Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 4;21:100279. doi: 10.1016/j.aohep.2020.10.007

Table 1.

Characteristics of eligible studies.

First author Year Country Groups cases Age Sex (male, %) Liver biochemical parameters NOS scores
An W [19] 2020 China Survivors 99 54.6 ± 15.6 38 (38.4) ASTa, ALTa, GGTa, LDHa 8
Non-survivors 11 72.4 ± 7.1 6 (54.5)
Chen R [23] 2020 China Survivors 1570 47.65 ± 69 865 (55.1) ASTb, ALTb, TBILb, LDHb 7
Non-survivors 50 68.65 ± 26.72 39 (78.0)
Chen T [25] 2020 China Survivors 161 51.35 ± 21.69 88 (54.7) AST, ALT, TBILa, ALB, LDH, GGTa, ALPa 7
Non-survivors 113 68.06 ± 11.26 83 (73.5)
Chen TL [24] 2020 China Survivors 36 72 18 (50.0) AST, ALT, ALB, LDH, GLB 7
Non-survivors 19 77 16 (84.2)
Deng Y [26] 2020 China Survivors 116 43.52 ± 18.02 51 (44.0) ASTa, ALTa 7
Non-survivors 109 68.3 ± 9.02 73 (67.0)
Du R [27] 2020 China Survivors 158 56 ± 13.5 87 (55.1) ASTa, ALTa, TBILa, ALBa, GGTa, DBILa 8
Non-survivors 21 70.2 ± 7.7 10 (47.6)
He X [28] 2020 China Survivors 28 64.64 ± 12.34 18 (64.3) ALTb 9
Non-survivors 26 69.64 ± 10.98 16 (61.5)
Li D [29] 2020 China Survivors 136 54.76 ± 14.77 72 (52.9) ALBa, LDHa 8
Non-survivors 27 69.15 ± 13.12 14 (51.9)
Li Y [30] 2020 China Survivors 20 <51 8 (40.0) LDHb 7
Non-survivors 5 >51 4 (80.0)
Martín-Moro [43] 2020 Spain Survivors 23 65.98 ± 45.83 14 (60.9) LDHa 9
Non-survivors 11 76.01 ± 34.78 5 (45.5)
Ruan Q [31] 2020 China Survivors 82 58.81 ± 27.92 53 (64.6) ASTa, ALTa, TBILa, ALBa, LDHa 8
Non-survivors 68 66.29 ± 22.72 49 (72.1)
Wang D [32] 2020 China Survivors 88 46.19 ± 17.94 41 (46.6) ASTa, ALTa, TBILa, LDHa 7
Non-survivors 19 72.64 ± 13.62 16 (84.2)
Wang Ke [33] 2020 China Survivors 470 56.95 ± 15.62 224 (47.7) ASTb, ALTb, TBILb, ALBb, LDHb, GLBb, DBILb 7
Non-survivors 78 69.04 ± 12.24 55 (70.5)
Wang Kun [34] 2020 China Survivors 277 46 ± 14.4 129 (46.6) ASTa, ALTa, TBILa, ALBa, LDHa, GLBa, A/Ga 8
Non-survivors 19 65.6 ± 12.6 11 (57.9)
Wang L [20] 2020 China Survivors 274 68.7 ± 7.45 127 (46.4) ASTa, ALTa, LDHa 7
Non-survivors 65 76.35 ± 9.86 39 (60.0)
Wang Y [44] 2020 China Survivors 211 57.7 ± 16.42 105 (49.8) ASTa, ALTa, TBILa, ALBa, LDHa 7
Non-survivors 133 69.65 ± 11.24 74 (55.6)
Webb G [35] 2020 USA Survivors 30 57.29 ± 10.9 20 (66.7) TBILa, ALBa 9
Non-survivors 9 63.74 ± 5.25 5 (55.6)
Wu C [36] 2020 China Survivors 157 47.73 ± 11.09 99 (63.1) ASTa, ALTa, TBILa, ALBa, LDHa, GLBa,P-ALBa, TPa 7
Non-survivors 44 67.54 ± 12.03 29 (65.9)
Xu B [37] 2020 China Survivors 117 54.95 ± 17.26 59 (50.4) ASTa, ALTa 8
Non-survivors 28 72.73 ± 7.23 17 (60.7)
Yang X [38] 2020 China Survivors 20 51.9 ± 12.9 14 (70.0) TBILa 8
Non-survivors 32 64.6 ± 11.2 21 (65.6)
Yao Q [39] 2020 China Survivors 96 47.87 ± 16.28 36 (37.5) ALT, TBIL, ALBa 8
Non-survivors 12 62.99 ± 18.87 7 (58.3)
Zhang JG [42] 2020 China Survivors 12 63.85 ± 15.9 LDHb 8
Non-survivors 18 62.47 ± 16.47
Zhang JP [40] 2020 China Survivors 11 65.81 ± 15.38 6 (54.5) ALBa 8
Non-survivors 8 77.69 ± 8.72 5 (62.5)
Zhang JX [41] 2020 China Survivors 638 56.58 ± 18.57 306 (48.0) ASTb, ALTb, ALBb, LDHb 7
Non-survivors 25 68.82 ± 13.36 15 (60.0)
Zhou F [14] 2020 China Survivors 137 51.65 ± 9.74 81 (59.1) ALT, ALBa, LDH 8
Non-survivors 54 69.35 ± 9.9 38 (70.4)

NOS, Newcastle–Ottawa Scale; AST, aspartate aminotransferase; ALT, alanine transaminase; TBIL, total bilirubin; ALB, albumin; LDH, lactic dehydrogenase; GLB, globulin; GGT, gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase; ALP, alkaline phosphatase; DBIL, direct bilirubin; A/G, ALB-to-GLB ratio; P-ALB, prealbumin.

a

This parameter was available as a continuous outcome in the study.

b

This parameter was available as a dichotomous outcome in the study.

No superscript means this parameter was available as both continuous and dichotomous outcomes in the study.