Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Oct 30.
Published in final edited form as: Front Neuroendocrinol. 2017 Aug 9;47:134–153. doi: 10.1016/j.yfrne.2017.08.002

Table 1.

Summary of the effects of ovarian hormones on cognition

Ability Sample Characteristics Younger Older References

Attention

Humans

Premenopause F > L Pletzer et al., 2014

Postmenopause (55–65 years) HRT > no HRT Castonguay et al., 2015

Postmenopause HRT > no HRT Fedor-Feyberg, 1977;

Postmenopause (∼60 years) ERT > no ERT Schmidt et al., 1996

Postmenopause (∼65 years) HRT > no HRT Smith et al., 2001

Postmenopause (∼53 years) HRT = no HRT Gleason et al., 2015

Postmenopause (47–65 years) ERT = no ERT Polo-Kantola et al., 1998b

Postmenopause (53–72 years) HRT = no HRT Alhola et al., 2006

Postmenopause (∼53 years) HRT = no HRT Keenan et al., 2001

Postmenopause (58–75 years) HRT = no HRT Wolf et al., 2005

Animals

OVX macaques (6–11 years) OVX < intact
E2 > vehicle
Voyko 2002

OVX macaques (7–16 years) E2 = Vehicle Lacreuse et al., 2009

OVX macaques (∼20 years) E2 > No E2 Voytko et al., 2009

OVX macaques (18–25 years) E2 > No E2 Kohama et al., 2016

17-mo OVX rats E2 > No E2 Bohacek & Daniel, 2010

Intact rats Proestrous < Estrous/Diestrous Quinlan et al., 2010

E2 < Vehicle Almey et al., 2013

Non-spatial working memory

Humans

Maintenance

Digit Span forward: Postmenopause HRT = no HRT Alhola et al., 2006; Castonguay et al., 2015; Duff & Hampson, 2000; Gleason et al., 2015; Keenan et al., 2001; Polo-Kantola et al., 1998b; Schmidt et al., 1996

Manipulation/Updating

Early F = Late F Joseph et al., 2012

Postmenopause (∼56 years) HRT > no HRT Duff & Hampson, 2000

Postmenopause (55–65 years) HRT = no HRT
HRT > no HRT
Castonguay et al., 2015

Postmenopause (∼53 years) HRT = no HRT Gleason et al., 2015

Postmenopause (∼53 years) HRT > no HRT Keenan et al., 2001

Postmenopause (50–65 years) 3 days ERT > no ERT Krug et al., 2006

Postmenopause (∼69 years) HRT = no HRT Janowsky et al., 2000

Postmenopause (∼70 years) ERT > no ERT Baker et al., 2012

Animals

Object-DRST
Face-DRST
OVX macaques (6–9 years) EE2 = no EE2
EE2 < no EE2
Lacreuse & Herndon, 2003

Object-DRST OVX macaques (7–16 years) EB = no EB Lacreuse et al., 2009

OVX rats Low EB > no EB
Mod-high EB < no EB
Wide et al., 2004

OVX rats High E2 < no E2 Wang et al., 2008

OVX rats High E2 < no E2 High E2 < no E2 Wang et al., 2009

Task switching

Humans

Premenopause GnRHa = GnRHa + E/P
GnRHa: ↓ DLPFC
GnRHa + E/P: ↑ DLPFC
Berman et al., 1997

Postmenopause (∼60 years) ERT > no ERT Schmidt et al., 1996

Postmenopause (55–65 years) HRT > no HRT Castonguay et al., 2015

Early postmenopause (∼52 years) ↑DLPFC in HRT users; correlated with performance Girard et al., 2017

Postmenopause (∼65 years) 3-mo ERT = no ERT Duka et al., 2000

Animals

OVX macaques (∼20 years) HRT > no HRT Voytko et al., 2009

OVX macaques (∼24 years) EE2 = no EE2 Lacreuse et al., 2004

Young OVX rats E2 > no E2 Lipatova et al., 2016

reversal learning OVX marmosets (3–5 years) High E2 < No E2 Lacreuse et al., 2014

reversal learning OVX rats (21–22 mo) E2 < no E2 Gibbs et al., 2011

Response inhibition

Humans

Go/No-Go, Stop-Signal Premenopause F < L Colzato et al., 2010; Reimers et al., 2014

Stroop Interference Postmenopause (50–65 years) 3 days ERT > no ERT Krug et al., 2006

Stroop Interference Postmenopause HRT = no HRT Alhola et al., 2006; Baker et al., 2012; Castonguay et al., 2015; Duka et al., 2000; Polo-Kantola et al., 1998b; Wolf et al., 2005

Animals

Stop Signal Premenopausal baboons O = L Lacreuse et al., 2016

DRL OVX rats High E2 < no E2 Wang et al., 2008

DRL OVX rats High E2 < no E2 E2 = no E2 Wang et al., 2011

Decision making

Humans

Premenopause & postmenopause (∼55 years) Menses = mid L ERT = no ERT Reavis & Overman, 2001

Premenopause F > menses Smith et al., 2014

Animals

OVX rats High EB > no EB Uban et al., 2012

Spatial Working Memory

Humans

Premenopause High E2 > Low E2
E2 correlates with performance
Hampson & Morley 2013

Postmenopause (∼56 years) HRT > no HRT Duff & Hampson, 2000

Postmenopause (∼71 years) 3-mo ERT = no ERT Schiff et al., 2005

Animals

Premenopause O < F=L Lacreuse et al., 2001

OVX macaques (6–9 years) EE2 = no EE2 Lacreuse et al., 2003

OVX macaques (7–16 years) E2 = Vehicle Lacreuse et al., 2009

Macaques (6–10 years) OVX = intact
E2 = no E2
Voytko, 2000

Macaques (∼ 10 years) E2 = no E2 Hao et al., 2007

Macaques (20–27 years) Premenopause > peri/postmenopause Roberts et al., 1997

OVX macaques (∼22 years) E2 > no E2 Rapp et al., 2003

OVX macaques (18–25 years) E2 > E2/P > No E2 Kohama et al., 2016

OVX macaques (21–24 years) EE2 > no EE2 Lacreuse et al., 2002

OVX macaques (∼20 years) E2 = E2/P = no E2 Voytko et al., 2008

OVX marmosets (3–5 years) High E2 < No E2 Lacreuse et al., 2014

OVX macaques (19–27 years) Long-term OVX > intact Lacreuse et al., 2000

Intact rats Proestrous > estrous Pompili et al., 2010

OVX rats E2 > no E2 Gibbs, 2007; Holmes et al., 2002; Luine et al., 1998; Sandstrom & Williams, 2001; Velàzquez-Zamora et al., 2012

OVX rats Win-stay: E2 = no E2
Win-shift: E2 < no E2
Galea et al., 2001

OVX rats Intra-PFC/HPC E2 > vehicle Sinopoli et al., 2006

12-mo old OVX rats E2 > no E2 Daniel et al., 2006

21–25-mo old OVX rats E2+P > no E2+P Gibbs, 2000

13–22-mo old OVX rats OVX < intact E2 > no E2 Markowska & Savonenko, 2002

Spatial reference memory

Animals

Intact rats Proestrous = estrous Berry & McMahan, 1997;

Intact rats Watermaze: Proestrous < estrous
RAM: Proestrous = estrous
Pompili et al., 2010

Proestrous < estrous Warren & Juraska, 1997

OVX rats Watermaze: E2 > no E2
Y-maze: E2 = no E2
McLaughlin, 2008

E2 > no E2
Intra-HPC E2 > vehicle
Packard & Teather, 1997a,b

OVX rats E2 < no E2 Galea et al., 2001

OVX rats E2 = no E2 Fader et al., 1999; Holmes et al., 2002; Luine et al., 1998;

4, 16, & 24-mo old OVX rats E2 > no E2 E2 = no E2 Talboom et al., 2008

13–22-mo old OVX rats OVX = intact
E2 = no E2
Markowska & Savonenko, 2002

Object placement/NOIP test

Animals

OVX rats E2 > no E2 As reviewed by Tuscher et al., 2014; McLaughlin et al., 2008

Spatial strategy

Humans

Premenopause Late L > Early F/O Hussain et al., 2016

Animals

Rats Proestrous > estrous
E2 > no E2
E2 > no E2 As reviewed by Korol & Pisani, 2015; Korol et al., 2004

OVX rats Intra-HPC E2 > Vehicle Zurkovsky et al., 2007

Verbal memory

Humans

Premenopause Inconsistent reports, or F = L = Menses As reviewed by Poromaa & Gingnell, 2014

Premenopause GnRHa < cycling Craig et al., 2008

GnRHa = cycling Guerrieri et al., 2016; Owens et al., 2002

Age: ∼45–52 years Peri-/postmenopause/ < premenopause Greendale et al., 2009; Weber et al., 2013

Surgically menopausal women (36–45 years) BL > post-surgery Sherwin, 1988

Postmenopause HRT > no HRT Baker et al., 2012; Castonguay et al., 2015; Jacobs et al., 1998; Kampen & Sherwin, 1994; Keenan et al., 2001; Maki, Zonderman, & Resnick, 2001; Phillips & Sherwin, 1992b; Resnick et al., 1998

Postmenopause HRT = no HRT Baker et al., 2012; Gleason et al., 2015; Henderson et al., 2016

Visual recognition memory

Humans

Premenopause GnRHa < cycling Craig et al., 2010

Postmenopause (∼65–67 years) ERT > no ERT Resnick et al., 1998

Postmenopause (∼64 years) HRT = no HRT Alhola et al., 2006

Older AD patients (∼74 years) ERT = no ERT Sundermann et al., 2006

Animals

Premenopause No/brief retention delay: F = L
30-s retention delay: O < F=L
Kromrey, Czoty, & Nader, 2015; Lacreuse et al., 2001

OVX macaques (6–9 years) EE2 = no EE2 Lacreuse & Herndon, 2003

OVX macaques (7–16 years) E2 = Vehicle Lacreuse et al., 2009

OVX macaques (∼20–24 years) HRT > no HRT Lacreuse et al., 2002; Rapp et al., 2003; Voytko et al., 2008

OVX rats with low E2 Intra-PRh E2 < vehicle Gervais et al., 2013, 2016

Novel object preference

Rats Proestrous > estrous
E2 > no E2
Intra-HPC > vehicle
Intra-PRh > vehicle
Intra-HPC E2 = vehicle As reviewed by: Galea, Frick, Hampson, Sohrabji, & Choleris, 2016; Luine, 2015; Tuscher et al., 2014

Note: AD = Alzheimer’s Disease; DLPFC = dorsolateral prefrontal cortex; DRST = delayed recognition span test; E2 = 17β-estradiol; EB = estradiol benzoate; EE2 = ethinyl estradiol; ERT = estrogen replacement therapy; F = follicular phase; GnRHa = gonadotropin releasing hormone agonist; HPC = hippocampus; HRT = hormone replacement therapy; L = luteal; mo = month; O = Ovulatory; P = progesterone; PRh = perirhinal cortex; OVX = ovariectomized.