Table 13.

Results obtained by using the LL imaginary sub-band obtained by applying DT-CWT to the chest X-ray images (second training-test data set)

CNN Type	Method	TP	FN	TN	FP	SEN	SPE	ACC	F-1	AUC	CPU Time
First CNN Architecture	Without LBP	145,0	5,0	322,0	4,0	0,9667	0,9877	0,9811	0,9699	0,9970	0,7587
	With LBP	134,8	15,2	312,0	14,0	0,8987	0,9571	0,9387	0,9022	0,9861	0,7578
	Pipeline-1	147,2	2,8	322,0	4,0	0,9813	0,9877	0,9857	0,9774	0,9981	15,164
	Pipeline-2	146,0	4,0	322,2	3,8	0,9733	0,9883	0,9836	0,9740	0,9982	15,164
	Pipeline-3	147,6	2,4	321,0	5,0	0,9840	0,9847	0,9845	0,9755	0,9985	15,164
	Pipeline-4	144,6	5,4	323,0	3,0	0,9640	0,9908	0,9824	0,9718	0,9969	15,164
Second CNN Architecture	Without LBP	146,0	4,0	323,2	2,8	0,9733	0,9914	0,9857	0,9772	0,9981	15,022
	With LBP	128,8	21,2	306,0	20,0	0,8587	0,9387	0,9134	0,8615	0,9773	16,851
	Pipeline-1	147,4	2,6	322,6	3,4	0,9827	0,9896	0,9874	0,9800	0,9979	31,874
	Pipeline-2	146,2	3,8	323,0	3,0	0,9747	0,9908	0,9857	0,9773	0,9984	31,874
	Pipeline-3	147,8	2,2	322,0	4,0	0,9853	0,9877	0,9870	0,9794	0,9983	31,874
	Pipeline-4	145,6	4,4	323,8	2,2	0,9707	0,9933	0,9861	0,9778	0,9982	31,874