Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 3;26(6):961–1001. doi: 10.1093/humupd/dmaa022

Table I.

Summary of study characteristics and main findings for sperm quality, sexual function and reproductive hormones outcomes.

Reference Country Number of cases and controls (with mean age in years) Disease Key findings Effect on fertility Effect on reproductive hormones Effect on sexual function NOS quality assessment
Study type
Aminosalicylic acid and similar agents
  • 42 (NR)

  • NR

IBD All sperm samples had abnormalities, mainly in motility. Sperm quality improved after stopping SSZ or switching to 5-ASA. NR
  • H

  • CS


  • 11 (32.3)

  • NR

IBD Oligospermia was detected in 72% of samples. After switching to 5-ASA, all samples showed improvement in sperm counts. * NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 15 (NR)

  • NR

IBD Oligospermia was detected on 40% of samples. After switching to mesalazine, samples showed improvement in sperm counts. NR NR
  • H

  • CS


  • 10 (30)

  • 19 (NR)

IBD Mean number of sperm count and of normal morphology was significantly lower. In five patients who stopped SSZ, improvement in sperm quality was observed. * NR
  • H

  • Ch


  • 10 (NR)

  • 0

Healthy participants Prostaglandin levels in seminal plasma decreased by 36% secondary to SSZ exposure. NR NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 39 (NR)

  • 9 (NR)

IBD SSZ exposure was associated with significant decrease in sperm counts, motility and increase in abnormal sperm morphology. * NR
  • L

  • CC


  • 7 (NR)

  • 7 (30.1)

IBD Sperm motility was reduced in all cases and serum testosterone levels were significantly lower in exposed cases. NR
  • L

  • CC


  • 8 (NR)

  • 10 (NR)

IBD Sperm head size was significantly larger in cases than in controls. NR NR
  • L

  • CS

  • 11 (28.8)

  • 6 (36)

IBD Lower progressive motility in SSZ-exposed group. NR NR
  • L

  • CC


  • 1 (39)

  • 0

IBD Case report: reversible infertility after stopping SSZ, patient on high dose GCs. * NR
  • NA

  • CR


  • 28 (NR)

  • 4 (NR)

IBD Exposed samples showed reduced sperm motility and density and altered morphology. After withdrawal, sperm density and motility improved significantly but not sperm morphology. * NR
  • H

  • CS


  • 4 (30)

  • 0

IBD
  • Case series:

  • One of the first case series where authors reported semen analysis abnormalities in SSZ-exposed patients.

NR NR
  • NR

  • Case series


  • 6 (NR)

  • 0

IBD Head, midpiece and tail abnormalities were detected in spermatozoa of SSZ-exposed patients. NR NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 3 (NR)

  • 0

IBD
  • Case series:

  • Sperm abnormalities detected after SSZ-exposed patients were sent to the infertility clinic. Sperm quality improved after switching therapy to balsalazide.

NR NR
  • NA

  • Case series


  • 6 (NR)

  • 0

Healthy participants Sperm motility decreased 15% after exposure to SSZ. NR NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 1 (33)

  • 0

IBD Case report: SSZ-exposed patient who was diagnosed with infertility and achieved a successful pregnancy after switching therapy from SSZ to 5-ASA. NR NR
  • NA

  • CR

  • 61 (NR)

  • 0

IBD 26.23% of SSZ-exposed patients developed oligospermia. This is the first article to comment on the possible effect by disease activity. NR NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 1 (32)

  • 0

IBD Case report: oligospermia associated with exposure to SSZ. NR NR
  • NA

  • CR


  • 1 (25)

  • 0

IBD Case report: pregnancy achieved after stopping SSZ therapy. NR NR
  • NA

  • CR


  • 1 (32)

  • 0

IBD Case report: SSZ-induced infertility case confirmed by sperm penetration assay (sperm analysis was normal). −* NR NR
  • NA

  • CR


  • 21 (32.8)

  • 0

IBD 86% of SSZ-exposed patients had abnormal semen analysis (72% had oligospermia). NR NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 2 (32)

  • 0

IBD Case report: reversible oligospermia in two cases exposed to SSZ. Both cases achieved pregnancies after drug withdrawal. −* NR NR
  • NA

  • CS


Antimalarials
  • 5 (NR)

  • 10 (NR)

Healthy participants No differences in sperm quality parameters and reproductive hormones were found between exposed and non-exposed after exposure of chloroquine 1 g/day for 2 days and then 500 mg/day for 1 day. * * NR
  • L

  • CS


NR Healthy participants Chloroquine had a dual in vitro effect, enhancing rapid motility at low concentrations but inhibiting it at higher concentrations. At 250 µg/ml chloroquine, all spermatozoa were static.
  • +

NR NR
  • CS

  • L

  • 8 (NR)

  • 0 (NR)

Healthy participants Chloroquine is present in seminal plasma even after long time of no exposure. NR NR NR
  • L

  • Ch


  • 4 (NR)

  • 0 (NR)

Healthy participants Chloroquine crosses the BTB, probably by passive diffusion. NR NR NR
  • NA

  • Case series


Calcineurin inhibitors (CsP, ciclosporine; EVE, everolimus; SIR, sirolimus; TAC, tacrolimus)
NR
  • Healthy participants

  • CsP

In vitro study showing that ciclosporine exerts deleterious effects on sperm, which become immotile and nonviable. NR NR
  • H

  • CS


  • 9 (41.2)

  • NR

  • Kidney transplantation

  • CsP

With the exemption of a low semen volume, ciclosporine A at 3 mg/kg/day did not result in other sperm quality or hormonal abnormalities. * * NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 10 (NR)

  • 0

  • Kidney transplantation

  • CsP

Pretreatment (pre-transplant) testosterone levels were below normal in 80%. After 12 months of treatment with CsP and other immunosuppressive drugs, testosterone levels significantly increased in all 10 cases. NR + NR
  • L

  • CC


  • 34 (32)

  • 31 (31)

  • Kidney transplantation

  • CsP

Sperm concentration was inversely correlated to the CsP whole blood levels. * +
  • H

  • CC


  • 256 (NR)

  • 0

  • Kidney transplantation

  • CsP–EVE

Testosterone levels increased from baseline in EVE and EVE-CsP groups. NR + NR
  • L

  • Ch


  • 37 (38.1)

  • 0

  • Kidney transplantation

  • CsP–TAC

No statistical differences in baseline levels of serum FSH, LH, testosterone and PRL between CsP- and TAC-treated patients. All results were in normal ranges. NR * NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 19 (35)

  • 0

  • Kidney transplantation

  • CsP

Serum levels of reproductive hormones were normal in CsP exposed cases. NR * NR
  • L

  • CS

1 (40)
  • Kidney transplantation

  • SIR

Case report: patient was infertile while on Sirolimus he developed oligospermia with normal hormone levels after switching to tacrolimus he was able to conceive. −* * NR
  • NA

  • CR


  • 6 (43)

  • 0

  • Kidney transplantation

  • SIR

Case series: infertile patients with oligospermia, after discontinuing SRL, all patients had increased sperm counts and were able to conceive. −* NR +
  • NA

  • Case series


  • 25 (32)

  • 67 (NR)

  • Kidney transplantation

  • SIR

Sirolimus-exposed patients had lower sperm counts and motility. The fathered pregnancy rate was significantly lower in exposed patients than in non-exposed. NR NR
  • H

  • CS


  • 1 (29)

  • 0

  • Kidney transplantation

  • SIR

Recovery of spermatogenesis after cessation of sirolimus. −* NR
  • NR

  • CR


1 (26)
  • Lung–heart transplantation

  • SIR

Benign Leydig cell tumour in a patient exposed to sirolimus lead to testicular biopsy that showed testicular atrophy and signs of impaired spermatogenesis. −* NR
  • NA

  • CR


1 (36)
  • Kidney transplantation

  • SIR

Case report: low sperm count and motility with abnormal morphology associated with sirolimus exposure. These changes were reversed after switching therapy to tacrolimus.* −* NR NR NA

  • 66 (NR)

  • 66 (NR)

  • Heart transplantation

  • SIR

Patients exposed to sirolimus had significantly lower serum testosterone levels and higher FHS/LH levels than control group. NR NR
  • H

  • CS


  • 32 (41)

  • 34 (47)

  • Kidney transplantation

  • SIR

Patients exposed to sirolimus had significantly lower serum testosterone levels and higher FHS/LH levels than control group. NR NR
  • H

  • CS

  • 28 (46.5)

  • 28 (45.5)

  • Kidney transplantation

  • SIR

Sirolimus daily dose and testosterone concentrations were significantly inversely correlated (r = –0.383). NR NR
  • H

  • CC


  • 59 (48)

  • 0

  • Kidney transplantation

  • SIR

Significantly reduced levels of circulating testosterone amongst patients receiving sirolimus alone compared to those treated with calcineurin inhibitors alone were identified. NR NR
  • L

  • CS


Colchicine
  • 2 (40)

  • 0

Gout Cytogenic analysis of sperm (FISH) revealed no damage secondary to colchicine use. * NR NR
  • NA

  • CR


  • 1 (48)

  • 0

Retinal vasculitis Case report: reversible azoospermia. NR NR
  • NA

  • CR


  • 62 (32.4)

  • 0

Behçet syndrome The longer the use of colchicine, the more serious the adverse events on sperm count + NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 15 (NR)

  • 0

Healthy participants In vitro study, high concentrations of colchicine may affect in vitro motility of sperms, probably by its direct effect on the microtubules. NR NR
  • H

  • CC


  • 6 (34.6)

  • 0

FMF After being advised to stop treatment with colchicine prior to attempt conception, sperm analysis was within normal limits in all six patients. * NR NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 7 (22)

  • 0

Healthy participants Colchicine caused no significant changes in sperm quality or reproductive hormones levels after 3 or 6 months of treatment. * * NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 1 (36)

  • 0

Gout Case report: azoospermia believed to be associated with colchicine use. Colchicine was stopped and after 3 months, sperm count improved and wife became pregnant. NR NR
  • NA

  • CR

  • 72 (14.5)

  • 0

FMF Mean colchicine dose at the time of sperm analysis was higher in patients with low sperm motility than that with normal sperm motility. NR NR
  • H

  • Ch


Cyclophosphamide
  • 13 (NR)

  • NR

SLE The median serum inhibin B was lower in patients treated with CYC compared with those without this therapy. NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 14 (NR)

  • NR

SLE
  • Semen analysis demonstrated that patients who had undergone IV CYC therapy had worse sperm quality (count, motility and morphology) compared with patients who did not undergo this treatment.

  • Elevated FSH levels were detected in patients who underwent IV CYC therapy.

NR
  • H

  • CC


  • 19 (NR)

  • 0

Bone marrow transplantation 10% of patients who received CYC showed azoospermia, and recovery of spermatogenesis was observed in 60% of patients. NR NR
  • NA

  • Case series


  • 17 (NA)

  • 0

Nephrotic syndrome Significant inverse correlation between sperm density and CYC dosage and duration of treatment. NR NR
  • NA

  • Case series


  • 22 (NR)

  • 20 (NR)

Nephrotic syndrome Altered spermatogenesis was found in 41.6% of adult patients treated with CYC during childhood (1.8–5.5 mg/kg/day for 12 weeks). No significant inverse correlation of total dose of the drug with sperm density. NR
  • H

  • CC


  • 30 (22)

  • 18 (28)

Nephrotic syndrome A significant inverse correlation was evident between sperm density and CYC dosage. Recovery of sperm count after prolonged interval after treatment is possible. *
  • L

  • CC

  • 6 (NR)

  • 0

Nephrotic syndrome Histologic oligospermic changes were observed in three patients treated with high doses (10.6–16.2 g during 125–432 days). NR NR
  • L

  • Case series


  • 31 (33)

  • 33 (NR)

Behcet syndrome
  • Azoospermia and oligospermia found in 13 out of 17 patients treated with CYC.

  • High mean FSH levels in CYC-treated patients

NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 19 (22)

  • 17 (23)

Nephrotic syndrome Lower ejaculate volumes and sperm densities and higher percentage of immotile and abnormal forms in CYC exposed group. NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 3 (NR)

  • 0

Nephrotic syndrome All patients showed abnormalities: oligospermia (1), azoospermia (1) and aplasia of germinal epithelium (1). NR NR
  • NA

  • Case series


  • 16 (NR)

  • 0

Nephrotic syndrome Sperm quality abnormalities found in 63%. An increase in the total dosage and in duration of the treatment was associated with a higher incidence of testicular dysfunction. NR
  • L

  • Ch


  • 12 (NR)

  • 0

Nephrotic syndrome Low doses (2–4 mg/kg/day) did not influence pituitary gonadal function (confirmed by biopsy). NR
  • NA

  • Case series


  • 15 (NR)

  • 0

Nephrotic syndrome Serum testosterone levels were normal in CYC-treated patients NR * NR
  • NA

  • Case series


  • 23 (NR)

  • 0

Nephrotic syndrome Sperm quality was uniformly decreased in CYC-treated patients and high FSH levels were common. NR
  • L

  • Case series


  • 8 (NR)

  • 0

Nephrotic syndrome All eight biopsy specimens had evidence of testicular atrophy, and it was profound in 6. NR NR
  • L

  • CS

  • 7 (NR)

  • 0

Nephrotic syndrome Biopsies confirmed absent spermatogenesis in azoospermic patients and FSH elevation correlated with degree of testicular damage. NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 1 (18)

  • 0

Nephrotic syndrome First case report that reported azoospermia associated with CYC exposure. NR NR
  • NA

  • CR


  • 15 (NR)

  • 0

Nephrotic syndrome All 15 patients received CYC and became azoospermic or oligospermic. Five patients received testosterone (100 mg intramuscularly every 15 days during CYC therapy). After CYC treatment, normal sperm analysis was reported in all five patients who received testosterone (vs 1/10) NR NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 31 (31.2)

  • 0

NR Testicular biopsy was performed on five patients who were receiving CYC and no spermatogenesis was found. NR NR
  • L

  • CS


Methotrexate
  • 1 (26)

  • 0

Psoriasis Case report: reversible oligospermia secondary to MTX. NR NR
  • NA

  • CR


  • 2 (NR)

  • 0

Psoriasis Sperm count was reduced to 63–97% at 2 weeks after a single IV injection of MTX. NR NR
  • NA

  • Case series


  • 26 (33–52)

  • 0

Psoriasis
  • The mean difference in sperm count, motility and abnormal forms before and after methotrexate therapy was not significant.

  • Five testicular biopsies performed where no alterations were found.

* NR NR
  • L

  • CS

  • 10 (23–46)

  • 0

Psoriasis Sperm abnormalities found in 40% of MTX-treated patients but sperm quality was better than in patients treated with glucocorticoids. + NR NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 7 (28)

  • 1912 (NR)

IBD In all MTX-treated patients, basic semen analyses were within normal limits
  • −DFI

  • *sperm

NR NR
  • L

  • CC


1 (50) Psoriasis Case report: gynaecomastia and oligospermia secondary to MTX NR NR
  • NA

  • CR


NSAIDs
  • 14 (NR)

  • 17 (NR)

  • Healthy participants

  • Ibuprofen

Experiment: exposure to ibuprofen in adult testis explants caused a state of compensated hypogonadism. NR NR
  • NA

  • RCT


  • 19 (NR)

  • 0

  • Healthy participants

  • Salicylate

In vitro study: salicylate significantly decreases sperm motility NR NR
  • H

  • CS


  • 6 (NR)

  • 0

  • Healthy participants

  • Naproxen

Treatment with naproxen significantly reduces the concentration of all PGs present in human seminal fluid. NR NR NR
  • H

  • CC


NA
  • Healthy participants

  • Aspirin and indo methacin

In vitro study: production of testosterone by Leydig cells was altered by exposure to all these drugs NR NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 10 (25.1)

  • 12 (27.4)

  • Healthy participants

  • Indomethacin

Exposure to indomethacin led to lower PGs levels in seminal plasma but unchanged sperm quality parameters and levels of reproductive hormones. * * NR
  • L

  • CS

Retinoids
  • 31 (NR)

  • 14 (NR)

  • Psoriasis

  • Acitretin

After 3 months of treatment at doses of 20 mg/day and 30 mg/day, sperm quality did not differ between cases and controls. * * NR
  • H

  • CC


  • 24 (30)

  • 0

  • Healthy participants

  • Acitretin

After 3 months of treatment at doses of 20 mg or 40 mg/day alitretinoin and 4-oxo-alitretinoin were detected in 11 of 12 semen samples.Concentrations detected are unlikely associated with teratogenicity. NR NR NR
  • L

  • CC


  • 1 (39)

  • 0

  • Psoriasis

  • Acitretin

Case report: 39-year old diagnosed with psoriasis reported erectile dysfunction after starting treatment with acitretin (25 mg/day). After 2 weeks of drug withdrawal, patient reported normalisation of sexual activity. NR NR
  • NA

  • CR


  • 5 (34)

  • 6 (34)

  • Psoriasis

  • Acitretin

After 3 months of treatment at doses of 25–50 mg/day, sperm quality did not differ between cases and controls * * NR
  • H

  • CC


  • 81 (22.6)

  • 0

  • Acne

  • Isotretinoin

After 6 months of treatment at doses of 120 mg/day, all the sperm quality parameters changed positively and reproductive hormone levels did not differ. + * NR
  • H

  • CS


  • 13 (27)

  • 0

  • Acne

  • Isotretinoin

After 4 months of treatment at doses of 1 mg/kg/day, sperm motility increased significantly and the other sperm quality parameters did not differ. + NR NR
  • H

  • CS


  • 1 (29)

  • 0

  • Acne

  • Isotretinoin

Case report of ejaculatory failure associated with isotretinoin (1 mg/kg/day). NR NR
  • NA

  • CR

  • 47 (NR)

  • 0

  • Acne

  • Isotretinoin

Independent drug safety website (RxISK.org) data: isotretinoin commonly associated with SD. NR NR
  • H

  • Ch


Systemic glucocorticoids
  • 4 (NR)

  • 7 (NR)

RA Case series: biopsies performed after exposure to 75 mg of cortisone, and no negative effect was observed. * NR NR
  • NA

  • Case series


  • 36 (62)

  • 70 (68)

RA Compared to healthy controls, RA patients taking prednisone had significantly lower testosterone levels and slightly elevated levels of FSH and LH. NR NR
  • L

  • CS


Thiopurines (AZA, Azathioprine)
  • 23 (32)

  • 0 (NR)

  • IBD

  • AZA

Semen analyses of 23 patients with IBD showed no negative association between AZA therapy and sperm quality. * NR NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 5 (NR)

  • 0

  • IBD

  • AZA

80% of patients had oligospermia. NR NR
  • NA

  • Case series


  • 7 (NR)

  • 0

  • Kidney transplantation

  • AZA

No correlation between poor spermatogenesis and AZA was reported. * * NR
  • NA

  • Case series


  • 40 (27.6)

  • 40 (23.3)

  • IBD

  • AZA

Sperm motility was decreased in patients, DFI was similar.
  • −DFI

  • *sperm

* NR
  • H

  • Ch


TNF-α inhibitors (INF, infliximab; ETN, etanercept; CZP, certolizumab pegol; ADA, adalimumab; GOL, golimumab)
  • 27 (37.5)

  • 0

  • Psoriasis

  • ETN

  • ADA

Compared with baseline, no significant differences in mean total sperm number, sperm concentration, total and progressive motility nor other semen parameters were noticed during follow-up. * NR NR
  • L

  • Ch

  • 10 (NR)

  • 0

  • Healthy participants

  • ETN

*In vitro study: TNF-α had a detrimental effect on sperm function and in vitro etanercept counteracted this toxic action of TNF-α. + NR NR
  • L

  • CS


  • 10 (28.7)

  • 20 (27.4)

  • SpA

  • ADA

Improvement in semen parameters after 12 months of TNF-α inhibitor treatment was reported. + * NR
  • H

  • CC


  • 23 (34.7)

  • 42 (34.8)

  • AS

  • ETN (2)

  • ADA (14)

  • INF(4)

Exposure of 20 patients to three different types of anti-TNFs did not have a negative impact on sperm quality after 3–6 months and in six cases after 12 months of treatment. * NR NR
  • L

  • CC


  • 10 (33)

  • 24 (28.5)

  • AS

  • ETN (2)

  • ADA (8)

Sperm abnormalities were comparable in patients and controls after 6 months of TNF-α inhibitor therapy. * * NR
  • H

  • CC


  • 15 (29.5)

  • 102 (30)

  • SpA

  • ETN

  • ADA

  • INF

  • Impaired sperm quality was especially found in the group of anti-TNF naive patients with active disease.

  • Sperm quality tended to improve within the five paired samples for sperm vitality (P = 0.08) and sperm motility (P = 0.08).

+ * NR
  • L

  • CC


  • 10 (31)

  • 0

  • IBD

  • INF

Sperm motility, or the percentage of sperm that show flagellar motion, was below normal in study patients after INF treatment. NR NR
  • H

  • CS


  • 10 (NR)

  • 10 (NR)

  • Healthy participants

  • CZP

CZP treatment was found to have no effect on the semen quality variables assessed vs placebo * NR NR
  • NA

  • RCT


  • 28 (30.8)

  • 17 (27.5)

  • IBD

  • INF (38)

  • ADA(7)

  • A statistically significant reduction in DFI was observed after the start of anti-TNF-α therapy (median DFI 12.8 off therapy versus 10.0 on therapy, P = 0.02).

  • No differences in sperm quality parameters were found between groups.

  • *sperm

  • +DFI

NR NR
  • H

  • Ch


  • 3 (40)

  • 0

  • AS

  • INF

Case series reporting asthenoazoospermia in two out of three patients using infliximab. −* NR NR
  • NA

  • Case series


  • 1 (35)

  • 0

  • AS

  • ADA

Case report: oligoasthenozoospermia and decreased motility reversed after stopping drug. −* NR NR
  • NA

  • CR


1 (50)
  • AS

  • INF

Case report: low sperm count, concentration increased after stopping IFX. −* NR NR
  • NA

  • CR


  • 5 (NR)

  • 0

  • SpA

  • ADA

Normospermia before and after TNF-α therapy initiation. * NR NR
  • L

  • Ch


1 (58)
  • RA

  • ADA

Case report: priapism associated with adalimumab. NR NR
  • NA

  • CR


  • 22 (37.8)

  • 0

  • AS

  • ETN

  • ADA

  • INF

Anti-TNF-α-treated patients showed significant improvements in four out of the five IIEF domains. NR NR +
  • L

  • Ch

Verdolizumab
  • 15 (33)

  • 33 (23)

IBD
  • Sperm quality and DFI were similar amongst cases and controls after exposure to verdolizumab.

  • Verdolizumab was detected in seminal plasma at levels that correspondent to 0.3–1.1% of serum levels.

* * NR
  • L

  • CC

H, high; L, low; NA, not applicable; NR, not reported; *, no differences reported; +, positive effect; −, negative effect; −*, reversible negative effect upon withdrawal; CC, case–control study; Ch, cohort study; CR, case report; CS, cross-sectional study; RCT, randomised controlled trial.