Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2024 Jan 11.
Published in final edited form as: Front Sleep. 2023 Apr 6;2:1097946. doi: 10.3389/frsle.2023.1097946

Table 3. Summary of statistical analysis (two-way ANCOVA with Bonferroni’s correction for multiple comparisons) for all CANTAB behavioral tasks and all pair-wise comparisons between groups (control, mild OSA, and severe OSA).

Pairwise comparisons Predicted (LS) mean diff. 95% CI of diff. Below threshold Summary Adjusted P-value Effect size
Lower Upper
ASTLSWMD
Control vs. mild −194.32 −345.94 −42.71 Yes ** 0.0090 −1.521
Control vs. severe −224.73 −400.66 −48.80 Yes ** 0.0090 −1.698
Mild vs. severe −30.41 −161.65 100.83 No ns 1.0000 −0.230
ASTLCMD
Control vs. mild 76.07 −39.03 191.17 No ns 0.3070 0.784
Control vs. severe 182.28 48.71 315.84 Yes ** 0.0050 1.815
Mild vs. severe 182.28 6.57 205.84 Yes * 0.0340 1.058
ERTOMDRT
Control vs. mild 540.99 −72.07 1,154.05 No ns 0.0970 1.047
Control vs. severe 806.60 95.22 1,517.98 Yes * 0.0220 1.508
Mild vs. severe 265.61 −265.06 796.29 No ns 0.6320 0.497
ERTTH
Control vs. mild −8.57 −21.01 3.87 No ns 0.2680 −0.830
Control vs. severe −15.96 −30.40 −1.53 Yes * 0.0270 −1.470
Mild vs. severe −7.39 −18.16 3.38 No ns 0.2710 −0.681
PALTEA
Control vs. mild 0.13 −13.12 13.39 No ns 1.0000 0.012
Control vs. severe 5.52 −9.86 20.90 No ns 1.0000 0.477
Mild vs. severe 5.39 −6.09 16.86 No ns 0.7190 0.466
PALFAMS
Control vs. mild 0.64 −4.03 5.32 No ns 1.0000 0.163
Control vs. severe −1.90 −7.33 3.53 No ns 1.0000 −0.465
Mild vs. severe −2.54 −6.59 1.51 No ns 0.3590 −0.623
PRMPCI
Control vs. mild 7.80 −2.08 17.67 No ns 0.1610 0.937
Control vs. severe 3.19 −8.26 14.65 No ns 0.5380 0.371
Mild vs. severe −4.60 −13.15 3.95 No ns 0.5380 −0.534
PRMPCD
Control vs. mild −10.22 −27.74 7.30 No ns 0.4410 −0.692
Control vs. severe −9.88 −30.21 10.44 No ns 0.6710 −0.647
Mild vs. severe 0.33 −14.83 15.50 No ns 1.0000 0.022
RTIFMDRT
Control vs. mild 6.64 −33.59 46.87 No ns 1.0000 0.196
Control vs. severe 42.25 −4.44 88.94 No ns 0.0860 1.203
Mild vs. severe 35.61 0.78 70.44 Yes * 0.0440 1.015
RTIFMMT
Control vs. mild 26.05 −16.22 68.32 No ns 0.3790 0.732
Control vs. severe 69.31 20.26 118.36 Yes ** 0.0040 1.879
Mild vs. severe 43.26 6.67 79.85 Yes * 0.0170 1.173
SWMBE
Control vs. mild 4.76 −9.68 19.20 No ns 1.0000 1.443
Control vs. severe 9.23 −7.52 25.99 No ns 1.0000 2.703
Mild vs. severe 4.47 −8.02 16.97 No ns 1.0000 1.311
SWMS
Control vs. mild 1.13 −2.79 5.04 No ns 1.0000 0.797
Control vs. severe 0.08 −4.46 4.63 No ns 1.0000 0.058
Mild vs. severe −1.04 −4.43 2.35 No ns 1.0000 −0.711
SSPFSL
Control vs. mild −1.10 −2.78 0.58 No ns 0.3140 −0.726
Control vs. severe −1.79 −3.74 0.16 No ns 0.0790 −1.140
Mild vs. severe −0.69 −2.14 0.76 No ns 0.7030 −0.439
SSPRSL
Control vs. mild −0.66 −2.46 1.14 No ns 1.0000 −0.227
Control vs. severe −1.47 −3.56 0.61 No ns 0.2460 −0.490
Mild vs. severe −0.82 −2.37 0.74 No ns 0.5740 −0.271
OTSPSFC
Control vs. mild −1.82 −5.27 1.63 No ns 0.5660 −0.559
Control vs. severe −2.05 −6.05 1.96 No ns 0.6050 −0.615
Mild vs. severe −0.23 −3.22 2.76 No ns 1.0000 −0.125
DMSPC
Control vs. mild −0.52 −8.72 7.69 No ns 1.0000 −0.075
Control vs. severe 2.31 −7.22 11.83 No ns 1.0000 0.322
Mild vs. severe 2.82 −4.28 9.93 No ns 0.9530 0.395
DMSMDLAD
Control vs. mild 1,646.16 602.20 2,690.12 Yes *** 0.0009 1.872
Control vs. severe 2,368.74 1,157.36 3,580.13 Yes *** 0.0008 2.600
Mild vs. severe 722.59 −181.08 1,626.25 No ns 0.1520 0.793
DMSPEGE
Control vs. mild 0.00 −0.19 0.20 No ns 1.0000 0.061
Control vs. severe −0.05 −0.27 0.18 No ns 1.0000 −2.809
Mild vs. severe −0.05 −0.22 0.12 No ns 1.0000 −2.869
RVPA
Control vs. mild −0.02 −0.09 0.06 No ns 1.0000 −0.260
Control vs. severe −0.05 −0.14 0.04 No ns 0.5920 −0.693
Mild vs. severe −0.03 −0.10 0.04 No ns 0.7830 −0.442
RVPMDL
Control vs. mild 162.88 −50.81 376.56 No ns 0.1850 0.905
Control vs. severe 236.00 −11.96 483.96 No ns 0.0660 1.265
Mild vs. severe 73.12 −111.85 258.10 No ns 0.9600 0.392
SSTSSRT
Control vs. mild 17.46 −28.09 63.01 No ns 1.0000 0.455
Control vs. severe 38.83 −14.03 91.69 No ns 0.2130 0.977
Mild vs. severe 21.37 −18.06 60.80 No ns 0.5300 0.538
*

P < 0.05.

**

P < 0.01.

***

P < 0.001.

All values are evaluated at the following values: Age = 41.59 years, BMI = 26.78 kg/m2.

CANTAB tests (23 tests in 11 modalities) for controls, mild OSA and severe OSA. RTIFDMRT, Median duration between stimulus onset and release of button; RTIFMMT, Mean time taken to touch stimulus after button release; SWMBE, Between errors—number of times that a box in which a token has been previously found is revisited; SWMS, Number of distinct boxes used for the subject to begin new search for a token; PRMPCI, Number of correct responses made in immediate condition; PRMPCD, Number of correct responses made in delayed condition; ERTOMDRT, Median latency of response from stimulus onset to subject response; ERTTH, Number of correctly answered responses; ASTSWMD, Median latency of response in rule switching trials; ASTLCMD, Median latency of response on congruent trials; SSPFSL, Longest sequence successfully recalled—forward variant; SSPRSL, Longest sequence successfully recalled—reversed variant; PALTEA, Number of times incorrect box is chosen + adjusted estimated number of errors that would have been made on any problems, attempts, and recalls that were not reached; PALFAMS, Number of correct box choices made on first attempt; DMSPC, Percentage of assessment trials during which subject selected the correct box on their first box choice; DMSMDLAD, Median latency from the available choices being displayed to the subject choosing the correct choice; DMSPEGE, Reports the probability of an error occurring when the previous trial was responded incorrectly; RVPMDL, Median response latency during assessment sequence blocks where the subject responded correctly; RVPA, Measure of how good the subject is at detecting target sequences; SSTSSRT, Length of time between the go stimulus and the stop stimulus at which the subject is able to successfully inhibit their response on 50% of the trials; OTSPSFC, Number of assessment problems on which the first box choice made was correct; ns, non significant.