Table 2. Synthesis of intervention-specific impacts on health outcomes in primary and supporting evaluations.
Communicable diseases | Nutritional deficiencies | Maternal & perinatal | Injuries | Non-communicable diseases | General mental health | General physical health | Quality of life | Mortality | Personal or neighborhood safety | Social capital | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A. Primary evaluations | |||||||||||||
Single Interventions | Housing Interventions | ||||||||||||
TECHO | (+) (+) | ||||||||||||
Galiani et al., 2018 | (+)(+) | NS | |||||||||||
Galiani et al., 2017 | (+) | ||||||||||||
Transportation Interventions | |||||||||||||
Metrocable | (+)(+) | ||||||||||||
Cerdá et al., 2012 | |||||||||||||
Street asphalting | NS NS | NS | NS | NS | NS NS | ||||||||
Gonzalez-Navarro and Quintana-Domeque, 2016 | |||||||||||||
Gonzalez Navarro 2010 | |||||||||||||
Sanitation Interventions | |||||||||||||
Water expansion Galiani 2007 | NS(+) | ||||||||||||
Comprehensive Interventions | Programa HÃ!bitat | NS NS | (+)(+) NS | NS NS | |||||||||
McIntosh et al., 2018 | |||||||||||||
Ordóñez Barba and Ruiz Ochoa, 2015 | |||||||||||||
Ordóñez Barba et al., 2013 | |||||||||||||
Vila Viva | NT | ||||||||||||
Friche et al.,2015 | |||||||||||||
Favela-Barrio Soares 2005 | NS | NS | NS | NS | |||||||||
Slum upgrading Butala 2010 | (+) | ||||||||||||
Each outcome measured at each time point within the evaluations included in the current review and the review by Turley et al. is represented by a mark in the table. Reference: (+) = significant health-promoting direction of effects; | |||||||||||||
NS= non-significant effect; NT = notsignificance tested. | |||||||||||||
Note: The Jakarta Kampung Improvement Programstudied in Taylor (1987) was not included as it only involved the assessment of poverty and no other health outcome or any other outcome in the pathway to health. |
Communicable diseases | Nutritional deficiencies | Maternal & perinatal | Injuries | Non-communicable diseases | General mental health | General physical health | Quality of life | Mortality | Personal or neighborhood safety | Social capital | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
B. Supporting evaluations | ||||||||||||
Single Interventions | Housing Interventions | |||||||||||
TECHO | (+)(+)(+) | (+) NS | (+)(+) | NS NS | ||||||||
Simonelli et al., 2013 | NS | |||||||||||
South African Housing | NS NS | NS | NS | NS NS | ||||||||
Subsidy | ||||||||||||
Marais and Cloete, 2014 | ||||||||||||
People’s Housing Program | NS | (+) | (+) | (+)NS | (+) | |||||||
Shortt and Hammett, 2013 | ||||||||||||
Piso Firme | NS(+) | NS(+) | (+) | NS | NS | (+) | ||||||
Cattaneo 2009 | ||||||||||||
Comprehensive Interventions | Slum Improvement Program | (+)(+)(+) | (+) | |||||||||
Parikh et al., 2015 | NT | |||||||||||
Parikh et al., 2012 | ||||||||||||
Parikh in press | ||||||||||||
Barrio Escopa project | ||||||||||||
De Leon 1986 | (+) | |||||||||||
Slum Improvement Program | ||||||||||||
Moitra 1987 | NT | |||||||||||
Small Towns Urban | NT | |||||||||||
Development Project | ||||||||||||
Milone 1993 | ||||||||||||
Slum Improvement project | NS NT | NS NT | NT NT | |||||||||
Abelson 1996 | ||||||||||||
Zonal Improvement Program | (+) | |||||||||||
Aiga 2002 | ||||||||||||
Multicomponent physical | NT NT NT | |||||||||||
upgrading | ||||||||||||
Moraes 2004 | ||||||||||||
Each outcome measured at each time point within the evaluations included in the current review and the review by Turley et al. is represented by a mark in the table. Reference: (+)= significant health-promoting direction of effects; | ||||||||||||
NS = non-significant effect; NT = not significance tested. | ||||||||||||
Note: The Slum Networking intervention measured by Joshi (2002) was not included as it only involved the assessment of poverty and no other health outcome or any other outcome in the pathway to health. |