Table 1. Characteristics of included studies.
Author, Year, Country | Participants | Type of intervention | Target of intervention | Comparator3 | Theory mentioned in text |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
(Ahmadpanah et al., 2016), Iran | Hypertension & Depression N = 45 | Metacognitive detached mindfulness therapy (MDM) or Stress management training (SMT) | Reducing high blood pressure, depression, and anxiety | UC + | Metacognitive detached mindfulness therapy (MDM), stress management principles (SMT), systematic desensitization (Wolpe 1958) attention training techniques (ATT) (Kang, Gruber, & Gray, 2013) |
(Alexopoulos et al., 2013) United States | COPD & Depression N = 138 | Personalised intervention for depression and COPD (PID-C) | Depression, adherence to rehabilitation and treatment | UC | Theory of reasoned action (TRA) |
(Alexopoulos et al., 2016), United States | COPD & Depression N = 101 | Problem Solving-Adherence (PSA) and personalized intervention (PID-C) | Depression, adherence to rehabilitation and treatment | PID-C vs. PSA | Problem- solving therapy (PST) |
(Barker et al., 2018), Australia | MM (COPD, bronchiectasis, heart failure, coronary artery disease or ischemic heart disease and at least one other chronic condition, such as diabetes, hypertension, and cancer) N = 17 | A multimorbidity rehabilitation program (exercise and education) | Improving exercise capacity, self-management, quality of life and reducing hospitalizations | UC | Multimorbidity rehabilitation |
(Barley et al., 2014), United Kingdom | Heart Disease & Depression N = 81 | Personalised care (PC) | Improving Selfmanagement, reducing depression | UC | Self-efficacy (goal setting and action planning) |
(Beckie et al., 2011), United Kingdom | Heart Disease & Depression N = 252 | Behavior change plan (Informed by TTM) | Reducing depression | UC | Transtheoretical model (TTM) and Motivational Interviewing (MI) |
(Behnammoghadam et al., 2015), Iran | Heart Disease & Depression N = 60 | EMDR therapy | Reducing depression | UC + | EMDR therapy |
(Berkman et al., 2003) United States | Heart Disease & Depression N = 2481 | Psychoeducation and medication | Reducing depression and increasing social support | UC + | CBT, Social Learning Theory |
(Bogner & de Vries, 2008), United States | Hypertension & Depression N =64 | Integrated care | Improving adherence to medication, increase BP control, and reduce depression | UC | Theory of reasoned action (TRA) |
(Bogner & de Vries, 2010), United States | Diabetes & Depression N = 58 | Integrated care | Improve medication adherence, glycaemic control and reduce depression | UC | Theory of reasoned action (TRA) |
(Bogner et al., 2012), United States | Diabetes & Depression N = 180 | Integrated care | Improve adherence to medication, glycaemic control and depression. | UC | Theory of reasoned action (TRA) |
(Bogner et al., 2013) United States | Hypertension & Depression N =60 | Integrated care | Improve BP control and depressive symptoms. | UC | Theory of reasoned action (TRA) |
Diabetes & Depression N = 360 | Self-management support | UC + | Self-management support | ||
(Cherrington et al., 2018), United States | Improving self-management (T2DM control, exercise, diet, stress management), reducing depressive symptoms and healthcare utilization) | ||||
(Clarke et al., 2019), Australia | Diabetes & Depression N = 723 | Self-guided CBT | Improving work and social functioning (in T2DM), reducing depression | CG + Placebo control program (Healthy Lifestyles) with health and lifestyle information | CBT |
(Coventry et al., 2015), United Kingdom | MM (diabetes and/or coronary heart disease, Depression) N = 387 | Collaborative care | Reduce depressive symptoms and anxiety, increase self-management | UC | Collaborative care model, ABC model |
(de Godoy & de Godoy, 2003), Brazil | COPD & Depression N = 30 | Exercise, psychotherapy and education | Reduce depression and anxiety | CG + PT, Exercise, Education | Exercise, psychotherapy, and education |
(de Groot et al., 2019), United States | Diabetes & Depression N = 140 | Psychotherapy, exercise, and education | Reduce depression | UC or EX (Exercise only) or CBT + EX all offered the Dining with Diabetes nutrition education program | Beck’s model of cognitive therapy |
(Dejesus et al., 2009) United States | Diabetes & Hypertension N = 54 | Education and home BP selfmonitoring | Improve self-management | UC | Chronic disease model |
(Dekker et al., 2012), United States | Heart Disease & Depression N = 41 | Brief cognitive therapy | Reduce depressive symptoms and negative thinking, improve QoL | UC | Beck’s model of cognitive therapy (CT) |
(Denver et al., 2003), United Kingdom | Diabetes & Hypertension N = 120 | Nurse-led HT clinic group | Improve management of uncontrolled HT | UC | Nurse-led HT clinic group |
(Doyle et al., 2017), Australia | COPD & Depression N=110 | Telephone CBT | Reducing depression and anxiety and improving self-efficacy | UC + Active social control (befriending) | CBT, Befriending |
(Dunbar et al., 2014), United States | Diabetes & Heart Disease N = 65 | Education, counseling, selfmanagement | Self-care and selfmanagement (diet, medication, symptom monitoring, physical activity, and recognition of the interaction between self-management strategies for HF and DM) | UC + | Integrated theoretical framework to guide HF and DM self-care |
(Dunbar et al., 2014), United States | Diabetes & Heart Disease N = 134 | Integrated HF-T2DM Self-Care | Integrate and improve HF and DM self-care (diet, medications, selfmonitoring, symptoms, and PA) | UC + | Integrated theoretical framework to guide HF and DM self-care |
(Edelman et al., 2010) United States | Diabetes & Hypertension N = 239 | Self-management and medical clinic education groups | Improve self-care and selfmanagement | UC | Self-management model, Group medical clinics |
(Edelman et al., 2015), United States | Diabetes & Hypertension N = 377 | Tailored behavioral intervention | Improve self-management of comorbid T2DM and HT | UC + | Nurse led behavioral management |
(Egede et al., 2018), United States | Diabetes & Depression N = 90 | Reducing depression and anxiety and improving glycaemic control | Reducing depression and anxiety and improving glycaemic control | BAT via telemed at home vs. BAT in same room | Behavioral activation |
(Fortin et al., 2016), Canada | MM (Diabetes, cardiovascular disease, COPD, asthma, tobacco smoking, obesity, hyperlipidaemia, Prediabetes) N = 332 | Self-management support and health education | Improve chronic disease prevention and selfmanagement of multimorbidity | CG + 3 months delayed intervention | Chronic disease prevention and management (CDPM) |
(Freedland et al., 2009), United States | Heart Disease & Depression N = 123 | CBT or Supportive stress management and medication | Reducing depression and improving HF self-care after surgery | UC | Cognitive behavior therapy (CBT), Stress management |
(Freedland et al., 2015), United States | Heart Disease & Depression N = 158 | CBT and tailored education (for HF) | Reduce depression and improve self-care in HF patients | UC | CBT and tailored education (for HF) |
(Gary et al., 2010), United States | Heart Disease & Depression N = 74 | CBT, exercise, CBT and exercise | Improving physical activity, reducing depression, and enhancing quality of life | CBT + Exercise vs CBT only vs Exercise only vs. UC | CBT (Beck’s model of depression) |
(Garvey et al., 2015), Ireland | MM (two or more chronic conditions, 43 conditions identified, most common: arthritis, congestive cardiac failure, diabetes, depression and hypertension) N = 50 | Multimodal program: Fatigue management; healthy eating; maintaining physical activity, maintaining mental health; managing medications and communicating effectively with health professional | Improving activity participation, self-efficacy, self-management and quality of life | UC + Waiting list (invited to attend an OPTIMAL course following trial completion) | Adapted Stanford Chronic Disease Self-Management Program, Bandura’s model of Self efficacy |
(Glasgow et al., 2006), United States | Diabetes & Depression N = 335 | Computer-assisted Selfmanagement Intervention (focused on healthy eating and physical activity) | Improving diabetes selfmanagement (by improving healthy eating and exercise) | UC | Chronic care model selfmanagement framework, Motivational interviewing (MI) (Miller & Rollnick) |
(Hochhalter et al., 2010), United States | MM (treated for at least two of following: arthritis, lung disease, heart disease, diabetes, hypertension, depression, and osteoporosis) N = 79 | Patient engagement intervention or safety Group | Improve patients’ selfefficacy for managing multimorbidity | Group A: Intervention (Appointment - workshop + phone call) Group B: Safety (attention control - workshop + phone call) Group C: UC | Self-Determination Theory (SDT) |
(Huang et al., 2016), Taiwan | Diabetes & Depression N = 61 | Motivational enhancement therapy (MET) and CBT | Reduce depressive symptoms and increase quality of life | UC + | Theory of stress and coping (Lazarus and Folkman) modified by Miller & Rollnick’s motivational principles |
(Hynninen et al., 2010), Norway | COPD & Depression N = 51 | CBT | Reduce anxiety and depression | UC + | CBT adapted by Stanley et al.) |
(Jang et al., 2018), Korea | Heart Disease & Depression N =44 | Mindfulness-based art therapy (MBAT) | Reduce depression, trait anxiety, anger and anger expression | UC [Waiting list control (received MBAT afterwards)] | Kabat-Zinn’s mindfulness meditation (MBSR,) Monti’s Mindfulness-based art therapy (MBAT) and Selfregulation theory |
(Kasteleyn et al.,2016), Netherlands | Diabetes & Heart Disease N = 161 | Self-management support, motivational interviewing | Improve self-management, self-efficacy and wellbeing, reducing distress | UC + Attention control, 1 telephone consultation | Leventhal’s Common-Sense Model of self-regulation (CSM), Bandura’s Social Cognitive Theory, Motivational interviewing |
(Kunik et al., 2008), United States | COPD & Depression N = 238 | CBT | Reduce anxiety and depression | Education group | CBT |
(Lamers et al., 2010), Netherlands | COPD & Depression N = 187 | Minimal Psychological Intervention (MPI) | Reducing depression and anxiety, and improving quality of life | UC | CBT and self-management |
(Lamers et al., 2011), Netherlands | Diabetes & Depression N = 208 | Minimal Psychological Intervention (MPI) | Reducing depression and improving quality of life | UC | CBT and self-management |
(Landman et al.,2013), Netherlands | Diabetes & Hypertension N = 48 | Biofeedback | Lowering blood pressure | CG [visually identical device guiding users to a breathing frequency of approximately 14 breaths/ min] | Biofeedback |
(Liu et al.,2019), China | COPD & Depression N = 60 | Reduce depression and improve the quality of life | Reduce depression and improve the quality of life | UC + | Music Therapy |
(Logan et al., 2012), Canada | Diabetes & Hypertension N = 110 | Telemonitoring Self-Care Support System | Improve blood pressure control and self-care | UC | Telemonitoring Self-Care Support System |
(Logtenberg et al., 2007), Netherlands | Diabetes & Hypertension N = 30 | Device-guided breathing (Resperate) | Change in mean daytime ambulatory BP | UC + | Device-guided breathing (Resperate) |
(Long et al., 2015), China | Diabetes & Depression N = 100 | Group counseling | Reduce depression, improve treatment compliance and blood sugar control | UC + | Cognitive-behavioral group counseling, group dynamics |
(Ludman et al., 2013), United States | MM (Depression, Diabetes and/or coronary heart disease) N = 214 | TEAM care (self-management support, monitoring disease and pharmacotherapy) | Improving self-care-efficacy and confidence to maintain lifestyle changes (diet and exercise), reducing depression | UC | Collaborative care, Social Cognitive Theory, Self-management support |
(Lundgren et al., 2016), Sweden | Heart Disease & Depression N = 50 | Internet-Based Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (ICBT) | Reduce depression and anxiety and improve quality of life | CG + | CBT |
(Lutes et al., 2018), United States | Diabetes & Depression N = 139 | Collaborative care | Reducing depression and diabetes distress, improving self-care (diet, physical activity, smoking, foot care) | UC + educational materials | CBT, Problem-solving Therapy (PST), Collaborative care model |
(Lynch et al., 2014), United States | Diabetes & Hypertension N = 61 | Self-management intervention-Lifestyle Improvement through Food and Exercise (LIFE) | Improve self-management (diet, physical activity, and glycaemic control) | CG | Information processing model for food choice, self-management |
(Moral et al., 2015), Spain | MM (mean of 5 chronic conditions/patient: hypertension and diabetes -the most prevalent) N = 154 | Motivational Interviewing | To promote adherence to treatment in people treated by polypharmacy | UC | Motivational Interviewing (MI) |
(Nie et al., 2019) China | Heart Disease & Depression N = 284 | Education and lifestyle improving program (IPEL) | Reducing anxiety and depression, improving lifestyle (healthy diet, physical activity, and smoking cessation) | UC | Multicare intervention |
(Norlund et al., 2018), Sweden | Heart Disease & Depression N = 239 | Internet-Based Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (ICBT) |
Reducing depression and anxiety | TAU | CBT |
(O’Moore et al., 2018), Australia | Osteoarthritis & Depression N = 69 | ICBT Sadness Program | Reducing depression | UC | CBT |
(O’Neil et al., 2014), Australia | Heart Disease & Depression N = 121 | Reducing depression, improving self-management | Reducing depression, improving selfmanagement | UC | CBT |
(Onyechi et al., 2016), Nigeria | Diabetes & Depression N = 80 | Cognitive behavioral coaching | Reducing depression | UC | Cognitive Behavioral Coaching for Depression Manual (CBCDM) |
(Ose et al., 2019), Germany | MM (Diabetes and at least two other severe chronic comorbidities) N = 495 | Care management program | Improving self-management and self-care (diet, exercise, self-monitoring of blood glucose and foot care) | UC | Care management, Primary Care Network (PCN) |
(Parswani et al., 2013), New Zealand | Heart Disease & Depression N =30 | MBSR | Reduce anxiety and depression | TAU + health education session | Mindfulness meditation (Jon Kabat-Zinn, Segal et al.) |
(Penckofer et al., 2012), United States | Diabetes & Depression N = 74 | Psychoeducation (SWEEP program) CBT and education | Reduce depression, anxiety and anger and improve quality of life | UC + | CBT, ‘Reality Management Approach for Persons with Depression’ (Munoz et al.) |
(Pibernik-Okanovic et al., 2015), Croatia | Diabetes & Depression N = 209 | Psychoeducation, Physical exercise, enhanced UC | Reducing depression, improving diabetes distress, self-management and quality of life | Group A: CBT + Self-help manual. Group B: Exercise (same interval and duration as CBT) Group C: Enhanced treatment as usual | CBT |
Diabetes & Depression N = 291 | UC + | CBT | |||
(Piette et al., 2011), United States | Telephone-delivered CBT program | Improve management of depressive symptoms, physical activity levels, and diabetes-related outcomes | |||
(Rachmani et al., 2002), Israel | Diabetes & Hypertension N = 141 | Patient Participation Program | Improve self-management, self-monitoring, and disease control | UC | Intensive therapy, self-management |
(Renn et al., 2018), United States | COPD & Depression N=175 | Brief CBT (Psychoeducation, chronic disease selfmanagement, goal setting, behavioral activation, cognitive restructuring, relaxation, and coping with physical health symptoms) | Reduce illness intrusiveness and improve selfmanagement | EUC (enhanced usual care) | CBT |
(Richards et al., 2018), United Kingdom | Heart Disease & Depression N = 29 | EPC (enhanced psychological care) | Reduce depression and anxiety, mortality and morbidity and improve quality of life | UC | Enhanced psychological care, rehabilitation |
(Safren et al., 2014), United States | Diabetes & Depression N = 87 | Enhanced treatment as usual, CBT | Reduce depression, improve adherence and glycaemic control | UC + | CBT, Motivational interviewing (MI) |
(Salisbury et al., 2018), United Kingdom | MM (at least three types of chronic condition) N = 1546 | Patient-centred care model (3D approach) | Improve patient-cantered care, self-care, and quality of life | UC | Patient-centred care model (3D approach) |
(Schneider et al., 2016), United States | Diabetes & Depression N = 29 | Behavioral Activation and Exercise | Increasing exercise level and exercise enjoyment | Enhanced Usual Care + Depression treatment referrals were also provided. Participants received information available from the ADA on nutrition, exercise, and glucose monitoring |
Behavioral Activation (BA) |
(Shen et al., 2018), China | Heart Disease & Depression N = 60 | Psychological Intervention Program | Improving mental state, reducing stress and negative coping styles | UC | Comprehensive psychological intervention (cognitive therapy; relaxation therapy, emotional support) |
(Taveira et al., 2011), United States | Diabetes & Depression N = 88 | Psychoeducation (Pharmacist- Led Group Medical Appointments), Shared medical appointments (SMAs) | Reducing depression, improving self-care and self-care competence | UC | Psychoeducation (Pharmacist-Led Group Medical Appointments), Shared medical appointments (SMAs) |
ICBT | UC | ||||
(Turner et al., 2014), Australia | Heart Disease & Depression N = 42 | Decreasing depression, increasing self- efficacy, improve health perceptions and behavior change (physical activity, diet, medication adherence, and smoking cessation) | CBT and motivational interviewing (MI) | ||
(Wakefield et al., 2011), United States | Diabetes & Hypertension N = 302 | Home telehealth device and nurse care management | Improve self-care (diet, exercise, smoking cessation, foot care, advice for sick days, medication, weight management, preventive care) | High-intensity vs low- intensity vs UC | Care management |
(Wu et al., 2012) Australia | Heart Disease & Depression N = 30 | Peer CDSMP (self-management) | Improving knowledge, selfefficacy, and self-care behavior | UC + | Bandura’s theory of selfmanagement (Bandura, 1977, 2004) |
(Yoo et al., 2009), Korea, Republic of | Diabetes & Hypertension N = 123 | Ubiquitous Chronic Disease Care (UCDC) system (self-management) | Improving self-management | UC | Chronic Disease Care |