likert scale Not Acceptance
Muhwezi WW, 2014 2012 Uganda Cross-sectional Paper-based 870 Hpv Closed With statistical methods Acceptance
Murakami H, 2014 2007 Pakistan Cross-sectional Paper-based 630 Polio Open field Not Refusal
My C, 2017 2012 Australia Cross-sectional On-line 452 Flu Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Naeem M, 2011 2010 Pakistan Cross-sectional Paper-based 548 Polio Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Naeem M, 2011 2010 Pakistan Cross-sectional Paper-based 506 Hbv Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Namuigi P, 2005 2003 Papua New Guinea Cross-sectional Paper-based 120 Measles Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Niederhauser VP, 2007 2003-2004 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 64 Child vaccines Open field Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Oladokun RE, 2010 2009 Nigeria Cross-sectional Paper-based 248 Bcg/polio/dtp/masles/hbv Closed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Onnela JP, 2016 2012 India Cohort Paper-based 2,462 Polio Closed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Oria PA, 2013 2010 Kenya Cross-sectional Paper-based 7,177 Flu Mixed Not N.A.
Ozawa S, 2017 2013 Nigeria Cross-sectional Paper-based 198 Dtp/measles/polio Closed Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Paek HJ, 2015 2014 South Korea Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,017 Child vaccines Mixed Not N.A.
Painter JE, 2011 2009 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 102 Flu Mixed Not N.A.
Parrella A, 2013 2011 Australia Cross-sectional Telephone 469 Child vaccines Likert scale Not N.A.
Parrella A, 2012 2010 New Zeland Cross-sectional Telephone 179 Dtp/polio/hbv/hib/rotavirus/mmrv/mcv/pcv/flu Closed Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Paulussen TG, 2006 1999 Netherland Cross-sectional On-line 491 Dtp/polio/hib/mmr Closed Not N.A.
Peleg N, 2015 2011 Israel Cross-sectional Paper-based 273 Flu Closed Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Pelucchi C, 2010 2008 Italy Cross-sectional Paper-based 3,026 Hpv N.A. Not N.A.
Perez S, 2016 N.A. Canada Cross-sectional On-line 2,272 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Perez S, 2017 2014 Canada Cross-sectional On-line 2,272 Hpv Closed With statistical methods N.A.
Perez S, 2016 2014 Canada Cross-sectional On-line 2,272 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Perez S, 2016 2014 Canada Cross-sectional On-line 2,272 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Podolsky R, 2009 N.A. Usa Cross-sectional Paper-based 308 Hpv Mixed Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Pot M, 2017 2015-2016 Netherlands Cross-sectional On-line 8,062 Hpv Closed Not N.A.
Reiter PL, 2013 2008-2010 Usa Cross-sectional Mail 1,951 Hpv Mixed Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Restivo V, 2015 2012-2013 Italy Cross-sectional Telephone 443 Mmr Closed Not N.A.
Roberts JR, 2015 2011-2012 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 363 Dtp/mcv/hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Robitz R, 2011 2007-2008 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 484 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Rogers C, 2014 N.A. USA Cross-sectional On-line 51 Child vaccines Closed Not N.A.
Ruffin MT, 2012 2006-2008 USA Case-control Telephone 1,131 Hpv Closed Not N.A.
Salmon DA, 2005 2002-2003 USA Case-control Mail 1,367 Polio/mmrv/dtp/hib/hbv Closed Not N.A.
Salmon DA, 2009 N.A. USA Case-control Mail 963 Child vaccines Closed Not N.A.
Sam IC, 2009 2007 Malaysia Cross-sectional Paper-based 362 Hpv Mixed Not N.A.
Sampson R, 2011 2008 UK Cross-sectional I part mail, ii part interview 7 Flu Closed Not N.A.
Rickert VI, 2015 2012-2013 USA Cross-sectional On-line 501 Child vaccines/flu/pcv/mmr/varicella/dtp/hav/hbv/hpv/mcv Closed Not N.A.
Rose SB, 2012 2008-2009 New Zeland Cross-sectional Paper-based 769 Hpv Closed Not N.A.
Santibanez TA, 2016 2011-2012 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 19,178 Flu Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Saqer A, 2017 2017 Emirati Arabi Cross-sectional Paper-based 400 Hpv Closed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Schollin Ask L, 2017 2014 Sweden Cross-sectional On-line 1,063 Rotavirus Closed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Schwarz NG, 2009 2009 Gabon Cross-sectional Paper-based 40 Child vaccines Closed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Selmouni F, 2015 2015 Marocco Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,312 Hpv Open field Not Acceptance
Sengupta B, 1998 1998 India Cross-sectional Paper-based 656 Polio Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Seven M, 2015 2015 Turkey Cross-sectional Paper-based 368 Hpv Closed Not N.A.
Shao SJ, 2015 2014 Caraibi Cross-sectional Paper-based 35 Hpv Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Shapiro GK, 2016 2014 Canada Cross-sectional On-line 1,427 Hpv Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Shapiro GK, 2017 2016-2017 Canada Cross-sectional On-line 4,606 Hpv Open field Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Shawn DH, 1987 1986 Canada Cross-sectional Paper-based 133 Hib Closed Statistical methods not reported Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Sheikh A, 2013 2012-2013 Pakistan Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,044 Polio/tetanus/measles Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Shuaib FM, 2010 2008 Jamaica Case-control Paper-based 285 Child vaccines Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Skinner J, 1995 1992 Australia Cohort Mail 1,004 Child vaccines Mixed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Smailbegovic MS, 2003 1999 UK Case-control On-line 129 Child vaccines Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Smith MJ, 2009 2009 USA Cross-sectional On-line 121 Child vaccines Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Smith PJ, 2011 2009 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 11,206 Child vaccines Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Smith PJ, 2010 2003 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 2,921 Child vaccines Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Smith PJ, 2006 2001-2002 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 7,695 Child vaccines Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Smith PJ, 2015 2010-2013 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 19,144 Measles Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Smith PJ, 2016 2010-2014 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 8,490 Hpv Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Sohail MM, 2015 N.A. Pakistan Cross-sectional Paper-based 200 Child vaccines Mixed Not Acceptance
Songthap A, 2012 2012 Thailandia Cross-sectional Paper-based 664 Hpv Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Soyer OU, 2011 2003 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 500 Flu Mixed Not Acceptance
Staras SA, 2014 2009 Usa Cross-sectional Telephone 2,422 Hpv Closed Not Acceptance
SteelFisher GK, 2015 2013-2014 Multinational Cross-sectional Paper-based 6,025 Polio Closed Not Acceptance
Stefanoff P, 2010 2008-2009 Multinational Cross-sectional Telephone, paper-based, mail 6,611 Child vaccines Mixed Not Acceptance
Stein Zamir C, 2017 2015 Israel Cross-sectional Paper-based 45 Child vaccines Closed Not Acceptance
Stephenson JD, 1987 1986 Canada Cross-sectional Paper-based 133 Hib Closed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Stockwell MS, 2014 2007-2008 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 705 Child vaccines Mixed Not Acceptance
Strelitz B, 2015 2013-2014 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 152 Flu Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Stretch R, 2008 2007-2008 UK Cross-sectional Paper-based 651 Hpv Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Suarez-Castaneda E, 2014 2011 El Salvador Cross-sectional Paper-based 2,550 Child vaccines Mixed Not Acceptance
Sundaram SS, 2010 N.A. UK Cross-sectional Paper-based 50 Hpv Likert scale Not Acceptance
Tadesse H, 2009 2008 Ethiopia Case-control Paper-based 266 Child vaccines Mixed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Tagbo BN, 2014 2014 Nigeria Cross-sectional Paper-based 426 Polio Likert scale With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Taiwo L, 2017 2015 Nigeria Cross-sectional Paper-based 379 Child vaccines Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Takahashi K, 2014 1999-2003 Japan Cross-sectional Paper-based 120 Measles Mixed Not Refusal
Tam WW, 2015 2003 HongKong Cross-sectional Paper-based 5,617 Varicella Likert scale Not Acceptance
Tan TNQ, 2017 2011-2013 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 516 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Tang CW, 2011 2006-2008 Taiwan Cross-sectional Paper-based 539 Child vaccines Mixed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Taylor JA, 1996 1993 USA Case-control Paper-based 194 Child vaccines Likert scale Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Taylor JA, 2002 1998-2000 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 13,520 Child vaccines Mixed Not Acceptance
Thomas T, 2015 N.A. Georgia Cross-sectional Paper-based 37 Hpv Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Thomas TL, 2012 2010-2011 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 400 Hpv Mixed Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Thomas TL, 2013 2009 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 200 Hpv Likert scale Statistical methods not reported N.A.
Thomas TL, 2017 2010-2011 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 341 Hpv Likert scale Not Acceptance
Thompson EL, 2017 2012-2015 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 59,897 Hpv Closed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Tisi G, 2013 2011 Italy Cross-sectional Paper-based 161 Hpv Mixed Not Acceptance
Taylor, JA, 2000 1997-1998 USA Cross-sectional Paper-based 598 Varicella Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
Schwartz B, 2000 2000-2001 USA Cross-sectional Telephone 12,060 Hbv/dtp/measles/varicella Mixed Not N.A.
Streng A, 2010 2006-2008 Germany Cross-sectional Paper-based 1,088 Varicella Mixed Statistical methods not reported Acceptance
Opel DJ, 2011 2010 USA Cross-sectional Mail 228 Dtp/polio/mmr Likert scale Not Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt
World Health Organization, 1997 1994 Italy Cross-sectional Face to face 1,800 Dtp/polio Closed With statistical methods Hesitancy/scepticism/doubt

N.A.: not available.