Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Feb 28.
Published in final edited form as: J Med Artif Intell. 2022 Dec;5:11. doi: 10.21037/jmai-22-36

Table 1. List of all relevant studies for coronary anatomy imaging included in this systematic review.

First author Year Model output Sample size Imaging modality Model Index test Reference test External validation
Rodrigues et al. (3) 2016 Pericardial and mediastinal fat classification 20 CCTA RF Manual feature extraction algorithms Expert reader No
Kang et al. (4) 2015 Coronary stenosis classification 42 CCTA SVM Expert reader Invasive coronary angiography No
Araki et al. (5) 2016 Coronary plaque calcification 15 IVUS SVM NA cIMT No
Itu et al. (6) 2016 FFR prediction 87 CCTA MLP Computational fluid dynamics CT-FFR Invasive FFR Yes
Wolterink et al. (7) 2016 CAC quantification 250 CCTA CNN NA Expert reader No
Su et al. (8) 2017 Media adventitia border detection 4 IVUS MLP NA Expert reader No
Yong et al. (9) 2017 Coronary lumen segmentation 64 OCT CNN NA Expert reader No
Xu et al. (10) 2017 Coronary plaque classification 18 OCT CNN and SVM NA Expert reader No
Zreik et al. (11) 2019 Coronary plaque classification 163 CCTA RNN NA Expert reader No
Zreik et al. (12) 2018 LV segmentation for coronary stenosis significance classification 156 CCTA CNN + SVM NA Invasive FFR No
Kolluru et al. (13) 2018 Coronary plaque classification 48 OCT CNN NA Expert reader No
Zhang et al. (14) 2018 Coronary plaque classification 61 IVUS SVM NA Expert reader No
Oh et al. (15) 2018 Lipid core plaque detection 116 IVUS CNN NA Expert reader No
van Rosendael et al. (16) 2018 Clinical outcome prediction 8,844 CCTA Boosted ensemble algorithm Conventional clinical risk scores Clinical outcomes No
Stuckey et al. (17) 2018 CAD detection 606 cPSTA Elastic net NA Invasive coronary angiography No
Lessmann et al. (18) 2018 CAC detection 1,744 CCTA CNN NA Expert reader No
Šprem et al. (19) 2018 Motion artefact detection in CACS 585 CCTA CNN NA Conventional CACS No
Hae et al. (20) 2018 Prediction of myocardium subtended by coronary stenosis 932 CCTA SVM NA Invasive coronary angiography Yes
Dey et al. (21) 2018 FFR prediction 254 CCTA Boosted ensemble algorithm Conventional CCTA Invasive FFR No
van Hamersvelt et al. (22) 2019 LV segmentation for coronary stenosis significance classification 126 CCTA SVM NA Expert reader No
Cho et al. (23) 2019 FFR classification 1,501 Invasive coronary angiography XGBoost NA Invasive FFR Yes
Liu et al. (24) 2019 Vulnerable plaque detection 2,300 (images) OCT CNN NA Expert reader No
Gessert et al. (25) 2019 Coronary plaque segmentation 49 OCT CNN NA Expert reader No
Abdolmanafi et al. (26) 2019 Coronary artery wall pathology detection 45 OCT CNN NA Expert reader No
Liu et al. (27) 2019 Bifurcation lesion detection 308 Invasive coronary angiography CNN NA Expert reader No
Gharaibeh et al. (28) 2019 CAC quantification 34 IVUS CNN NA Expert reader No
Jun et al. (29) 2019 Thin cap fibroatheroma classification 100 IVUS CNN NA OCT No
Lee et al. (30) 2019 Coronary artery segmentation 4,980 Invasive coronary angiography CNN NA Expert reader No
Yang et al. (31) 2019 Coronary artery segmentation 2,042 Invasive coronary angiography CNN NA Expert reader Yes
Wang et al. (32) 2019 Media adventitia border detection 22 IVUS MLP P6 and P8 detectors Expert reader No
Johnson et al. (33) 2019 Clinical outcome prediction 6,892 CCTA KNN Conventional CT and clinical risk scores Clinical outcomes No
Kolossváry et al. (34) 2019 Coronary plaque classification 21 CCTA Least angle regression + radiomics Histogram assessment by expert reader Histology (ex vivo) No
Wang et al. (35) 2019 FFR prediction 63 CCTA RNN Conventional CCTA Invasive FFR No
Datong et al. (36) 2019 CAC detection 820 (images) CCTA CNN NA Expert reader No
Oikonomou et al. (37) 2019 Clinical outcome prediction 5,487 CCTA RF + radiomics Conventional clinical risk scores Clinical outcomes Yes
Masuda et al. (38) 2019 Coronary plaque classification 78 CCTA Extreme gradient boosting Conventional CCTA IVUS No
Kigka et al. (39) 2019 Coronary plaque progression prediction 40 CCTA RF NA Clinical outcomes No
Zhang et al. (40) 2019 Coronary risk prediction 4,415 CCTA Boosted ensemble algorithm Conventional clinical risk scores Clinical outcomes No
Commandeur et al. (41) 2019 Epicardial adipose tissue quantification 850 CCTA CNN NA Expert reader No
Hong et al. (42) 2019 Coronary artery segmentation 156 CCTA CNN NA Expert reader No
Huo et al. (43) 2019 CAC detection 2,332 CCTA CNN NA Expert reader No
Wang et al. (44) 2020 MPVI prediction 9 IVUS SVM and RF GLMM Follow-up MPVI No
Lee et al. (45) 2020 FFR prediction 1,328 IVUS AdaBoost NA Invasive FFR No
Wu et al. (46) 2020 Coronary stenosis detection 63 Invasive coronary angiography CNN NA Expert reader No
Sampedro-Gómez et al. (47) 2020 Stent restenosis prediction 263 Invasive coronary angiography ERT Conventional clinical risk scores Clinical outcomes No
Miyoshi et al. (48) 2020 Coronary neointimal coverage classification, yellow colour classification, red thrombus detection 107 Invasive coronary angioscopy GAN SVM Expert reader Yes
Zhang et al. (49) 2020 Coronary stenosis classification 228 Invasive coronary angiography HEAL NA Expert reader No
Du et al. (50) 2021 Coronary artery segmentation, stenosis classification, total occlusion detection, calcification detection, thrombus detection, dissection detection 10,073 Invasive coronary angiography CNN and GAN NA Expert reader No
He et al. (51) 2020 Coronary plaque segmentation 24 OCT CNN NA Expert reader No
Yabushita et al. (52) 2021 Coronary artery segmentation 146 Invasive coronary angiography CNN NA Expert reader No
Hamaya et al. (53) 2020 Clustering epicardial functional stenosis with low CFR 364 Invasive coronary angiography Unsupervised hierarchical clustering K-mean clustering Clinical outcomes No
Lee et al. (54) 2019 Coronary plaque segmentation 55 OCT CNN A-line CNN detector Expert reader No
Min et al. (55) 2020 Thin cap fibroatheroma classification 602 OCT CNN NA Expert reader No
Commandeur et al. (56) 2020 Clinical outcome prediction 1,912 CCTA Extreme gradient boosting Conventional CT and clinical risk scores Clinical outcomes No
Muscogiuri et al. (57) 2020 CAD classification 288 CCTA CNN NA Expert reader No
Benz et al. (58) 2020 Coronary artery image reconstruction 43 CCTA CNN Adaptive statistical iterative reconstruction Invasive coronary angiography No
Wang et al. (59) 2020 CAC quantification 530 CCTA CNN NA Expert reader No
Al’Aref et al. (60) 2020 Coronary stenosis prediction from CACS 13,054 CCT Boosted ensemble algorithm NA CCTA No
Kawasaki et al. (61) 2020 FFR prediction 47 CCTA RF NA Invasive FFR No
Fischer et al. (62) 2020 CAC quantification 200 CCTA RNN NA Expert reader No
van Velzen et al. (63) 2020 CAC quantification 7,240 CCTA CNN NA Expert reader No
Zreik et al. (64) 2020 Coronary stenosis classification 187 CCTA CNN + SVM NA Invasive FFR No
Kumamaru et al. (65) 2020 FFR prediction 1,052 CCTA CNN + GAN Conventional CCTA Invasive FFR No
Candemir et al. (66) 2020 Coronary stenosis classification 493 CCTA CNN NA Expert reader Yes
Shu et al. (67) 2022 Clinical outcome prediction 154 CCTA SVM + radiomics NA Expert reader Yes
van den Oever et al. (68) 2020 CAC rule out 100 CCTA CNN NA Expert reader Yes
Han et al. (69) 2020 Coronary stenosis classification 150 CCTA CNN Expert reader Invasive coronary angiography No
Han et al. (70) 2020 Rapid plaque progression prediction 1,083 CCTA Boosted ensemble algorithm Conventional clinical risk scores Clinical outcomes No
Lin et al. (71) 2020 Pericoronary adipose tissue prognosis prediction 177 CCTA Boosted ensemble algorithm + radiomics Conventional CT and clinical risk scores Clinical outcomes No
Chen et al. (72) 2020 Coronary artery segmentation 124 CCTA CNN Expert reader Invasive coronary angiography No
Tesche et al. (73) 2021 Clinical outcome prediction 361 CCTA Boosted ensemble algorithm Conventional CT and clinical risk scores Clinical outcomes No
Al’Aref et al. (74) 2020 CL precursors detection 46 CCTA Boosted ensemble algorithm Traditional CCTA CL precursors Invasive coronary angiography Yes
Hong et al. (75) 2020 CCTA image noise reduction 82 CCTA CNN NA Invasive coronary angiography No
Podgorsak et al. (76) 2020 Coronary segmentation and FFR prediction 64 CCTA CNN Expert reader Invasive FFR No
Eberhard et al. (77) 2020 FFR prediction 56 CCTA CNN Invasive FFR Clinical outcomes No
Son et al. (78) 2020 CAC prediction 20,130 Retinal fundus imaging CNN NA CCTA No
Carson et al. (79) 2020 FFR prediction 25 CCTA MLP and RNN MPR Invasive FFR Yes
Gangl et al. (80) 2019 Coronary plaque segmentation 104 (images) OCT CNN NA Expert reader No
Głowacki et al. (81) 2020 Coronary stenosis prediction from CACS 435 CCT Extreme gradient boosting NA CCTA No
Hoshino et al. (82) 2020 FAI clusters 220 CCTA Unsupervised hierarchical clustering Invasive FFR Clinical outcomes No
Kawaguchi et al. (83) 2018 FFR prediction 934 CCTA CNN NA Invasive FFR No

CCTA, coronary computed tomographic angiography; RF, random forest; SVM, support vector machine; IVUS, intra-vascular ultrasound; NA, not available; cIMT, carotid intima-media thickness; FFR, fractional flow reserve; MLP, multi-layer perceptron; CT, computed tomography; CAC, coronary artery calcification; CNN, convolutional neural network; OCT, optical coherence tomography; RNN, recurrent neural network; LV, left ventricle; CAD, coronary artery disease; cPSTA, cardiac phase space tomography analysis; CACS, coronary artery calcium score; KNN, k-nearest neighbours; MPVI, morphological plaque vulnerability index; GLMM, generalised linear mixed model; ERT, extremely randomised tree; GAN, generative adversarial network; HEAL, hierarchical attentive multi-view; CFR, coronary flow reserve; CL, culprit lesion; MPR, multi-variant polynomial regression; FAI, fat attenuation index.