Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 28;15(1):1838052. doi: 10.1080/17482631.2020.1838052

Table I.

Characteristics of included studies

Authors
Year
Country Aim of the article Patient group Healthcare professionals Setting Co-production element
Intervention studies
(Balán et al., 2013) USA Describe experiences with a motivational pharmacotherapy intervention Spanish-speaking immigrant patients Psychiatrists Psychiatric clinic Co-productive counselling to improve treatment adherence
(DeCamp et al., 2015) USA Describe experiences with family advisory groups for clinics and hospitals Latina mothers Healthcare professionals Primary healthcare setting Identify and address areas for healthcare improvement in a co-productive process
(Lee et al., 2009) Australia Describing experiences of a consumer reference group to understand barriers for migrant patients Ethnic women Healthcare professionals Primary healthcare setting Patient participation in primary health care programme planning and services
(Kaltman et al., 2016) USA Measuring the effectiveness of an integrated self-management intervention Latino patients Healthcare professionals Primary healthcare setting Co-production of an intervention for diabetes and depression self-management
(Polo et al., 2012) USA Describing benefits and challenges of strategies aiming at increasing patient participation Latino patients Bilingual care managers, healthcare professionals Mental healthcare setting Individuals’ contribution to co-production of healthcare service
Interview studies
(King et al., 2015) Canada Examining strategies to enhance culturally sensitive care in paediatric rehabilitation Immigrant parents of children with disabilities Social workers, occupational and speech therapist Hospital setting Tools for and approaches to co-productive culturally sensitive care
(Brassart et al., 2017) Canada Describing barriers to and strategies for treatment engagement Immigrant parents raising a child with a disability Healthcare professional Hospital setting Engagement in and understanding of the therapeutic process of immigrant parents raising a child with a disability
(Naldemirci et al., 2018) Sweden Describing the risks of person-centred care in three research projects Migrant patients Healthcare professionals Healthcare setting (used for community setting) Co-production in person-centred care routines (patient narrative, partnership, and documentation)
Case studies
(Mendenhall et al., 2008) USA Describing the clinical journey of a refugee patient Refugee patient Healthcare professionals, outreach coordinator Primary healthcare setting A co-productive partnership between patient and healthcare professionals
(Balachandra et al., 2009) USA Describing the clinical journey of a refugee patient Refugee patient Healthcare professionals, Interpreters Primary healthcare setting Co-production between patient and health care professionals
(Cochran et al., 2017) USA Describing the tragic medical case of a Pakistani immigrant family Immigrant parents to a terminally ill child Healthcare professionals Hospital setting Cultural humility in shared decision-making
Systematic review
(Mead et al., 2013) USA Review of literature on shared-decision making Minority patients Healthcare professionals Hospital setting Factors influencing co-production with minority patients
Other publications
(Borkan et al., 2008) USA Perspective paper describing a framework for quality care that relates to ethnicity-based on case examples Migrant patients Healthcare professionals Hospital setting Approaches and tools to achieve co-productive cultural competency and humility
(Benson et al., 2010) Australia Editorial describing a refugee’s experiences of mental health services Refugee patient Healthcare professionals Hospital setting The role of narrative competence in co-producing a patient’s diagnosis and treatment
(Alegria et al., 2020) USA Editorial describing lessons learnt about how to engage ethnic minorities Minority patients Healthcare professionals Mental healthcare setting The role of egalitarian collaboration in the clinical encounter