Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2024 Feb 28.
Published in final edited form as: Health Psychol Rev. 2023 Feb 22;18(1):165–188. doi: 10.1080/17437199.2023.2182813

Table 1. Characteristics of included studies.

Author, Year, Country Participants Type of intervention Target of intervention Comparator3 Theory mentioned in text
(Ahmadpanah et al., 2016), Iran Hypertension & Depression N = 45 Metacognitive detached mindfulness therapy (MDM) or Stress management training (SMT) Reducing high blood pressure, depression, and anxiety UC + Metacognitive detached mindfulness therapy (MDM), stress management principles (SMT), systematic desensitization (Wolpe 1958) attention training techniques (ATT) (Kang, Gruber, & Gray, 2013)
(Alexopoulos et al., 2013) United States COPD & Depression N = 138 Personalised intervention for depression and COPD (PID-C) Depression, adherence to rehabilitation and treatment UC Theory of reasoned action (TRA)
(Alexopoulos et al., 2016), United States COPD & Depression N = 101 Problem Solving-Adherence (PSA) and personalized intervention (PID-C) Depression, adherence to rehabilitation and treatment PID-C vs. PSA Problem- solving therapy (PST)
(Barker et al., 2018), Australia MM (COPD, bronchiectasis, heart failure, coronary artery disease or ischemic heart disease and at least one other chronic condition, such as diabetes, hypertension, and cancer) N = 17 A multimorbidity rehabilitation program (exercise and education) Improving exercise capacity, self-management, quality of life and reducing hospitalizations UC Multimorbidity rehabilitation
(Barley et al., 2014), United Kingdom Heart Disease & Depression N = 81 Personalised care (PC) Improving Selfmanagement, reducing depression UC Self-efficacy (goal setting and action planning)
(Beckie et al., 2011), United Kingdom Heart Disease & Depression N = 252 Behavior change plan (Informed by TTM) Reducing depression UC Transtheoretical model (TTM) and Motivational Interviewing (MI)
(Behnammoghadam et al., 2015), Iran Heart Disease & Depression N = 60 EMDR therapy Reducing depression UC + EMDR therapy
(Berkman et al., 2003) United States Heart Disease & Depression N = 2481 Psychoeducation and medication Reducing depression and increasing social support UC + CBT, Social Learning Theory
(Bogner & de Vries, 2008), United States Hypertension & Depression N =64 Integrated care Improving adherence to medication, increase BP control, and reduce depression UC Theory of reasoned action (TRA)
(Bogner & de Vries, 2010), United States Diabetes & Depression N = 58 Integrated care Improve medication adherence, glycaemic control and reduce depression UC Theory of reasoned action (TRA)
(Bogner et al., 2012), United States Diabetes & Depression N = 180 Integrated care Improve adherence to medication, glycaemic control and depression. UC Theory of reasoned action (TRA)
(Bogner et al., 2013) United States Hypertension & Depression N =60 Integrated care Improve BP control and depressive symptoms. UC Theory of reasoned action (TRA)
Diabetes & Depression N = 360 Self-management support UC + Self-management support
(Cherrington et al., 2018), United States Improving self-management (T2DM control, exercise, diet, stress management), reducing depressive symptoms and healthcare utilization)
(Clarke et al., 2019), Australia Diabetes & Depression N = 723 Self-guided CBT Improving work and social functioning (in T2DM), reducing depression CG + Placebo control program (Healthy Lifestyles) with health and lifestyle information CBT
(Coventry et al., 2015), United Kingdom MM (diabetes and/or coronary heart disease, Depression) N = 387 Collaborative care Reduce depressive symptoms and anxiety, increase self-management UC Collaborative care model, ABC model
(de Godoy & de Godoy, 2003), Brazil COPD & Depression N = 30 Exercise, psychotherapy and education Reduce depression and anxiety CG + PT, Exercise, Education Exercise, psychotherapy, and education
(de Groot et al., 2019), United States Diabetes & Depression N = 140 Psychotherapy, exercise, and education Reduce depression UC or EX (Exercise only) or CBT + EX all offered the Dining with Diabetes nutrition education program Beck’s model of cognitive therapy
(Dejesus et al., 2009) United States Diabetes & Hypertension N = 54 Education and home BP selfmonitoring Improve self-management UC Chronic disease model
(Dekker et al., 2012), United States Heart Disease & Depression N = 41 Brief cognitive therapy Reduce depressive symptoms and negative thinking, improve QoL UC Beck’s model of cognitive therapy (CT)
(Denver et al., 2003), United Kingdom Diabetes & Hypertension N = 120 Nurse-led HT clinic group Improve management of uncontrolled HT UC Nurse-led HT clinic group
(Doyle et al., 2017), Australia COPD & Depression N=110 Telephone CBT Reducing depression and anxiety and improving self-efficacy UC + Active social control (befriending) CBT, Befriending
(Dunbar et al., 2014), United States Diabetes & Heart Disease N = 65 Education, counseling, selfmanagement Self-care and selfmanagement (diet, medication, symptom monitoring, physical activity, and recognition of the interaction between self-management strategies for HF and DM) UC + Integrated theoretical framework to guide HF and DM self-care
(Dunbar et al., 2014), United States Diabetes & Heart Disease N = 134 Integrated HF-T2DM Self-Care Integrate and improve HF and DM self-care (diet, medications, selfmonitoring, symptoms, and PA) UC + Integrated theoretical framework to guide HF and DM self-care
(Edelman et al., 2010) United States Diabetes & Hypertension N = 239 Self-management and medical clinic education groups Improve self-care and selfmanagement UC Self-management model, Group medical clinics
(Edelman et al., 2015), United States Diabetes & Hypertension N = 377 Tailored behavioral intervention Improve self-management of comorbid T2DM and HT UC + Nurse led behavioral management
(Egede et al., 2018), United States Diabetes & Depression N = 90 Reducing depression and anxiety and improving glycaemic control Reducing depression and anxiety and improving glycaemic control BAT via telemed at home vs. BAT in same room Behavioral activation
(Fortin et al., 2016), Canada MM (Diabetes, cardiovascular disease, COPD, asthma, tobacco smoking, obesity, hyperlipidaemia, Prediabetes) N = 332 Self-management support and health education Improve chronic disease prevention and selfmanagement of multimorbidity CG + 3 months delayed intervention Chronic disease prevention and management (CDPM)
(Freedland et al., 2009), United States Heart Disease & Depression N = 123 CBT or Supportive stress management and medication Reducing depression and improving HF self-care after surgery UC Cognitive behavior therapy (CBT), Stress management
(Freedland et al., 2015), United States Heart Disease & Depression N = 158 CBT and tailored education (for HF) Reduce depression and improve self-care in HF patients UC CBT and tailored education (for HF)
(Gary et al., 2010), United States Heart Disease & Depression N = 74 CBT, exercise, CBT and exercise Improving physical activity, reducing depression, and enhancing quality of life CBT + Exercise vs CBT only vs Exercise only vs. UC CBT (Beck’s model of depression)
(Garvey et al., 2015), Ireland MM (two or more chronic conditions, 43 conditions identified, most common: arthritis, congestive cardiac failure, diabetes, depression and hypertension) N = 50 Multimodal program: Fatigue management; healthy eating; maintaining physical activity, maintaining mental health; managing medications and communicating effectively with health professional Improving activity participation, self-efficacy, self-management and quality of life UC + Waiting list (invited to attend an OPTIMAL course following trial completion) Adapted Stanford Chronic Disease Self-Management Program, Bandura’s model of Self efficacy
(Glasgow et al., 2006), United States Diabetes & Depression N = 335 Computer-assisted Selfmanagement Intervention (focused on healthy eating and physical activity) Improving diabetes selfmanagement (by improving healthy eating and exercise) UC Chronic care model selfmanagement framework, Motivational interviewing (MI) (Miller & Rollnick)
(Hochhalter et al., 2010), United States MM (treated for at least two of following: arthritis, lung disease, heart disease, diabetes, hypertension, depression, and osteoporosis) N = 79 Patient engagement intervention or safety Group Improve patients’ selfefficacy for managing multimorbidity Group A: Intervention (Appointment - workshop + phone call) Group B: Safety (attention control - workshop + phone call) Group C: UC Self-Determination Theory (SDT)
(Huang et al., 2016), Taiwan Diabetes & Depression N = 61 Motivational enhancement therapy (MET) and CBT Reduce depressive symptoms and increase quality of life UC + Theory of stress and coping (Lazarus and Folkman) modified by Miller & Rollnick’s motivational principles
(Hynninen et al., 2010), Norway COPD & Depression N = 51 CBT Reduce anxiety and depression UC + CBT adapted by Stanley et al.)
(Jang et al., 2018), Korea Heart Disease & Depression N =44 Mindfulness-based art therapy (MBAT) Reduce depression, trait anxiety, anger and anger expression UC [Waiting list control (received MBAT afterwards)] Kabat-Zinn’s mindfulness meditation (MBSR,) Monti’s Mindfulness-based art therapy (MBAT) and Selfregulation theory
(Kasteleyn et al.,2016), Netherlands Diabetes & Heart Disease N = 161 Self-management support, motivational interviewing Improve self-management, self-efficacy and wellbeing, reducing distress UC + Attention control, 1 telephone consultation Leventhal’s Common-Sense Model of self-regulation (CSM), Bandura’s Social Cognitive Theory, Motivational interviewing
(Kunik et al., 2008), United States COPD & Depression N = 238 CBT Reduce anxiety and depression Education group CBT
(Lamers et al., 2010), Netherlands COPD & Depression N = 187 Minimal Psychological Intervention (MPI) Reducing depression and anxiety, and improving quality of life UC CBT and self-management
(Lamers et al., 2011), Netherlands Diabetes & Depression N = 208 Minimal Psychological Intervention (MPI) Reducing depression and improving quality of life UC CBT and self-management
(Landman et al.,2013), Netherlands Diabetes & Hypertension N = 48 Biofeedback Lowering blood pressure CG [visually identical device guiding users to a breathing frequency of approximately 14 breaths/ min] Biofeedback
(Liu et al.,2019), China COPD & Depression N = 60 Reduce depression and improve the quality of life Reduce depression and improve the quality of life UC + Music Therapy
(Logan et al., 2012), Canada Diabetes & Hypertension N = 110 Telemonitoring Self-Care Support System Improve blood pressure control and self-care UC Telemonitoring Self-Care Support System
(Logtenberg et al., 2007), Netherlands Diabetes & Hypertension N = 30 Device-guided breathing (Resperate) Change in mean daytime ambulatory BP UC + Device-guided breathing (Resperate)
(Long et al., 2015), China Diabetes & Depression N = 100 Group counseling Reduce depression, improve treatment compliance and blood sugar control UC + Cognitive-behavioral group counseling, group dynamics
(Ludman et al., 2013), United States MM (Depression, Diabetes and/or coronary heart disease) N = 214 TEAM care (self-management support, monitoring disease and pharmacotherapy) Improving self-care-efficacy and confidence to maintain lifestyle changes (diet and exercise), reducing depression UC Collaborative care, Social Cognitive Theory, Self-management support
(Lundgren et al., 2016), Sweden Heart Disease & Depression N = 50 Internet-Based Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (ICBT) Reduce depression and anxiety and improve quality of life CG + CBT
(Lutes et al., 2018), United States Diabetes & Depression N = 139 Collaborative care Reducing depression and diabetes distress, improving self-care (diet, physical activity, smoking, foot care) UC + educational materials CBT, Problem-solving Therapy (PST), Collaborative care model
(Lynch et al., 2014), United States Diabetes & Hypertension N = 61 Self-management intervention-Lifestyle Improvement through Food and Exercise (LIFE) Improve self-management (diet, physical activity, and glycaemic control) CG Information processing model for food choice, self-management
(Moral et al., 2015), Spain MM (mean of 5 chronic conditions/patient: hypertension and diabetes -the most prevalent) N = 154 Motivational Interviewing To promote adherence to treatment in people treated by polypharmacy UC Motivational Interviewing (MI)
(Nie et al., 2019) China Heart Disease & Depression N = 284 Education and lifestyle improving program (IPEL) Reducing anxiety and depression, improving lifestyle (healthy diet, physical activity, and smoking cessation) UC Multicare intervention
(Norlund et al., 2018), Sweden Heart Disease & Depression N = 239 Internet-Based Cognitive
Behavioral Therapy (ICBT)
Reducing depression and anxiety TAU CBT
(O’Moore et al., 2018), Australia Osteoarthritis & Depression N = 69 ICBT Sadness Program Reducing depression UC CBT
(O’Neil et al., 2014), Australia Heart Disease & Depression N = 121 Reducing depression, improving self-management Reducing depression, improving selfmanagement UC CBT
(Onyechi et al., 2016), Nigeria Diabetes & Depression N = 80 Cognitive behavioral coaching Reducing depression UC Cognitive Behavioral Coaching for Depression Manual (CBCDM)
(Ose et al., 2019), Germany MM (Diabetes and at least two other severe chronic comorbidities) N = 495 Care management program Improving self-management and self-care (diet, exercise, self-monitoring of blood glucose and foot care) UC Care management, Primary Care Network (PCN)
(Parswani et al., 2013), New Zealand Heart Disease & Depression N =30 MBSR Reduce anxiety and depression TAU + health education session Mindfulness meditation (Jon Kabat-Zinn, Segal et al.)
(Penckofer et al., 2012), United States Diabetes & Depression N = 74 Psychoeducation (SWEEP program) CBT and education Reduce depression, anxiety and anger and improve quality of life UC + CBT, ‘Reality Management Approach for Persons with Depression’ (Munoz et al.)
(Pibernik-Okanovic et al., 2015), Croatia Diabetes & Depression N = 209 Psychoeducation, Physical exercise, enhanced UC Reducing depression, improving diabetes distress, self-management and quality of life Group A: CBT + Self-help manual. Group B: Exercise (same interval and duration as CBT) Group C: Enhanced treatment as usual CBT
Diabetes & Depression N = 291 UC + CBT
(Piette et al., 2011), United States Telephone-delivered CBT program Improve management of depressive symptoms, physical activity levels, and diabetes-related outcomes
(Rachmani et al., 2002), Israel Diabetes & Hypertension N = 141 Patient Participation Program Improve self-management, self-monitoring, and disease control UC Intensive therapy, self-management
(Renn et al., 2018), United States COPD & Depression N=175 Brief CBT (Psychoeducation, chronic disease selfmanagement, goal setting, behavioral activation, cognitive restructuring, relaxation, and coping with physical health symptoms) Reduce illness intrusiveness and improve selfmanagement EUC (enhanced usual care) CBT
(Richards et al., 2018), United Kingdom Heart Disease & Depression N = 29 EPC (enhanced psychological care) Reduce depression and anxiety, mortality and morbidity and improve quality of life UC Enhanced psychological care, rehabilitation
(Safren et al., 2014), United States Diabetes & Depression N = 87 Enhanced treatment as usual, CBT Reduce depression, improve adherence and glycaemic control UC + CBT, Motivational interviewing (MI)
(Salisbury et al., 2018), United Kingdom MM (at least three types of chronic condition) N = 1546 Patient-centred care model (3D approach) Improve patient-cantered care, self-care, and quality of life UC Patient-centred care model (3D approach)
(Schneider et al., 2016), United States Diabetes & Depression N = 29 Behavioral Activation and Exercise Increasing exercise level and exercise enjoyment Enhanced Usual Care +
Depression treatment referrals were also provided. Participants received information available from the ADA on nutrition, exercise, and glucose monitoring
Behavioral Activation (BA)
(Shen et al., 2018), China Heart Disease & Depression N = 60 Psychological Intervention Program Improving mental state, reducing stress and negative coping styles UC Comprehensive psychological intervention (cognitive therapy; relaxation therapy, emotional support)
(Taveira et al., 2011), United States Diabetes & Depression N = 88 Psychoeducation (Pharmacist- Led Group Medical Appointments), Shared medical appointments (SMAs) Reducing depression, improving self-care and self-care competence UC Psychoeducation (Pharmacist-Led Group Medical Appointments), Shared medical appointments (SMAs)
ICBT UC
(Turner et al., 2014), Australia Heart Disease & Depression N = 42 Decreasing depression, increasing self- efficacy, improve health perceptions and behavior change (physical activity, diet, medication adherence, and smoking cessation) CBT and motivational interviewing (MI)
(Wakefield et al., 2011), United States Diabetes & Hypertension N = 302 Home telehealth device and nurse care management Improve self-care (diet, exercise, smoking cessation, foot care, advice for sick days, medication, weight management, preventive care) High-intensity vs low- intensity vs UC Care management
(Wu et al., 2012) Australia Heart Disease & Depression N = 30 Peer CDSMP (self-management) Improving knowledge, selfefficacy, and self-care behavior UC + Bandura’s theory of selfmanagement (Bandura, 1977, 2004)
(Yoo et al., 2009), Korea, Republic of Diabetes & Hypertension N = 123 Ubiquitous Chronic Disease Care (UCDC) system (self-management) Improving self-management UC Chronic Disease Care