Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2021 Jun 15.
Published in final edited form as: Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng. 2020 Apr 15;362:112834. doi: 10.1016/j.cma.2020.112834

Table 4. Reproducing Table 2 from Gao et al. [67] using the Prony-based method Eq. (12) for refinement in space with a constant Δt = 5e–5.

Gao et al. [67] Prony approximation
N = 3 N = 6 N = 9 N = 12
α h Δt E(h, Δt) log2 E(h, Δt) log2 E(h, Δt) log2 E(h, Δt) log2 E(h, Δt) log2
1/2 1/10 1 /20 000 1.50e–2 2.00 5.95e–3 2.06 6.02e–3 2.01 6.02e–3 2.01 6.01e–3 2.01
1/20 3.75e–3 2.00 1.43e–3 2.22 1.50e–3 2.00 1.50e–3 2.00 1.50e–3 2.00
1/40 9.38e–4 2.00 3.07e–4 3.24 3.75e–4 1.99 3.75e–4 1.99 3.74e–4 2.00
1/80 2.35e–4 2.00 3.25e–5 -0.75 9.47e–5 1.95 9.44e–5 1.96 9.37e–5 2.00
1/160 5.86e–5 * 5.47e–5 * 2.45e–5 * 2.43e–5 * 2.35e–5 *
2/3 1/10 1 /20 000 1.37e–2 1.99 5.67e–3 2.08 5.77e–3 2.00 5.77e–3 2.00 5.77e–3 2.00
1/20 3.44e–3 2.00 1.35e–3 2.31 1.44e–3 1.98 1.44e–3 1.97 1.44e–3 1.98
1/40 8.61e–4 2.00 2.71e–4 3.33 3.66e–4 1.92 3.67e–4 1.90 3.67e–4 1.91
1/80 2.15e–4 2.00 2.68e–5 –1.58 9.67e–5 1.71 9.81e–5 1.66 9.75e–5 1.68
1/160 5.37e–5 * 8.01e–5 * 2.96e–5 * 3.11e–5 * 3.05e–5 *