Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 4;51(5):2740–2763. doi: 10.1007/s10489-020-02019-1

Table 24.

Comparison of the results obtained, within the scope of the study, with previous studies

Study SEN SPE ACC F-1 AUC
Tuncer et al. [26] 0,8149-1,0000 0,9380-1,0000 0,9049-0,9955 X X
Panwar et al. [27] 0,9762 0,7857 0,881 X X
Ozturk et al. [28] 0,9513 0,953 0,9808 0,9651 X
Mohammed et al. [29] 0,706-0,974 0,557-1,000 0,620-0,987 0,555–0,987 0,800-0,988
Khan et al. [30] 0,993 0,986 0,990 0,985 X
Apostolopoulos and Mpesiana [31] 0,9866 0,9646 0,9678 X X
Waheed et al. [32] 0,69-0,90 0,95-0,97 0,85-0,95 X X
Mahmud et al. [33] 0,978 0,947 0,974 0,971 0,969
Vaid et al. [34] 0,9863 0,9166 0,9633 0,9729 X
Benbrahim et al. [35] 0,9803-0,9811 X 0,9803-0,9901 0,9803-0,9901 X
Elaziz et al. [36] 0,9875-0,9891 X 0,9609-0,9809 X X
Martínez et al. [37] 0,97 X 0,97 0,97 X
Loey et al. [38] 1,0000 1,0000 1,0000 X X
Toraman et al. [39] 0,28-0,9742 0,8095–0,98 0,4914-0,9724 0,55-0,9724 X
Duran-Lopez et al. [40] 0,9253 0,9633 0,9443 0,9314 0,988
Minaee et al. [41] 0,98 0,751-0,929 X X X
Our Study (Before Pipeline-First data set) 0,9853 0,8950 0,9539 0,9655 0,9939
Our Study (Before Pipeline-First data set) 0,9747 0,9725 0,9739 0,9799 0,9976
Our Study (Before Pipeline-First data set) 0,9800 0,9700 0,9765 0,9819 0,9975
Our Study (Before Pipeline-First data set) 0,9773 0,9675 0,9739 0,9800 0,9983
Our Study (Before Pipeline-Second data set) 0,9733 0,9914 0,9857 0,9772 0,9981
Our Study (Before Pipeline-Second data set) 0,9640 0,9920 0,9832 0,9730 0,9985
Our Study (Before Pipeline-Second data set) 0,9680 0,9902 0,9832 0,9732 0,9982
Our Study (Before Pipeline-Combined data set) 0,9253 0,9892 0,9719 0,9468 0,9937
Our Study (Before Pipeline-Combined data set) 0,9187 0,9936 0,9734 0,9486 0,9975
Our Study (Before Pipeline-Combined data set) 0,9240 0,9931 0,9745 0,9511 0,9949
Our Study (After Pipeline-First data set) 0,9947 0,9575 0,9817 0,9862 0,9990
Our Study (After Pipeline-First data set) 0,9813 0,9800 0,9809 0,9853 0,9977
Our Study (After Pipeline-First data set) 0,9933 0,9675 0,9843 0,9881 0,9988
Our Study (After Pipeline-Second data set) 0,9920 0,9877 0,9891 0,9828 0,9991
Our Study (After Pipeline-Second data set) 0,9640 0,9939 0,9845 0,9750 0,9980
Our Study (After Pipeline-Combined data set) 0,9760 0,9892 0,9856 0,9734 0,9984
Our Study (After Pipeline-Combined data set) 0,9653 1,0000 0,9906 0,9823 0,9997